Cotchin or Kreuzer | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Cotchin or Kreuzer

Who would you prefer, Cotchin or Kereuzer


  • Total voters
    143
  • Poll closed .
kruezer is a gun and will easily be the best ruck in the land but cotchin is better

it irrelevant though. its like asking who was better out of wayne carey and leigh matthews
 
RedanTiger said:
But was Jack worth pick 8, which we traded away for Polak?
Won the Coleman medal in a side that got seriously smashed for most of the season. Also won Jaaack the medal that was named after him before he was even born.
No doubt in my mind that he was worth pick 8 or even better in his draft. Young Jaaack is a seriously class player.




Interesting suggestion that Jack Watts and Tyrone Vickery would be a better career comparison.
 
Brodders17 said:
you dont think Jack was the right pick at 13 the year before? or Lids at 1 in 04?
Lids was a standout and we couldnt mess recruiting him. Look at the other selections we had in that draft. Apart from Lid's noone is left.
Jack was a very good selection and has taken a little time to show why we recruited him.
You look at past recruiting and we've totally messed up all early selections apart from Lids, Jack and Cotch.

Cotchin without a doubt will be our next leader. He has all the qualities and leads by example. Unfortunately we havent seen the best of Cotchin yet due to injuries. This kid is only going to get better.
 
Only injury Karma will separate them over their careers.

And there's your winner.

TBC
 
nwonash said:
Lids was a standout and we couldnt mess recruiting him. Look at the other selections we had in that draft. Apart from Lid's noone is left.
Jack was a very good selection and has taken a little time to show why we recruited him.
You look at past recruiting and we've totally messed up all early selections apart from Lids, Jack and Cotch.

I think Martin would be another good early selection.
Your point is valid though.
 
despite the fact we got Cotchin and they got Kruezer, if Trent stays reasonably fit I believe he'll be an AFL great - has time and space. Not going to compare Trent to Judd because I think the Chimp can be better...
 
Cotch for his time and space, duck and weave, left or right, all off virtually no preseason, looks real comfortable at the elite level, and he's still just a kid ( 21 in April?) Can't wait to see what he can produce fully fit and with a developing midfield around him. Appears to have great mental strength and resolve, and will be a natural leader that will demand integrity in all aspects from his fellow teamates, a guy who we can really build a successful era on.........Oh, and I believe he will be the key reason his best mate kruezer joins the Tiges in the next few years!
 
Eat the rich said:
Oh, and I believe he will be the key reason his best mate kruezer joins the Tiges in the next few years!

Not beyond the realms of possibility, that. All the better reason to chip in to help the Tiges build a war chest. 8)
 
Tanking is certainly developing an ugly underbelly, I think it's fair to say that having the first pick is something of a poison chalice for both club and player.
 
For a young ruckman/fwd with injury dramas Kruezer has shown some freakish ability. After he turns 24 he will be brilliant.
Wouldn't swap him for the Chimp though
 
mld said:
How about that Cale Morton?

Chimp ? Kreuzer ? Cale Morton ? Pffft.....what are you all on about??

Watch out for the new POWER FORWARD in Jack Watts this weekend!!