Coronavirus | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Coronavirus

If they had mandatory testing of staff instead of voluntary it may well have been avoided.

You understand that some businesses own or operate multiple sites so workers will be engaged at multiple sites? Its not necessarily one person working for a number of different businesses?

There are benefits and disadvantages of casual work.

Staff working at the hotels were also working at a pizza bar.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
SA outbreak amplified and spread via casual workers again. When are governments both Federal and State going to wake up realise the gig economy is a bad thing.

The "gig' economy is simply a way that business has attempted to maximise profits by eroding employee rights and priviledges.

I just hope SA's outbreak is a wake up call for the rest of Australia. The pandemic is certainly not over yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Standing by for criticism of the SA (liberal) Government & Steven Marshall for their mismanagement of hotel quarantine..

Can't believe that private security is STILL being used in hotel quarantine. We were told adnauseum that this was the primary reason for Victoria's outbreak (by the murdoch media rags anyway).

Its hard to comprehend why SA hadn't already replaced hotel security guards with ADF or SA Police personell. Its such a no brainer! /s
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
You understand that some businesses own or operate multiple sites so workers will be engaged at multiple sites? Its not necessarily one person working for a number of different businesses?

That may be the case, but businesses especially those in high risk scenarios should not be sharing staff between sites.

Ie. all aged care facilities should have been instructed that staff should be single site operators. Anyone operating in a hotel quarantine site, should not be able to have a secondary job, so none of them should be working as uber drivers / pizza shop workers etc.

This is common sense and I know for a fact (through the business I work for) that some companies and some government departments have actually followed through on this off their own back.

This may impact some businesses, but those businesses may already be receiving JobKeeper for those staff anyway so it wouldn't necessarily impact this bottom lines too much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
That may be the case, but businesses especially those in high risk scenarios should not be sharing staff between sites.
Agree. But its laughable to argue we should cease the entire casual or piecemeal labour because of this.
 
Agree. But its laughable to argue we should cease the entire casual or piecemeal labour because of this.

We can't cease them all but we should be bringing restrictions in as to how casuals should be used.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
If they had mandatory testing of staff instead of voluntary it may well have been avoided.
.
It would have helped but unless the mandatory testing is daily then it's not going to stop it completely and not even hospitals have that because it's logistically impossible.
Mandatory testing is only one step. It has to be combined with a lot of things like infection control, PPE, training and then when it happens effective contact tracing. Not one of those things on its own will eliminate the risk
 
You trust other countries test procedures?
It's better than a poke in the eye. Having said that a global standard of testing and protocols should be established. If we are going to have these bubbles, better tracing of individuals and requirements to have subsequent test(s) while here should be necessary. Sure you could be negative upon reaching the airport but travelling on a flying petri dish with others from god knows where is putting yourself at an extremely high risk of picking something up in transit.
 
Can't believe that private security is STILL being used in hotel quarantine. We were told adnauseum that this was the primary reason for Victoria's outbreak (by the murdoch media rags anyway).

Its hard to comprehend why SA hadn't already replaced hotel security guards with ADF or SA Police personell. Its such a no brainer! /s
The SA CHO is saying that the person first infected in the Quarantine Hotel had no contact with guests and most likely picked it up off a contaminated surface. Not defending the use of private security but it's difficult to imagine how having the SA Police or ADF guarding the hotel would have changed what happened. Seems like a fault/lapse in cleaning processes. She's also saying that this is a particularly nasty strain. It's really just another indication that the people returning from overseas should be locked up somewhere where the staff looking after them don't go home at night or go to other jobs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
The SA CHO is saying that the person first infected in the Quarantine Hotel had no contact with guests and most likely picked it up off a contaminated surface. Not defending the use of private security but it's difficult to imagine how having the SA Police or ADF guarding the hotel would have changed what happened. Seems like a fault/lapse in cleaning processes. She's also saying that this is a particularly nasty strain. It's really just another indication that the people returning from overseas should be locked up somewhere where the staff looking after them don't go home at night or go to other jobs.
I think the police have been involved, but they can't be the people responsible for cleaning etc. Check the photo in the link below, and note the date.


The article is about the system reaching capacity. When things get busy, people often don't keep following procedure, especially those that are poorly trained. So as you say there has been a fault or lapse somewhere.

Maybe the capacity of these "medi-hotels" should be minimised so as not to get overloaded. And obviously people working in them don't work elsewhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
What’s this?

Lee's bizarre notions that expats should not be able to come home. Any Australian citizen should be able to come home when they can - many have been stranded and are in really difficult financial straits.

When they do come home they have to the responsibility to comply with whatever testing and quarantine procedures are deemed necessary by state/federal governments. As long as they do that, they have the right to return.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Lee's bizarre notions that expats should not be able to come home. Any Australian citizen should be able to come home when they can - many have been stranded and are in really difficult financial straits.

When they do come home they have to the responsibility to comply with whatever testing and quarantine procedures are deemed necessary by state/federal governments. As long as they do that, they have the right to return.
Ah right thanks. Yes I agree expats should be able to come home when possible. But we should also be implementing a program of expat testing in developed countries so that we are reducing the risk by getting as many expats as possible returning after they’ve shown a negative test result. Obviously as we’ve discussed that’s not really feasible for less developed countries. However the more we can implement such a program the less risk we take on. Regardless all returnees would still need to quarantine.

But most of all we need to substantially improve the quarantine program. Getting it out of hotels in major cities would be good start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Seriously? They're Australian Citizens Lee!
Not their fault the hotel quarantine failed.
They were told to come home in MARCH. They made their decisions and they took their chances. They have NO *smile* RIGHT to bring the country down just because the second wave is five times worse than the first in the UK.

Manus or Christmas, or remain in place until you can get vaccinated. *smile* globetrotters.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 1 users
Lee's bizarre notions that expats should not be able to come home. Any Australian citizen should be able to come home when they can - many have been stranded and are in really difficult financial straits.

When they do come home they have to the responsibility to comply with whatever testing and quarantine procedures are deemed necessary by state/federal governments. As long as they do that, they have the right to return.
What part of this didn't they understand?
This is a global emergency. If you didn't heed the clear advice first time around, this government's obligations are terminated AFAIC.

Fortunately for people like you, it's just my opinion and not the government's stance.