2023 mid-season rookie draft | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2023 mid-season rookie draft

Herald Sun's mock MSD draft

1 Ryan Maric - West Coast
2 James Trezise - North
3 Ethan Stanley - Hawthorn
4 Jack Buller - Richmond
5 Clay Tucker - GWS
6 Oscar McDonald - Sydney
7 Sam Naismith - Geelong
8 Robert Hansen Jr - Freo
9 Jayden Hunter - Essendon
10 Marty Hore - Dogs
11 Noah Casalini - Port
12 Brandon Ryan - Hawthorn
13 Rye Penny - Richmond
14 Pass - GWS
15 Harry Arnold - Swans


(MSD) Rye Penny​

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
are there any phantom drafts out there? i couldn't find one
Herald sun said we will get Buller with our first pick and Rye Penny with our second. Penny is a bit random, we certainly don’t need another mid sized defender
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Is Shaun Mannagh a chance of being picked up. Think he would be a good option as a small forward. 25, and his stats are outstanding for a small forward.

Averaging 27 touches, 6.5 tackles and 2.75 scoring shots per game.

YES YES YES!!! See below for earlier post Posh.

Not a lot of talk about him, but he's number 1 on Leysy's list.


Couple more names. Sam Lowson will be a great story if gets his chance. Been through a lot.

Unfortunately, a bit old now you'd think - 28 this year.

The one Leysy is keenest on (In Vic anyway as across them more) is Shaun Mannagh from Werribee.

Some might remember him from our VFL side back when Fly was coaching. Went back to Ovens and Murray and dominated a very strong comp before heading to Werribee where he is a star. Sill only 25.

Quick, skilled, fit, strong, wins own ball and is clean. Still improving and gets the most out of himself.

He has a game that could translate to AFL and moreso at our club playing that small forward that pushes up and down the ground.

His height (175cm) probably the main reason hasn't been drafted yet.

But we love a midget (or used to). About time we went back to that mantra.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users

James Trezise can’t quite believe his rise in the VFL this year.
Adam Oxley can believe it.

Former Collingwood wingman Oxley played in a premiership with Trezise at West Gippsland club Tooradin-Dalmore last season and formed the view the 20-year-old belonged at a higher level.

As it was, a Tooradin-Dalmore connection to Richmond VFL took him to Tigerland.

Former Brisbane Lions rookie Blake Grewar, who also figured in the flag last year, had played with the VFL Tigers and, through coach Steve Morris, recommended they invite Trezise to pre-season training.

They did.

He made the list.

And he has since emerged as one of the state league’s most exciting prospects.


After being asked by the AFL to present for a medical, Trezise is even considered a chance for next Wednesday’s AFL mid-season draft.

“I didn’t expect anything like this,’’ he says.

“I was stressing out that I wouldn’t even sign a contract, that they wouldn’t offer me one.

“After that, everything has caught me by surprise.

“After signing, it was all about just trying to get a game, and once that happened I just wanted to stay in the side.’’

The 188cm Trezise has played every game for the Tigers.

After his performance against Carlton, when he had 16 possessions, four marks and gunned a goal from outside 50m, Morris called him a “super exciting player’’.

“The X-factor that he has was on show in and around the footy, and kicked a beautiful goal from long range in the first quarter,’’ Morris told the club website.

James Trezise has quickly made a big impression in his first VFL season. Picture: Supplied

James Trezise has quickly made a big impression in his first VFL season. Picture: Supplied
Trezise’s stand-out effort came in Round 8 against Geelong, when he had 29 disposals and collected 10 marks.

It led to more lift-off from Morris.

“Best game for the year for James. He’s been improving each week, but I thought he was fantastic defensively,’’ the coach said. “He’s an extremely good one-versus-one player and won the ball back a number of times for us.’’

Trezise was taken aback when he received an email from AFL high-performance manager Paul Sealy about the medical.

He is surprised recruiters have noticed him.

“Bit shocked, to be honest. I’ve only played the eight games of VFL footy,’’ he says. “Now people are saying, ‘You could be a chance’.’’

Trezise, a business and marketing student at Swinburne University, came out of the strong Berwick Junior Football Club.

He made two interleague teams but none of the Dandenong Stingrays programs.

The Covid pandemic meant Trezise didn’t get on the park much in 2020 or 2021. Picture: Supplied

The Covid pandemic meant Trezise didn’t get on the park much in 2020 or 2021. Picture: Supplied
After joining Tooradin-Dalmore to play in the under 18s and impressing enough to make the West Gippsland under-age side, Trezise was promoted for a senior debut in 2019.

But he played no football in 2020 because of Covid and had 10 games in 2021 before the pandemic killed off the season.

Last year, then, was his first full season in senior company.

The left-footer kicked 26 goals, had eight mentions in the best and helped Tooradin-Dalmore to its first senior premiership in 25 years. He played in the forward line and had a run in the ruck.

Adam Oxley played 34 AFL games for Collingwood before linking up with Tooradin-Dalmore. Picture: AAP Image/Julian Smith

Adam Oxley played 34 AFL games for Collingwood before linking up with Tooradin-Dalmore. Picture: AAP Image/Julian Smith
Whatever his position, he took the eye of Oxley.

“I’m in my third year at Tooradin and from my first few weeks there I could see there was something special about him,’’ Oxley tells CODE Sports.

“He put on a bit of size last year and he’s always been super-athletic with a vertical leap as good as I’ve ever seen. The main thing that jumped out at me was his defensive skills. He loves tackling, and his tackles stick like a vice.

“The longer last year went on he gained more and more confidence and won us a lot of games off his own boot. He played everywhere too. That’s another string to his bow, his versatility. He’s a good forward, he can play a bit of wing. I see Richmond have chucked him back and he’s even gone in the ruck.’’

What is his best position?

Oxley thinks he’s a “natural forward with his cat-like reflexes and his hangers’’.

“But I could easily see him being a half-back flanker, taking plenty of intercept marks and kicking the ball well, because his kicking is amazing,’’ he says.

“You could call him the ultimate swingman.’’

Oxley is enjoying watching Trezise make his mark at Punt Rd, noting his “trajectory is trending in the right direction’’.

He says it’s not silly to think Trezise could play an AFL game later in the season if he’s selected in the mid-season draft.

“If a club has a few injuries, he could slide in, just because of that utility style he shows.’’


Trezise appreciates Tooradin-Dalmore’s part in his jump to the VFL.

Last year he played alongside not only Oxley and Grewar, but AFL premiership Magpie Brent Macaffer and ex-Richmond rookie Piva Wright.

He says they all gave him a lot of advice and encouragement, and supported him trying to go to the VFL, as did coach Lachie Gillespie.

Similarly, he says Morris and the other Richmond coaching staff have backed him at every turn.

In Trezise’s absence, Tooradin-Dalmore has named an award after him this season.

The defensive player of the week is given ‘The Jimmy Award’.

“I don’t even know if anyone has told him yet,’’ Oxley says.

James Trezise might not believe it anyway.

Richmond VFL operations manager and recruiting office Oliver Grant on James Trezise

‘Jim’s become a much-loved member of the group since joining our program. His investment in football and subsequent development has been exponential and we are very proud of the position he now finds himself in. He’s an exciting player and a terrific young man.’’


‘Jim’s become a much-loved member of the group since joining our program. His investment in football and subsequent development has been exponential and we are very proud of the position he now finds himself in. He’s an exciting player and a terrific young man.’’
A Matty Parker clone?
 
Herald Sun's mock MSD draft

1 Ryan Maric - West Coast
2 James Trezise - North
3 Ethan Stanley - Hawthorn
4 Jack Buller - Richmond
5 Clay Tucker - GWS
6 Oscar McDonald - Sydney
7 Sam Naismith - Geelong
8 Robert Hansen Jr - Freo
9 Jayden Hunter - Essendon
10 Marty Hore - Dogs
11 Noah Casalini - Port
12 Brandon Ryan - Hawthorn
13 Rye Penny - Richmond
14 Pass - GWS
15 Harry Arnold - Swans


(MSD) Rye Penny​

Penny keeps missing targets by hand and by foot
Not another HB
if we go tall forward with first pick we need best small forward with second
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Key forward is his role in the Lynch style. We are desperate to fill that role. 22-year-old who fits in our list profile.
He's a worker, that adds to his value. My biggest query with Buller is identifying his greatest weapon, I wouldn't say pack marking, I wouldn't say leading patterns as he doesn't appear to be explosive off the mark, I also wouldn't say leap or elite conversion. It's an almost package, maybe a 35 goal Mihocek, I suppose that is possible. I guess the biggest bonus is we won't require 3-4 years of physical development, a quick decision can be made. If we go down this path then we'll need to focus on other areas with these late picks with any subsequent drafts. I think the three B's in Bauer, Bradtke & Buller is more than enough speculating on tall forwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
Still keen on Buller. Size and strength wise ready to go. Fills a glaring need.

Can ruck as well. 22 touches, 14 marks, 4 goals, 8 hitous. Plays like a brute.

No brainer, but we might miss at pick 4.
 
He's a worker, that adds to his value. My biggest query with Buller is identifying his greatest weapon, I wouldn't say pack marking, I wouldn't say leading patterns as he doesn't appear to be explosive off the mark, I also wouldn't say leap or elite conversion. It's an almost package, maybe a 35 goal Mihocek, I suppose that is possible. I guess the biggest bonus is we won't require 3-4 years of physical development, a quick decision can be made. If we go down this path then we'll need to focus on other areas with these late picks with any subsequent drafts. I think the three B's in Bauer, Bradtke & Buller is more than enough speculating on tall forwards.
That's who he reminds me of but I think he might be better. Mihoeck is a very handy footballer that would walk into every side in the comp.

I like the rucking component as well. There's a bit of Oscar Allen to Buller as well. I think he's worth the punt. If we fail trying to fill the biggest hole on the list so be it. Not fussed about what draft it is. And the mid-season draft is so new, Buller is worth the go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
"Pick 4, Richmond"

"player number 237639......Riley Collier Dawkins"
 
  • Wow
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Buller was a defender as a junior, for sure we will get him and then play him down in the backline
 
  • Haha
  • Sad
Reactions: 2 users
Still keen on Buller. Size and strength wise ready to go. Fills a glaring need.

Can ruck as well. 22 touches, 14 marks, 4 goals, 8 hitous. Plays like a brute.


Thanks for sharing the highlights - I know it's a small sample size, but I likes what I sees. Runs through the forward line like he owns it. Tackles chumps like they owe him money. Works up the ground because you gotta spend your petrol tickets on something. Has swagger.

Would not be disappointed if we snaffled him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Time to make amends for the JVR snub.
Could balance out if we pick up a promising tall forward.
Personally I’d take two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Is there anyone in the list of likelies that can take a consistent overhead and pack mark? Really need someone in our forward line that does that.
 
He's a worker, that adds to his value. My biggest query with Buller is identifying his greatest weapon, I wouldn't say pack marking, I wouldn't say leading patterns as he doesn't appear to be explosive off the mark, I also wouldn't say leap or elite conversion. It's an almost package, maybe a 35 goal Mihocek, I suppose that is possible. I guess the biggest bonus is we won't require 3-4 years of physical development, a quick decision can be made. If we go down this path then we'll need to focus on other areas with these late picks with any subsequent drafts. I think the three B's in Bauer, Bradtke & Buller is more than enough speculating on tall forwards.
Bully who would you take between him and Hunter ?.
 
Herald Sun's mock MSD draft

1 Ryan Maric - West Coast
2 James Trezise - North
3 Ethan Stanley - Hawthorn
4 Jack Buller - Richmond
5 Clay Tucker - GWS
6 Oscar McDonald - Sydney
7 Sam Naismith - Geelong
8 Robert Hansen Jr - Freo
9 Jayden Hunter - Essendon
10 Marty Hore - Dogs
11 Noah Casalini - Port
12 Brandon Ryan - Hawthorn
13 Rye Penny - Richmond
14 Pass - GWS
15 Harry Arnold - Swans


(MSD) Rye Penny​


Did I hear Bower??