Before everyone starts endless pages of Griff vs Ty vs McBean and they all can't all play with Jack ask yourself this question....
Would our defence really perform worse if Chaplin was replaced by Griff at CHB?
We get better coverage for uber tall forwards as Griff is way better in the air on talls. Elton can continue to play (or Astbury) and Rance has 2 big guys around him now and never has to go within 30m of goal to defend a high ball again... he can just intercept everything across the 50m line.
That way all 4 in Ty, Griff, Elton and McBean play (keeping everyone happy and the team developing) and e have phenomenal coverage in the Ruck and Forward line for falls.
One always gets subbed and Maric (who is aging) gets plenty of gas saved for later in the year as Griff and Ty can pinch hit.
Even Jack can spend some time up the ground or CHB if the forward line needs a mother look.
Is Chaplin's influence on the game really that much to ignore all the benefits of the above option?