What would we know? Its voted by the players so obviously he offers something.Columbo said:Edwards shouldn't be in there. Nice bloke, nice player, not leadership material. Sounds like a popularity contest.
What would we know? Its voted by the players so obviously he offers something.Columbo said:Edwards shouldn't be in there. Nice bloke, nice player, not leadership material. Sounds like a popularity contest.
bigwow said:Maybe Jack doesn't want to part of the leadership group. Can still be a leader without a label.
IanG said:Still a mystery, why didn't they vote for him?
Columbo said:Edwards shouldn't be in there. Nice bloke, nice player, not leadership material. Sounds like a popularity contest.
zgod said:What would we know? Its voted by the players so obviously he offers something.
Columbo said:Edwards shouldn't be in there. Nice bloke, nice player, not leadership material. Sounds like a popularity contest.
The final aside, did you see how much better the team played when Sheds was in it as opposed to when he wasn't? His absence after he broke his leg against Carlton could have been the difference between us making top 4 and missing out. Sheds would be among the first 5 picked every week and those others you name are well behind him. He's also replacing Morris. I guess you missed the GWS game, which was pretty much won by Sheds' goal from outside 60, he also kicked the goal that put us ahead and we went on with it from there. I haven't seen him lose his footing all that often either. Probably got the quickest hands and one of the fastest minds in the side, too.Tigaman said:I am not a fan of Sheds due to his mediocre performance over the years at Tigerland. To be in a leadership group of an elite sporting club you have to have the form on the board & Sheds does not have that as his stats show.
I am of the opinion Sheds will struggle to get a game this year with Lennon, Lambert, McIntosh panting down his back. Tigers have to move on from players like Sheds who cannot stay on their feet when it is in close. As for Jack he has enough to do without being in the leadership group. To get a kick he has gotta work his butt off, due to those in front & around him . With Rance, Houli ,Sheds pushing their barrows all we need now is a Bhuddist Monk to strip for us.
sorry don't agree at all.lamb22 said:Pros Chaplin and Morris out.
Cons Jack not in (not captain actually)
I think the Edwards selection is good in that I think it will help his game. He has added resilience and composure over the last 2 or 3 years and this should help his mindset in that regard.
Jack and Rance are the spiritual leaders out there.
Lids shouldn't be in there but if he was dropped it probably wouldn't do him or us any favours , especially in media land.
lamb22 said:......
Jack and Rance are the spiritual leaders out there.
Lids shouldn't be in there but if he was dropped it probably wouldn't do him or us any favours , especially in media land.
WesternTiger said:Love how average joe supporter knows who and who shouldn't be in the leadership group! :hihi