Bad loss, we should have won, we had a big enough lead in the last to hold on. Very very disappointing.
3 things lost us the game: bad decisions, skills not up to scratch and woeful umpiring.
The forward pressure game is dead, well at least in home and away games, we'll see if it changes in the cauldron which is finals.
Our small forwards are not positioning well. I am not surprised Jack is trying to mark when we think he should be bringing it to ground, the only players in front of the pack are the opposition. The small forwards have to get in better positions. The whole idea of having small forwards bring massive pressure and hold the ball in just no longer seems to work so their role must change.
We should have slowed the game down near the end but that really isn't the way we play so keeping it moving is still the way to go, but they have to execute better and play the percentages better. Too many turnovers really cost us.
The change in game style is a response to the change in rules, but we really need to nail our passes better, way too many are off the mark. I don't know how they can fix this up mid season but we must adjust to the way the game is played and that means better execution.
The umpiring was an embarrassment. The "dangerous" tackle was not a dangerous tackle, the Richmond player deliberately made sure the WCE player went down on his side so he wouldn't get done for in the back. The throw by Grimes was a handball, mind you, the throw at the other end by a WCE player not 30 seconds later - that was the real deal, genuine chuck. The kick to Kennedy wasn't close to 15m. In a game decided right at the end by less than a goal this makes a huge difference, the difference between winning and losing. We should have won anyway, but it sure doesn't help when the umpires give a nice shove to the momentum shift that WCE got.
We're not gone, there were some decent signs. At times it did look like a Richmond game. Lambert came back well. Houli was good for a lot of the game. The back line did well considering they really are not tall enough to compete against that forward line. Vlastuin was back, he was really good for 90% of the game. We have players to come back - expecting us to be able to compete in the ruck for 4 quarters against NicNat when we are missing both Nank and Soldo is not realistic. Prestia back will make a substantial difference. Nank back will also make our defence taller. Chol is not a first ruck but he is getting better and can be a second ruck, he had moments and probably more of them than he used to have, but just does not seem to be able to switch on for the whole game, no idea why. Cotchin will improve.
Castagana has to lift and play more of a crumbing small forward, as does Rioli - either that or they shouldn't be playing. Blocking space simply ain't working, new role or out.
Caddy, the game seems to have passed him by. If he can get to where the ball is about to go he can be effective and it makes up for the lack of pace, but he rarely does this now.
It is going to be tough, but we can win finals, we do have players coming back. Time to take a breather, the Match Committee need to make some tough decisions, then reload and go for it.
Go Tiges.
DS