Welcome to the Tigers Nathan Broad | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Welcome to the Tigers Nathan Broad

MD Jazz said:
Was awful most of the game, looks like a different player. No confidence, should be dropped for 3 shockers in a row.

Try looking at the bigger picture a bit. He’s an integral part of our back 6/7 that gets the job done week in and week out.

Why would you change it?
 
Our weakest link over the last few games by a long way

Getting carried by the rest of the backline

On very very thin ice
 
Has done a decent defensive job but his numbers have been poor. It will all come down to whether we want his negating or Brando’s run.
 
22nd Man said:
two cups.
You're not suggestion Broady would go back to back and get photos of one girl and two cups are you?
 
Sintiger said:
Has done a decent defensive job but his numbers have been poor. It will all come down to whether we want his negating or Brando’s run.

I reckon we have looked really unbalanced playing Ellis. Too many defenders and too many running defenders. The balance was a lot better last night.
 
Gee Mike Sheehan trying to hang Broad for shirking a contest( ducking )?

Was that on the wing?

Trying to remember it.

Shhh. Broady is a pretty tough ombré.

Sheehan has become irrelevant.
 
Yeah there was a high ball on the members wing just near the interchanges where broady didn’t go hard. Was a genuine moment of hesitance - call it a shirk.

Maybe a sign he’s lacking a bit of confidence
 
Sintiger said:
Has done a decent defensive job but his numbers have been poor. It will all come down to whether we want his negating or Brando’s run.
In last year's finals, Broad mixed it with the likes of Patton and Hawkins, and I think he helped curb Lynch from the Crows. That's what we need, especially if Rance or Astbury fall over in a match. Ellis's role can be absorbed by the system.
 
Nomorewaiting said:
Gee Mike Sheehan trying to hang Broad for shirking a contest( ducking )?

Was that on the wing?

Trying to remember it.

Shhh. Broady is a pretty tough ombré.

Sheehan has become irrelevant.

Yes, Brayshaw said 'he was unaware of his surrounds', but Hodgey gave him the all clear.
 
Watched the GF replay again in the bye weekend and Broady was just great.
During this year we really missed him when he was out of the side.
But he's dropped off a bit in recent times and not looking as certain.
And it's not the best time to be struggling a bit for form.
 
wayne said:
Yes, Brayshaw said 'he was unaware of his surrounds', but Hodgey gave him the all clear.

I was at the game and it looked bad. May have something to do with low confidence levels. I still want him in our back half
 
If you're looking for someone to drop, I'd probably drop Broad. Not a big deal but he's probably our weakest link.

Bobble could do his job fine and give us more attack off half back.
 
It was broady who kept AA gunston from having any impact at all

Wasnt it?
 
wayne said:
Yes, Brayshaw said 'he was unaware of his surrounds', but Hodgey gave him the all clear.

That was pretty poor but I think Broad has lost a lot of confidence since coming back from injury. Still he did help to make Breust and Gunston totally ineffectual.