David Astbury, Thank You | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

David Astbury, Thank You

Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Put your hand up and say your not right.
We were 2 players down from the bounce. He and dusty should've not played.
Selfish
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Have a gut feel someone will go past Dave next year. And it may not be Garthwaite. Watch out for Ben Miller. Same height as Dave but way more athletic.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Hoefully he has passed his bug on to the Collingwood team with an incubation preiod of five days.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Does gatro make you slip over?
His decision to play when not 100%, is getting me angry. Selfish
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

zippadeee said:
Does gatro make you slip over?
His decision to play when not 100%, is getting me angry. Selfish

*smile*. He played because we have no-one else who could play on Cox. He had to play. Then he had to play well or Cox badly. We saw how those dice rolled.

We play Collingwood next weekend and we would walk into the game hoping the Astbury/Cox match-up works for us because CCJ or Chol who we need against someone who is frigging 7 foot tall aren't ready.

No different to Nankervis/Grundy. No option, the match-up either goes our way or it doesn't.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

You don't send soldiers to war on one leg because you know they're tough.

Never play underdone players in finals.

Club's fault, not Dave's.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Brettstigers said:
*smile*. He played because we have no-one else who could play on Cox. He had to play. Then he had to play well or Cox badly. We saw how those dice rolled.

We play Collingwood next weekend and we would walk into the game hoping the Astbury/Cox match-up works for us because CCJ or Chol who we need against someone who is *smile*g 7 foot tall aren't ready.

No different to Nankervis/Grundy. No option, the match-up either goes our way or it doesn't.

No he didn't have to play and yes we did have other options.

Astbury wasn't healthy and therefore should've been ineligible for selection. It's been the Golden Rule of finals since forever. I was just as arrogant as the coaching staff for thinking it wouldn't matter before the game, but in hindsight this was such an amateur mistake.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

123kid said:
You don't send soldiers to war on one leg because you know they're tough.

Never play underdone players in finals.

Club's fault, not Dave's.

Yeah, but that never happens. Every player thinks he can push past whatever niggle he has. AFL players are all ultra competitive.

The *only* time I think that a player declared himself unfit was Prestigiacomo.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

Baloo said:
Yeah, but that never happens. Every player thinks he can push past whatever niggle he has. AFL players are all ultra competitive.

The *only* time I think that a player declared himself unfit was Prestigiacomo.

The medical team can make the decision, not the player.

Same with Dusty, Dimma said if it was a H&A game then he doesn't play. History clearly shows you need fresh players in finals. I just wish we all realised this pretty obvious fact yesterday, but we all were blinded by our status.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

But we conveniently forget (or don’t know of) all the other times players have played injured in finals but blitz ie Stevie J in the 2011 GF.
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

123kid said:
The medical team makes the decision, not the player.

Yes, but my point is the player will do whatever he can to convince the medical team he is fit to play. If the medicos are unable to say categorically one way or another then you're left with the player
 
Re: David "Dave" Astbury

tigertim said:
But we conveniently forget (or don’t know of) all the other times players have played injured in finals but blitz ie Stevie J in the 2011 GF.

Or Stevie J in the prelim last year.