Short sighted view. He needs a trusted run similiar to that afforded Castagna. The kid has the goods he just needs to be trusted so that one mistake wont be scrutinized into the VFL
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Jack Ross
- Thread starter Tigertool
- Start date
I don't think he should be in the VFL Rinso. But I also don't think he's turning into Tom Mitchell anytime in the next 15 years either.
So 4 possessions in the first half and 6 in the second half, I suppose he improved 50% in the 2nd half. Please. Disposal by foot is poor.
That’s nasty big fella, Matt Arnott lol one of the worst AFL players we’ve had, super hard at man, not so much at ball .
I think Jacks going ok, however as others have said there’s no X factor , just a good honest player, I’m not writing him off yet I think he’s got improvement in him , however going forward I have Dow, Martyn and RCD in front of him
Nah, showed enough composure across the game. Keep playing him. Needs the exposure
Meh. A nothing player. Doesnt break the lines. Slow decision making. Kicking is average. No speed. Gets caught too often. Plodder and list clogger. Showed promising signs in his first year as an extractor then decided to lose his muscle and strength and has found himself as that inbetween average player. Should have bulked up and played the Cripps role
Geez that inability to make a decision was terrible in the 3rd q. Reminded me of the 90s
Yep - ridiculous playing him on a wing. Disappointing game though & he is slow. Can’t believe how backwards he’s gone from his debut.
Started the game quite well, I thought but wasn't that effective as the game wore on.
He will stay in as the injuries mount. In the early stages of his career I thought the Tigers had unearthed a good player, but that foot injury seems to have cruelled him a bit.
As some others have said he needs to find another gear and grasp this opportunity well.
Or it may not augur so well for his future at RFC.
He will stay in as the injuries mount. In the early stages of his career I thought the Tigers had unearthed a good player, but that foot injury seems to have cruelled him a bit.
As some others have said he needs to find another gear and grasp this opportunity well.
Or it may not augur so well for his future at RFC.
Still only 21 games but has never looked as assured as in the first few. Hard to tell what his role is from the TV. Who played on Smith?
