We're a better side with Hopper in. But.
When he and Taranto join forces in our midfield it's too much about their old ways and not enough about getting each of them to gain understanding of the other mids - Shai, Martin, Short, Dion, Cotchin, Graham.
This stuff takes time. And Hopper's month long absence might speed this up.
Last week we scrapped a mediocre win against a side that opened with a midfield of Bruhn, Atkins and Holmes. A Fitzroy class midfield. We should have flogged them by ten goals if we were in any kind of form. We can be frank with ourselves - we will miss Hopper. But our midfield synergy is not right yet. Maybe breaking up the old pair for a few weeks will help us a little with this.
Sure. Ruck defence will help. We miss Nankervis hopelessly and will profit from his return if only so he can stop the horrendous bleeding. At one stage last week against Fitzroy we were 1-7 for CB clearance based largely on ruck rout. But also on lack of understanding of who will be where and when. It's not like we were sharking anything. Our formations looked *smile*.
As much as we need Hopper we need more synergy in the middle. Better understanding.