Another point of reference would be the amount of AA selections of players at clubs that had dominant eras. Brisvegas, Moggies, Hawforn constantly had numerous players in the AA squad multiple times during their dominant eras. Aside from Dusty we'd be lucky to get anyone else make the team n usually only for the one year.Impossible comparison.
You’ve completely discounted development. A player can only reach his ultimate potential in the right environment and with the right coaching. Who knows how good each player would be at different clubs under different coaches?
One very credentialed ex coach/media commentator ( and many agreed ) said that Richmond was the worst team to ever win a Premiership. That alludes to great coaching if you accept any of that stuff.
Only fair comparison is which coach has won 3 Premierships and which one hasn’t. That’s how history will look at it. Over win/loss averages included
Nothing but a handy workman like mob that complimented one another and were bloody well coached.