allybabe said:I will be as diplomatic as possible.
It was a MAJOR surprise he went at 30.
MAJOR.
Ridley said:His highlights look good. Nice left foot and seems very balanced.
But I can't say I'm not disappointed that, with all the mids we picked, we didn't pick a tall KPP with pick 30. Both McCarthy and Mitchell were highly rated, both were available, and both went to *smile*ing scum Carlton.
Given the state of our KPP stocks, particularly in defence, why the hell wouldn't we have picked either of these two?
Col.W.Kurtz said:Is he the bloke that's going to release Lids back to the midfield?
Exactly!, you could add McCarthey to that list as welltoothless said:Welcome Jake, hope your career outlasts Horlin-Smith, Parker, Hallahan & Mitchell
Gourdis - Untried (and 193cm...?)Inspector said:KPP,s at Richmond Gourdis Grimes Thursfield McGuane Rance Post Riewoldt Griffiths Vickery Astbury Moore Westoff i have included Vickery because the word is he will play more forward than ruck that's 12 key position or potential key position players.
mad_doggy911 said:I'm real angry we didn't take Parker. Bloody hell. He can play midfield and HF. I don't like Batchelors unco kicking style. Under more pressure it might come undone. That's a big concern for me.
Enough saidrosy23 said:This has probably been posted, apologies if that's the case. From Inside Football.
"Jake won our B&F playing predominantly off half back. A good size , he has great hands and is a super reader of the game. A terrific one on one player who set up a lot of our rebounds and was our number 1 rebounding player and marking the ball off opposition kicks. He is one of those classic rebounding half backs that AFL clubs get really excited about. A really balanced player coming off a tremendously consistant year and he deserves a crack at AFL level. I think he will get it!"
Dandenong Stingrays Coach Greame Yeats
Gourdis & Grimes are "tried" more than any draft pick we'd take this year, they've both played AFLkeepa lids onit said:Gourdis - Untried (and 193cm...?)
Grimes - Untried (is he big enough for Kep Posi? 193cm 83kg)
thrusfield - NOT KEY POSI
maguane - NOT KEY POSI, but is playing stop gap CHB
moore - NOT KEY POSI
Rance - doesnt look to be Key Posi on what hes shown so far but he is 194 and athletic. give the benefit
Ridley said::hihi :hihi I must admit the Miller angle did cross my mind. Am really staggered we didn't get McCarthy or Mitchell with this pick.
Bloody flankers!!! Is Wallace back coaching? Surprised we didn't recontract McMuffin
keepa lids onit said:Gourdis - Untried (and 193cm...?)
Grimes - Untried (is he big enough for Kep Posi? 193cm 83kg)
thrusfield - NOT KEY POSI
maguane - NOT KEY POSI, but is playing stop gap CHB
moore - NOT KEY POSI
Rance - doesnt look to be Key Posi on what hes shown so far but he is 194 and athletic. give the benefit
that leaves
Post, Riew, Griffo, Vickery and Astbury. (Westhoff?? still raw rookie. cant consider)
i make that 5 proper key position with 3 goo grimes and rance given the benefit also. not 12 like you say.
means we dont have nearly enough proper key positions and should ahve defincately drafted a decent one at pick 30.
on topic, good luck cleo.... :-\