Coaches votes- 2013

[Rosy]

I think it would be fascinating to compare the voting patterns of a secret ballot vs the current open system.

that would be very interesting. i think we'd get quite different results. without really studying the weekly voting it seems to me that people are influenced by others votes. there might be similar votes for a while then someone throws in another name and all of a sudden that player starts getting votes.

 

[bruntonave.]

Season totals:

Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank
-------------------------------------------
1st Martin, Dustin 58 22 11 2.64 eq 17th
/ snip /
22nd Grigg, Shaun 2 22 1 0.09 eq302nd

24th Newman, Chris 1 18 1 0.06 eq336th

Stephenson, Orren 0 6 - - eq367th
Grimes, Dylan 0 8 - - eq367th

McGuane, Luke 0 12 - - eq367th

Thanks as always to L2R2R
So. Of the above, who plays on Sunday?

 

[mld]

I think it would be fascinating to compare the voting patterns of a secret ballot vs the current open system.

Must admit that I stopped voting when I saw people using people's voting history for point-scoring in arguments. Can't see how a secret ballot would be practical though.

 

[Baloo]

Can't see how a secret ballot would be practical though.

Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.

 

[mld]

Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.

Okay cool. If this doesn't happen for next season, Dimma must go.

 

[Rosy]

Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.

i suspect if it was secret and not readily visible on the forum far less people would be inclined to participate.

 

[Baloo]

Okay cool. If this doesn't happen for next season, Dimma must go.

Hater

i suspect if it was secret and not readily visible on the forum far less people would be inclined to participate.

yeah, tend to agree. I was just addressing the technical aspects, not the human ones. I don't understand humans.

 

[zippadeee]

Morris and Grigg very low in the AFL..

What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking

 

[YinnarTiger]

What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking

What's so shocking about a player ranked 22 by the coaches being included in our best 22?

 

[ToraToraTora]

What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking

That is your most mental post ever. Almost Dyeresque. Awesome.

 

[seven]

What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking

Wasn't even considered for the Australian squad.

 

[zippadeee]

What's so shocking about a player ranked 22 by the coaches being included in our best 22?

What's he played 20-21 games this year and he hasn't been able to snag votes?
He makes no impact.. Wake up
A 19 year old has shown him up thus year

 

[YinnarTiger]

What's he played 20-21 games this year and he hasn't been able to snag votes?

Don't you know how to read a table?

 

[zippadeee]

Don't you know how to read a table?

Nah, I can read a Chair? :ner

 

[YinnarTiger]

Nah, I can read a Chair? :ner

Not bad for a kid that's repeating Year 8.

 

[LeeToRainesToRoach]

thanks lee2. would it be possible to see last year's results as well for comparison. i reckon we'd have a few changes and a more even spread.

Hopefully this makes sense.

Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank RFC AFL Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank
---------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------
1st Martin, Dustin 58 22 11 2.64 eq 17th +12 +162 1st Cotchin, Trent 107 22 20 4.86 1st
2nd Cotchin, Trent 52 21 8 2.48 24th -1 -23 2nd Deledio, Brett 73 22 13 3.32 10th
3rd Jackson, Daniel 46 22 8 2.09 27th +13 +282 3rd Maric, Ivan 39 21 7 1.86 eq 43rd
4th Deledio, Brett 42 22 7 1.91 eq 33rd -2 -23 4th Tuck, Shane 39 22 9 1.77 eq 43rd
5th Ellis, Brandon 29 20 6 1.45 eq 64th +15 +281 5th Grigg, Shaun 28 22 4 1.27 eq 75th
6th Rance, Alex 28 22 5 1.27 eq 66th +3 +85 6th Riewoldt, Jack 21 22 4 0.95 100th
7th Houli, Bachar 21 20 6 1.05 eq 96th +4 +66 7th Edwards, Shane 14 20 2 0.70 eq134th
8th Conca, Reece 19 16 5 1.19 eq105th +2 +57 8th Foley, Nathan 13 10 3 1.30 eq137th
9th Riewoldt, Jack 19 21 6 0.90 eq105th -3 -5 9th Rance, Alex 11 22 5 0.50 eq151st
10th Vickery, Tyrone 16 20 4 0.80 eq120th +8 +225 10th Conca, Reece 10 18 3 0.56 eq162nd
11th Vlastuin, Nick 14 17 2 0.82 eq138th NA NA 11th Houli, Bachar 10 22 3 0.45 eq162nd
12th Chaplin, Troy 13 21 3 0.62 eq149th NA +72 12th Grimes, Dylan 9 9 3 1.00 eq179th
13th Edwards, Aaron 12 8 2 1.50 eq154th NA +104 13th Martin, Dustin 9 20 5 0.45 eq179th
14th King, Jake 8 17 2 0.47 eq193rd +4 +152 14th Morris, Steven 3 21 1 0.14 eq258th
15th Maric, Ivan 8 19 3 0.42 eq193rd -12 -150 15th Nahas, Robin 3 22 2 0.14 eq258th
16th Edwards, Shane 6 19 3 0.32 eq224th -9 -90 16th Jackson, Daniel 1 19 1 0.05 eq309th
17th Tuck, Shane 4 10 1 0.40 eq257th -13 -214 17th Newman, Chris 1 22 1 0.05 eq309th
18th Foley, Nathan 4 16 1 0.25 eq257th -10 -120 18th Elton, Todd 0 1 - - eq345th
19th Petterd, Ricky 3 11 1 0.27 eq280th NA +65 Graham, Angus 0 1 - - eq345th
20th White, Matt 3 16 2 0.19 eq280th -2 +65 Webberley, Jeromey 0 1 - - eq345th
21st Morris, Steven 2 21 1 0.10 eq302nd -7 -44 Astbury, David 0 2 - - eq345th
22nd Grigg, Shaun 2 22 1 0.09 eq302nd -17 -227 Connors, Daniel 0 2 - - eq345th
23rd Knights, Chris 1 5 1 0.20 eq336th NA +9 Derickx, Tom 0 2 - - eq345th
24th Newman, Chris 1 18 1 0.06 eq336th -7 -27 Moore, Kelvin 0 3 - - eq345th
25th Griffiths, Ben 0 1 - - eq367th -7 -22 Helbig, Brad 0 5 - - eq345th
Helbig, Brad 0 1 - - eq367th -7 -22 White, Matt 0 7 - - eq345th
McDonough, Matt 0 1 - - eq367th NA NA O'Hanlon, Brett 0 8 - - eq345th
Lonergan, Sam 0 2 - - eq367th NA -58 Post, Jayden 0 8 - - eq345th
Dea, Matt 0 3 - - eq367th -7 -22 Griffiths, Ben 0 9 - - eq345th
Arnot, Matthew 0 4 - - eq367th NA NA McGuane, Luke 0 9 - - eq345th
Astbury, David 0 5 - - eq367th -7 -22 Vickery, Tyrone 0 9 - - eq345th
Nahas, Robin 0 6 - - eq367th -10 -109 Maric, Addam 0 10 - - eq345th
Stephenson, Orren 0 6 - - eq367th NA -22 Miller, Brad 0 10 - - eq345th
Grimes, Dylan 0 8 - - eq367th -13 -188 King, Jake 0 12 - - eq345th
Batchelor, Jake 0 9 - - eq367th -7 -22 Batchelor, Jake 0 14 - - eq345th
McGuane, Luke 0 12 - - eq367th -7 -22 Dea, Matt 0 14 - - eq345th
Ellis, Brandon 0 21 - - eq345th

 

[Rosy]

thanks heaps lee2.

 

[Tigers of Old]

Wow that would suggest Jacko has had a massively improved season.

Martin & Ellis too.

Maric has dropped right off. As has Grigg, Tuck & Foley.

 

[Rosy]

the peer voted mvp awards have heaps of respect from me

gazza 5th time mvp and by a record margin. an absolute superstar. i can't imagine the excitement of having him play for your team. 2nd in coaches award

i don't understand the vitriol towards joel selwood on here. i'd love him as a tiger. 1st most courageous player, 1st best captain and runner up mvp. 3rd in coaches award.

 

[zippadeee]

the peer voted mvp awards have heaps of respect from me

gazza 5th time mvp and by a record margin. an absolute superstar. i can't imagine the excitement of having him play for your team. 2nd in coaches award

i don't understand the vitriol towards joel selwood on here. i'd love him as a tiger. 1st most courageous player, 1st best captain and runner up mvp. 3rd in coaches award.

me too RoseZip. I would give them Deldeio and a first rounder for him
The bloke is a gun footballer