Coronavirus | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Coronavirus

But there is a cost to those decisions. That is what the article pointed out. Saving these lives now will have unintended consequences in other areas that will cost other lives. They just won't be as directly measurable.

the Sweden example shows that not locking down had the same impact or worse on the economy. The analysis is extremely poor as it assumes the economy continues as it did prior to corona. It ignores costs like increased deaths and hospitalisations, and the resultant excess deaths due to lack of health service availability. It assumes no vaccine is forthcoming and herd immunity is an inevitable strategy. It doesn't cost the impact of a herd immunity strategy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
- - - - -

Can that be correct - 40-50% of all infections show no symptoms? That just doesn't sound right. There would be no stopping it.

I don’t know about the actual percentage - but it is not uncommon for people to Test positive without showing any symptoms at all.

Combine that with the virus being highly contagious is why all the health professionals are *smile* scared.
 
Where did I argue against government spending now? I'm only pointing out I disagree with the theory (MMT) you are a fan of. And I'm not a supporter of the likes of that knob Tim Wilson. I just don't like the idea of governments controlling the macroeconomic levers.

I'm not an economist and like everything there are plenty of smart people who support MMT and plenty who don't. Most are influenced by political persuasion.
I didn't bring MMT into it, you did. (It's more an established practice than a theory, by the way. Even an arch necon like Alan Greenspan said: "The United States can pay any debt it has because we can always print money to do that. So there is zero probability of default.")

I'm talking about the notion that we "can't afford" to do the things we need to do, to protect individuals, businesses, and the economy. We absolutely can. We just have to choose to. In a country as rich as Australia, no one has to be destitute, or homeless, or wanting for healthcare, but unfortunately there are some who can't feel like winners unless someone else is losing.

Incidentally,
A poll of 50 leading economists, conducted by the Economic Society of Australia, found that 44 of them agreed the government should use its budget to boost demand during the economic crisis and recovery, “even if it means a substantial increase in public debt”.

And if Reserve Bank Governor Philip Lowe shares the government’s worries about debt and deficit, he’s got a strange way of showing it.
Only on Tuesday he said that “debt across all levels of government in Australia, relative to the size of the economy, is much lower than in many other countries and it is likely to remain so. The Australian government can borrow at the lowest interest rates since Federation.”
So it is “well placed to smooth out the shock to private incomes and support the economy through the pandemic”.

Every time you think this government is a bunch of *smile* wits, they remind you they're a pack of campaigners.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
I don’t know about the actual percentage - but it is not uncommon for people to Test positive without showing any symptoms at all.

Combine that with the virus being highly contagious is why all the health professionals are *smile* scared.

Yep, estimated around 40% are asymptomatic, which is why track and trace and test is critical.

For some age groups it's higher.
 
worldwide cases increasing by the day - almost 300k daily. deaths also increasing after dropping off a bit in May. this is just the beginning.
 
Not stopped, not fined. Great message there for the people doing the right thing.
 
Not stopped, not fined. Great message there for the people doing the right thing.

Maybe they should do as they say, and take her through the Covid ward at the Austin or Royal Melbourne.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Not stopped, not fined. Great message there for the people doing the right thing.

Seriously; this is a *smile* disgrace. WTF are we doing in this state? The vast majority of people are abiding by draconian, albeit necessary, lock down rules, wearing masks 10 hours a day, staying at home unless absolutely necessary to go out; all the while the rest of the country is going out to dinner, to the footy, catching up with friends and family etc; all laughing at how *smile* inept we are in Victoria.

Then some *smile* nut job drives up to the checkpoint and just drives out of Melbourne without any consequences!!! What is the *smile* point of having checkpoints if they aren't enforced? Yet a couple of kids hanging in a park not wearing masks with no one else around will probably get fined $200.

Geez this is a *smile* joke. Andrews needs to take control and enforce the law on these *smile* wits who are deliberately disobeying the lock down rules. Fine them $10K; throw them in the slammer. I don't give a *smile*. Just sort it out.

Otherwise we may as well all just flip the bird and get on with our lives as normal and let the virus sort us all out. Bloody hell :mad:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10 users
Yeh because no privately run business is capable of delivering quality services and government's services are nothing but quality. It's amazing that any privately run businesses exist given how incapable they are.

It's all scomos fault anyway.
i dont think anyone is saying private business cant be successful, but private business running social services for profit is fraught with risk, particularly in sectors where there is no natural marker to drive quality.

and you need to move on from Scomo, it is a bit boring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Seriously; this is a *smile* disgrace. WTF are we doing in this state? The vast majority of people are abiding by draconian, albeit necessary, lock down rules, wearing masks 10 hours a day, staying at home unless absolutely necessary to go out; all the while the rest of the country is going out to dinner, to the footy, catching up with friends and family etc; all laughing at how *smile* inept we are in Victoria.

Then some *smile* nut job drives up to the checkpoint and just drives out of Melbourne without any consequences!!! What is the *smile* point of having checkpoints if they aren't enforced? Yet a couple of kids hanging in a park not wearing masks with no one else around will probably get fined $200.

Geez this is a *smile* joke. Andrews needs to take control and enforce the law on these *smile* wits who are deliberately disobeying the lock down rules. Fine them $10K; throw them in the slammer. I don't give a *smile*. Just sort it out.

Otherwise we may as well all just flip the bird and get on with our lives as normal and let the virus sort us all out. Bloody hell :mad:

Im getting the feeling you're not particularly happy with the way this young lady has conducted herself.

Agree, btw. disgraceful behaviour.
 
VIC
New Cases: 280 (300 with 20 reclassified)
Total Cases: 7405
Active Cases: 3734 (up 104, which is down by more than half from yesterday).
6 deaths (55 Total). * All 6 deaths are linked to Aged Care Facilities.
24,118 tests (1,437,233 Total)

NSW
New Cases: 7
Total Cases: 3640
Active Cases: 131 (up 7)
0 deaths (51 Total). Note: NSW Government website says 51 deaths, other sites say 49.
36,169 tests (1,297,429 Total) * 7 Cases from a lot more tests (highest amount of tests done in a single day). encouraging day for NSW.
 
Im getting the feeling you're not particularly happy with the way this young lady has conducted herself.

Agree, btw. disgraceful behaviour.
Yeah I should be more forthright :mhihi

Anyway it's not just her behaviour and others like her, I'm also pissed with the so called enforcement of the lock down rules. Don't wear a mask walking around outside in the open air with no one around you; here's a $200 fine. Drive through a checkpoint outside of the lock down area and give no explanation as to what you're doing; on you way nothing to see here. That is just absolute bull *smile*. What is the *smile* point of doing this if people can just get away with crap like that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
The mis-management of Aged Care facilities is an absolute disgrace.

All along we never the elderly were the most at risk. Yet nothing was done to protect them from this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Can anyone explain why Geelong is not part of the lockdown area and the Mitchell Shire is? As of yesterday Geelong LGA had 23 active cases with case increasing on a daily basis, albeit in low numbers. The Mitchell Shire had 11 active cases which was 2 less than the day before. The Mitchell Shire borders Hume LGA which a week or so ago had the most active cases. However Hume has been well overtaken by Wyndham LGA which now has clearly the most active cases and shares a border with Geelong LGA.

Makes no sense at all.
 
Can anyone explain why Geelong is not part of the lockdown area and the Mitchell Shire is? As of yesterday Geelong LGA had 23 active cases with case increasing on a daily basis, albeit in low numbers. The Mitchell Shire had 11 active cases which was 2 less than the day before. The Mitchell Shire borders Hume LGA which a week or so ago had the most active cases. However Hume has been well overtaken by Wyndham LGA which now has clearly the most active cases and shares a border with Geelong LGA.

Makes no sense at all.

I imagine they will review and update as necessary, they can't turn lockdowns on and off on a daily basis.
 
I imagine they will review and update as necessary, they can't turn lockdowns on and off on a daily basis.
Wasn't suggesting they should do it on a daily basis. It's been over 2 weeks since the lockdown and Mitchell's numbers are going down whilst Geelong's are going up. Given Geelong is substantially more heavily populated than Mitchell and also has many, many residents travelling to the Wyndham red zone for work everyday then applying the restrictions in Geelong seems very pertinent; a no brainer really.