Ok fair enough, I wonder if that's altered when they changed the interpretation in season.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Umpires
- Thread starter zippadeee
- Start date
Ok fair enough, I wonder if that's altered when they changed the interpretation in season.
If all the frees being called for above were paid then we would saying too many frees being paid, umpires should let the game flow.
I don't think anyone's asking for more frees to be paid, more consistency and a clear directive is what is being asked. Some of the one's that are being paid shouldn't be and some that aren't should be.
Then they certainly aren't using that now. The Soldo one and Castagna ones on Friday night I can't understand how either could be paid HTB.
The ones that really annoy me, and the ones where the player just lays the ball on the ground and uses their body as a shield (ala rugby union) and allow another player to pick the ball up.
I'll ask for more frees to be paid, because when you pick and choose which frees are paid you must be inconsistent.
If they were more consistent then there would be more frees, at least for a little while until everyone adjusts.
The holding the ball rule is currently a farce. It was much clearer back in the bad old days when lots more frees were paid. They need to be a lot more consistent with prior opportunity because at the moment it seems to be prior lottery.
DS
If they were more consistent then there would be more frees, at least for a little while until everyone adjusts.
The holding the ball rule is currently a farce. It was much clearer back in the bad old days when lots more frees were paid. They need to be a lot more consistent with prior opportunity because at the moment it seems to be prior lottery.
DS
Steps as in stages or 3 physical steps? Chamberlain on the radio last week was saying prior opportunity can take many forms. If you take long enough after a mark/free kick for the umpire to call play on then that’s your prior. Same as feigning a handball.
Treloar got pinged for THROWING
Fantastic job by the umpires this week
Did Eddie forget to make the “donation “
This week?
Dustin Martin gets the whistle blown against him the micro-second after a tackle has caused him to miss kick or miss his handball. They love pinging No 4 at Richmond. It’s gotta be we are mouthy on the field or they just hate our colours subconsciously
Join the dots kids.
Lyold (Carlton) rings his brother Matty.
SL. "Hey Matty, do us a favour"
ML "Whats going on?"
SL "Have a go at the umpires on the 45 shows your on"
ML "Why?"
SL "Show some footage of Cripps getting held and pushed without the ball, ok"
ML "How about Dusty getting slapped every week?"
SL ""'*^"*K him, they don't pay me"
ML. " You owe me"
Lyold (Carlton) rings his brother Matty.
SL. "Hey Matty, do us a favour"
ML "Whats going on?"
SL "Have a go at the umpires on the 45 shows your on"
ML "Why?"
SL "Show some footage of Cripps getting held and pushed without the ball, ok"
ML "How about Dusty getting slapped every week?"
SL ""'*^"*K him, they don't pay me"
ML. " You owe me"
When 'release the gesh' was doing the job he was always front and centre explaining certain decisions and different changes they were doing. Where's the umpires boss these days??
Why aren't coaches alowed to highlight mistakes?
Every occupation comes with stress and criticism, why are they protected?
They get paid really well these days. If they can't handle it there would be another 100 umpires that could do it. Don't cover/shield them, they should be open to criticism like everyone else.
Good on Clarkson and Hinkley they can't hold it any more, why because this is the Worse group of umpires ive seen in over 45 year's of watching this game.
Bias, team barrackers, influenced by external people, they love the limelight.
They will drive people away from the game.
They have just tooo much influence on the game these days, its a joke.
The ruck rule needs to change unless the ruckman is assaulted, no Ruckman should be given a free kick. Holding, blocking, farting its all crap.
Why aren't coaches alowed to highlight mistakes?
Every occupation comes with stress and criticism, why are they protected?
They get paid really well these days. If they can't handle it there would be another 100 umpires that could do it. Don't cover/shield them, they should be open to criticism like everyone else.
Good on Clarkson and Hinkley they can't hold it any more, why because this is the Worse group of umpires ive seen in over 45 year's of watching this game.
Bias, team barrackers, influenced by external people, they love the limelight.
They will drive people away from the game.
They have just tooo much influence on the game these days, its a joke.
The ruck rule needs to change unless the ruckman is assaulted, no Ruckman should be given a free kick. Holding, blocking, farting its all crap.
Abso-f'n-lutly!!!!!! There were wide shots of bonces/ball-ups from Friday's game, that clearly showed a GWS player standing right behind Dusty, like they were in a Tokyo rush hour train, elbows and forearms pushing him along, effectively tunnelling him right under the ball, how the *smile* can that not be seen?
It helps when your brother is in the media.
When his brother was at freo, Lloyd was silent.
Now that he is at Carlton, lloyd is complementary of everything happening at princess park.
We need Michael Warner on main stream TV. He will destroy them
<
Tigers on the verge of breaking another team .......................
|
Footy Hub Life - What do you miss most?
>
