-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Trent Cotchin (Merged)
- Thread starter Gordietiger
- Start date
jb03 said:
Went for the ball, low and hard, incidental. Delayed concussion two *smile* quarters later! We might as well bring in a new rule for delayed concussion 2 weeks later and suspend a player.
TigerForce said:
Went for the ball, low and hard, incidental. Delayed concussion two *smile*ing quarters later! We might as well bring in a new rule for delayed concussion 2 weeks later and suspend a player.
That's after the contact. Shoulder / head. He won't get outed but he aimed to hurt.
Shiel copped another big hit from Astbury later in 1st quarter, that may very well have triggered the delayed concussion.
Reckon Cotchin gets off.
Reckon Cotchin gets off.
Saw it at the ground in real time and thought nothing of it....except that it was a contest between two players for a loose ball and Cotch just went harder at it. Saw the replay after getting home....looked at it a few times and came away with same view...ie, hard contested ball get...both players going for the same ball....one just went harder at it. Surely there is nothing to answer to here.
It'll be a pretty tough MRP that rubs a captain out of a Grand Final over an incident like that. Round 6, perhaps. Grand Final, YEAH NAH.
Giardiasis said:
On the money. This year is as good or better than his Brownlow year. And on the two factors mentioned by G. I say he is a better more valuable player now.
Shiel got hit multiple times high in the first quarter. Biggest one was from Astbury. Set Dylan S back on his heals big time. I reckon that was just as likely to have caused the delayed concussion.
What a captains game!! Just brilliant!!
That bump. Happened right in front of me. The first thing Shiel did was grab his shoulder. His head was fine.
It was his shoulder that copped the brunt of it.
Cotchin has no case to answer.
That bump. Happened right in front of me. The first thing Shiel did was grab his shoulder. His head was fine.
It was his shoulder that copped the brunt of it.
Cotchin has no case to answer.
Was it even Cotch's shoulder that connected with Shiel? To me it looked like it was Cotch's back.
<
the 2025 draw.
|
Kane McAuliffe
>
