Noah Balta - Welcome to Tigerland | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Noah Balta - Welcome to Tigerland

Sitting next to the cheersquad, I got to watch Balta all day.

He lined up in the same goal square every quarter! I couldn't tell whether I preferred him forward or back. The forward line looked much more potent with him there (lynch being able to get separation), and the backline looked much more stable with him there (Vlossy able to intercept).

We also could have used him for more minutes in the ruck.

It's funny, cause he's still not particularly good in any of these places. I saw one contest in particular in the backline in the second where he was waiting on Naughton in the goal square, got caught dreaming for a fraction of a microsecond, and Naughton got five metres on him (which he then closed to two) but was lead to the ball. Interesting thing was that for the rest of the game (when he was playing back) he had a hand either across the chest, or touching the back, and it didn't happen again. But the great thing was, there was a five minute patch in the same quarter, where he just started leaping and punching everything. Shades of early Rance.

It's gotta be tricky to be looking for separation one second, then trying to shut down the next. And then spending moments on ball in the ruck. This would be such an easy decision if it was only Rance out, or only Jack, but we apparently need a swing man at the moment (who could have predicted we'd need a 19 year old to cover both our vice captains?).

If it was my decision, though, I'd be sitting him at full back next game and just saying 'run, jump, punch'. Don't worry about marking. Don't worry about making the play. Kill everything.

This is how both Rance and Grimes started. Eventually, once you learn how to time your run, and get to a contest with some balance, you start going for the grabs. Then you're the all australian captain.
 
Sintiger said:
An unbroken colt who could win multiple Group 1s.

If we don't persist we are crazy
Yep.
A dropped lolly pop mark which I reckon I could nearly have managed followed up later by a couple of sublime moments to match the best of any. Just needs learnin time.
 
Wouldn't mind seeing him go into the midfield for some centre bounces. Win a centre clearance and go long to the goal square or even better kick a few goals.
 
Coburgtiger said:
Sitting next to the cheersquad, I got to watch Balta all day.

He lined up in the same goal square every quarter! I couldn't tell whether I preferred him forward or back. The forward line looked much more potent with him there (lynch being able to get separation), and the backline looked much more stable with him there (Vlossy able to intercept).

We also could have used him for more minutes in the ruck.

It's funny, cause he's still not particularly good in any of these places. I saw one contest in particular in the backline in the second where he was waiting on Naughton in the goal square, got caught dreaming for a fraction of a microsecond, and Naughton got five metres on him (which he then closed to two) but was lead to the ball. Interesting thing was that for the rest of the game (when he was playing back) he had a hand either across the chest, or touching the back, and it didn't happen again. But the great thing was, there was a five minute patch in the same quarter, where he just started leaping and punching everything. Shades of early Rance.

It's gotta be tricky to be looking for separation one second, then trying to shut down the next. And then spending moments on ball in the ruck. This would be such an easy decision if it was only Rance out, or only Jack, but we apparently need a swing man at the moment (who could have predicted we'd need a 19 year old to cover both our vice captains?).

If it was my decision, though, I'd be sitting him at full back next game and just saying 'run, jump, punch'. Don't worry about marking. Don't worry about making the play. Kill everything.

This is how both Rance and Grimes started. Eventually, once you learn how to time your run, and get to a contest with some balance, you start going for the grabs. Then you're the all australian captain.
Great post, burger.
 
Coburgtiger said:
Sitting next to the cheersquad, I got to watch Balta all day.

He lined up in the same goal square every quarter! I couldn't tell whether I preferred him forward or back. The forward line looked much more potent with him there (lynch being able to get separation), and the backline looked much more stable with him there (Vlossy able to intercept).

We also could have used him for more minutes in the ruck.

It's funny, cause he's still not particularly good in any of these places. I saw one contest in particular in the backline in the second where he was waiting on Naughton in the goal square, got caught dreaming for a fraction of a microsecond, and Naughton got five metres on him (which he then closed to two) but was lead to the ball. Interesting thing was that for the rest of the game (when he was playing back) he had a hand either across the chest, or touching the back, and it didn't happen again. But the great thing was, there was a five minute patch in the same quarter, where he just started leaping and punching everything. Shades of early Rance.

It's gotta be tricky to be looking for separation one second, then trying to shut down the next. And then spending moments on ball in the ruck. This would be such an easy decision if it was only Rance out, or only Jack, but we apparently need a swing man at the moment (who could have predicted we'd need a 19 year old to cover both our vice captains?).

If it was my decision, though, I'd be sitting him at full back next game and just saying 'run, jump, punch'. Don't worry about marking. Don't worry about making the play. Kill everything.

This is how both Rance and Grimes started. Eventually, once you learn how to time your run, and get to a contest with some balance, you start going for the grabs. Then you're the all australian captain.

Great observation. I remember Grimes spoiling 100% of the time, gives him less to think about.
 
A keeper is The Ark.

I loved his agro too.

I thought he was going to knock Naughton's block off at one stage. Love the passion.

Even that action is very similar to his Grand Master Poo Bah "The Rancid one"!.
Wasn't backwards in coming forward.

He will be a beast in a year or so.
 
theglove3 said:
I thought he was going to knock Naughton's block off at one stage. Love the passion.

Naughton does appear to have all the appeal of Matthew Lloyd. The velvet tack hammer.
 
Coburgtiger said:
Sitting next to the cheersquad, I got to watch Balta all day.

He lined up in the same goal square every quarter! I couldn't tell whether I preferred him forward or back. The forward line looked much more potent with him there (lynch being able to get separation), and the backline looked much more stable with him there (Vlossy able to intercept).

We also could have used him for more minutes in the ruck.

It's funny, cause he's still not particularly good in any of these places. I saw one contest in particular in the backline in the second where he was waiting on Naughton in the goal square, got caught dreaming for a fraction of a microsecond, and Naughton got five metres on him (which he then closed to two) but was lead to the ball. Interesting thing was that for the rest of the game (when he was playing back) he had a hand either across the chest, or touching the back, and it didn't happen again. But the great thing was, there was a five minute patch in the same quarter, where he just started leaping and punching everything. Shades of early Rance.

It's gotta be tricky to be looking for separation one second, then trying to shut down the next. And then spending moments on ball in the ruck. This would be such an easy decision if it was only Rance out, or only Jack, but we apparently need a swing man at the moment (who could have predicted we'd need a 19 year old to cover both our vice captains?).

If it was my decision, though, I'd be sitting him at full back next game and just saying 'run, jump, punch'. Don't worry about marking. Don't worry about making the play. Kill everything.

This is how both Rance and Grimes started. Eventually, once you learn how to time your run, and get to a contest with some balance, you start going for the grabs. Then you're the all australian captain.

I actually appreciate your thoughts on Noah because I'm a big fan and have been all along. But I disagree with you about making him play FB now, even with Rance missing. Firstly because you've forgotten about Astbury being out too for this game. With him back, we can keep managing, as it allows Grimes and Broad to take less that the main KPF and Floss to zone off and intercept.

This is the same argument I've had with Bontague. The 2nd reason I object is because it's that defensive mentality. We've lost Alex the Great so get a very young, inexperienced player to start emulating him from scratch - by just punching any ball that comes near him. That mentality is just so old-school and outdated footy. Good modern FL's are going to be really loving the chance to feed off the crumbs to score; just like ours do/did and everyone's gone to school on finding and training their SFs to pounce and apply fierce forward pressure. Go look at how CScott has altered the Moggies FL. Mark the ball when you can, punch if you can't. Marking gives you ball control, allowing you to move it on quickly or 'tempo' it around until an attack is primed, and the way DH has allowed us to turn into a very poor ball-winning side along with a crap marking team is one of the reasons we are being undone. Bevo showed the way in the final H&A game of '18, so Bucks and Longmuir got the template for the PF, and used again this year. Bevo just used it to rip us a new one again.

So, play Balta forward in order to seek to win games, not try to save them. It's the old truism - attack is the best form of defence. There is little point in defence for it's own sake. When he's fresh from a rest, play Balts at CHF, when he's needing a break from relief rucking, play him deep and release Lynch to move around at CHF and escape the throng of key defenders sitting deep for our dumb bomb-kicking. Balts is a natural attacker; look at his goal this game and others. Making him into a grim defender at this stage is just a waste, and a loser mentality IMHO. He is a really fast big man - he's made for attack. Let him rip.
 
Bill James said:
Naughton does appear to have all the appeal of Matthew Lloyd. The velvet tack hammer.

Not a bad forward for a Full back, he couldnt get his hands on it against the Green shoots