Tigerbob said:
I am not sold on this kid. Want to hear about how he interviews, his personality and his decision making under pressure. Everytime I see this kid, he just doesn't seem clean. Scully, Trengove, Martin are all clean. This kid, I have that bad feeling about.
Leysy's normally with you on the boards Bobby. Couldnt be poles further apart on Morabito though Geordie lad.
On the draft camp. Leysy's long held the belief its an overrated tool. Good for the layman to get a lookin at some basic results perhaps. But clubs should have enough knowledge to have there likely selections down pat by now.
On the bolded above. Reckon you need to be VERY wary of dissing young 17 y.o kids because of interviews or supposed personities that you state we need to look out for.
Leysy's of the belief that you need to draft who you believe will be the most talented kids not next year but in the future. You should pretty much disregard phyche tests & interviews. They are bloody footballers for leysy's sake. Not civil engineers. & most importantly are 17 & 18 year old kids straight out of school that have a lot of maturing to do. Nearly all grow up once in the system along with natural maturity.
Heck look at us overlooking Buddy & Mitch Clark for similar "personality faults". DAre say there's another 20 seasons of near All Aus worthy seasons worth between them just there. :-\ Look at clubs overlooking Cyril for the exact same reason. John Beveridge overlooking the obvious talent for a solid workaholic ruck in McEvoy has without question cost his club & 100,000 supporters a premiership...
Back on Morabito's interview. He knows he will stay home & be drafted by Freo if we overlook him... Who could blame him for being laconic in an interview. If we deem him the most talented football it should be COMPLETELY disregarded. Once guys move into a new club they soon create a new circle of friends & nearly all never look back.
Tigers of Old said:
Other teams can take punt on X-Factors, we need footballers and I'm not sure he's one first and foremost.
He aint an X factor ToO. He was WA MVP in the national champs & won the WAFL rising star.
He performed well in a woeful bottom of the ladder team in a strong comp against men. He was part of very young team & received little to no protection because of that.
Leysy's of the belief that RFC supporters (are perhaps quire rightly) burnt & scarred by picks in the past.
But facts are we overlooked the aforementioned supposed "loose cannons" like Buddy & Clark & have since taken the supposed sae option "footballers" that have dropped in the draft namely Hughes, Connors & Rance who were meant to go way earlier in recent years. We shouldn't be scared from taking player with a higher ceiling because of the past.
Saying that Martin looks an excellent prospect & Trengrove a better one that would suit us perfectly. Just bemused by the constant dissing of Morabito on here amongst the big 3....
Also more bemusing is the fact that Butcher (& leysy's no fan) was talked up by nearly all & sundry on here as who we should take at 3 a month ago....
He's played one game in the bush since & Martin none yet the heard mentality on here has swung totally around. (Which is quite right with those two yet amusing none the less). ;D