Changes V Dees | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Changes V Dees

ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS
Wrong Carter imo. Ross is a better player than that.

It is an opinion, not up for debate. I just don’t agree with you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS
Haaarrrgh. Look out, the night carter has lifted the lid n the dunny budgies have gone frantic.

Asked this question of someone else in a different thread, but it's worthy of asking again. Who n how many in the senior side the last few weeks has AFL standard kicking??? Butchered ourselves out of a few victories in recent weeks n none of it was Rossy's fault.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS

Wrong...........Jack's disposal stacks up well.........very well, against his teammates, and he's getting better.




Career Season Totals​

YearTeamGCPUPEDDE%CMMI51%BOCLCCLSCLSIMGTOITCT50TOG%
2023​
2​
5​
21​
21​
77.8​
0​
1​
3​
0​
3​
1​
2​
2​
387​
8​
3​
0​
91​
2022​
15​
74​
184​
208​
83.2​
0​
3​
21​
5​
24​
9​
15​
74​
4238​
35​
36​
3​
1032​
2021​
15​
43​
117​
120​
75.5​
1​
2​
13​
4​
12​
6​
6​
34​
2840​
28​
23​
1​
728​
2020​
7​
36​
62​
63​
67.7​
0​
0​
9​
0​
10​
6​
4​
21​
1443​
22​
15​
0​
501​
2019​
7​
48​
75​
86​
71.1​
1​
0​
9​
0​
24​
10​
14​
26​
1991​
24​
18​
0​
471​
Career
46
206
459
498
76.6
2
6
55
9
73
32
41
157
10899
117
95
4
2823
* Includes 5 games as unused substitute.
Career Season Averages​

YearTeamGCPUPEDDE%CMMI51%BOCLCCLSCLSIMGTOITCT50TOG%
2023​
2​
2.5​
10.5​
10.5​
77.8​
0​
0.5​
1.5​
0​
1.5​
0.5​
1.0​
1.0​
193.5​
4.0​
1.5​
1.0​
45.5​
2022​
15​
4.9​
12.3​
13.9​
83.2​
0​
0.2​
1.4​
0.3​
1.6​
0.6​
1.0​
4.9​
282.5​
2.3​
2.4​
4.9​
68.8​
2021​
15​
2.9​
7.8​
8.0​
75.5​
0.1​
0.1​
0.9​
0.3​
0.8​
0.4​
0.4​
2.3​
189.3​
1.9​
1.5​
2.3​
48.5​
2020​
7​
5.1​
8.9​
9.0​
67.7​
0​
0​
1.3​
0​
1.4​
0.9​
0.6​
3.0​
206.1​
3.1​
2.1​
3.0​
71.6​
2019​
7​
6.9​
10.7​
12.3​
71.1​
0.1​
0​
1.3​
0​
3.4​
1.4​
2.0​
3.7​
284.4​
3.4​
2.6​
3.7​
67.3​
Career
46
4.5
10.0
10.8
76.6
0
0.1
1.2
0.2
1.6
0.7
0.9
3.4
236.9
2.5
2.1
3.4
61.4
* Includes 5 games as unused substitute.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Haaarrrgh. Look out, the night carter has lifted the lid n the dunny budgies have gone frantic.

Asked this question of someone else in a different thread, but it's worthy of asking again. Who n how many in the senior side the last few weeks has AFL standard kicking??? Butchered ourselves out of a few victories in recent weeks n none of it was Rossy's fault.

You are a dull, slow-witted individual like many on here.

Time and again this guy has been promoted (because our depth is ordinary) and time and again he has not helped us win.

The club obviously sees his flaws because a) he takes zero risk by hand or foot and b) he cannot secure a regular berth despite a spate of injury.

When are you and others going to wake up?

The guy is a depth player at best and will not be taking us anywhere.
 
  • Dislike
Reactions: 7 users
Wrong...........Jack's disposal stacks well.........very well, against his teammates, and he's getting better.




Career Season Totals​

YearTeamGCPUPEDDE%CMMI51%BOCLCCLSCLSIMGTOITCT50TOG%
2023​
2​
5​
21​
21​
77.8​
0​
1​
3​
0​
3​
1​
2​
2​
387​
8​
3​
0​
91​
2022​
15​
74​
184​
208​
83.2​
0​
3​
21​
5​
24​
9​
15​
74​
4238​
35​
36​
3​
1032​
2021​
15​
43​
117​
120​
75.5​
1​
2​
13​
4​
12​
6​
6​
34​
2840​
28​
23​
1​
728​
2020​
7​
36​
62​
63​
67.7​
0​
0​
9​
0​
10​
6​
4​
21​
1443​
22​
15​
0​
501​
2019​
7​
48​
75​
86​
71.1​
1​
0​
9​
0​
24​
10​
14​
26​
1991​
24​
18​
0​
471​
Career
46
206
459
498
76.6
2
6
55
9
73
32
41
157
10899
117
95
4
2823
* Includes 5 games as unused substitute.
Career Season Averages​

YearTeamGCPUPEDDE%CMMI51%BOCLCCLSCLSIMGTOITCT50TOG%
2023​
2​
2.5​
10.5​
10.5​
77.8​
0​
0.5​
1.5​
0​
1.5​
0.5​
1.0​
1.0​
193.5​
4.0​
1.5​
1.0​
45.5​
2022​
15​
4.9​
12.3​
13.9​
83.2​
0​
0.2​
1.4​
0.3​
1.6​
0.6​
1.0​
4.9​
282.5​
2.3​
2.4​
4.9​
68.8​
2021​
15​
2.9​
7.8​
8.0​
75.5​
0.1​
0.1​
0.9​
0.3​
0.8​
0.4​
0.4​
2.3​
189.3​
1.9​
1.5​
2.3​
48.5​
2020​
7​
5.1​
8.9​
9.0​
67.7​
0​
0​
1.3​
0​
1.4​
0.9​
0.6​
3.0​
206.1​
3.1​
2.1​
3.0​
71.6​
2019​
7​
6.9​
10.7​
12.3​
71.1​
0.1​
0​
1.3​
0​
3.4​
1.4​
2.0​
3.7​
284.4​
3.4​
2.6​
3.7​
67.3​
Career
46
4.5
10.0
10.8
76.6
0
0.1
1.2
0.2
1.6
0.7
0.9
3.4
236.9
2.5
2.1
3.4
61.4
* Includes 5 games as unused substitute.

Why is it so hard for everyone?

In a year where speed of ball movement has never been greater, you have Ross who receives the ball and … neatly delivers by hand to someone five metres away.

Or he takes a little 15m dart pass that gets us nowhere fast.

Dustin Martin has a lowish DE but these stats have little to do with how the game unfolds on any given day.

Please let’s not rely on DE when talking about Ross.
 
Why is it so hard for everyone?

In a year where speed of ball movement has never been greater, you have Ross who receives the ball and … neatly delivers by hand to someone five metres away.

Or he takes a little 15m dart pass that gets us nowhere fast.

Dustin Martin has a lowish DE but these stats have little to do with how the game unfolds on any given day.

Please let’s not rely on DE when talking about Ross.
Ok, he must've got lucky today when he laced out McDonagh with a 40 metre pass for a goal, or when he kicked a goal himself from outside 50
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
If and when Ross is picked to play AFL he must play as a mid
Not on the wing that’s not his ideal position
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS
So Taranto is all silk mate. I reckon JRoss actually is a much better kick than him and quite a few others who are getting picked weekly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
So now we want Ross over Taranto?

I’ll have a spell, this forum is off the rails.

Ten goal belting coming up and posters will be clamouring for Ross next week.

Lol
 
Why is it so hard for everyone?

In a year where speed of ball movement has never been greater, you have Ross who receives the ball and … neatly delivers by hand to someone five metres away.

Or he takes a little 15m dart pass that gets us nowhere fast.

Dustin Martin has a lowish DE but these stats have little to do with how the game unfolds on any given day.

Please let’s not rely on DE when talking about Ross.
Far better that he uses precise medium distance disposals to put team mates into time n space rather than our senior nuffies pin pointing opposition players with long distance dump kicks or dish off scrubby half metre hand passes that simply put the receiver under extreme pressure in heavy traffic.

Rossy might never elevate above general role playing hole filler on the list, but there's jobs he could be doing now far better than some entrenched in the seniors just now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS
Sad thing about comments like this, is that over the years there's been a constant stream of us expert fans making these same sort of comments about Grigga, Bash, Towner, KMac, Presty, Nank, Short, George, Soldo, Nigel, Rossy, Raaalllph, etc etc during stages of their careers. It never stops n more often than not it's simply just wrong.
Every era there's a handful of players that are premium elite, a big bunch of players that are very good and an even bigger bunch of players that are moderately competent at AFL level and make up the bulk of most teams each year.
The game itself will sort out the wheat from the chaff, then the coaches simply try to make the best use they can of the entire mix that they have. They get it right they chase flags, get it wrong n they collect spoons n chase new jobs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
ROSS'S KICKING IS NOT AFL STANDARD

WE HAVE HAD ENOUGH OF A LOOK AT HIM

HE IS NOW LAST PICKED

FFS
You didn’t see Juddy Clarke jump out of the way of Papley last week ? Suggest you watch the 3rd Q again where Papley ran through the pack in the goal square
And he gets a game again and Ross doesn’t ? Oh boy !
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
How Jack Ross , and yeah we know his shortcomings, doesn't get an extended run in the firsts is a little beyond me ..

others get a gig who do less than him

tore it up in the VFL today against a very strong Casey Ds and basically led the team
I think it’s the price of nursing cotch to 300. I don’t like it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
Sad thing about comments like this, is that over the years there's been a constant stream of us expert fans making these same sort of comments about Grigga, Bash, Towner, KMac, Presty, Nank, Short, George, Soldo, Nigel, Rossy, Raaalllph, etc etc during stages of their careers. It never stops n more often than not it's simply just wrong.
Every era there's a handful of players that are premium elite, a big bunch of players that are very good and an even bigger bunch of players that are moderately competent at AFL level and make up the bulk of most teams each year.
The game itself will sort out the wheat from the chaff, then the coaches simply try to make the best use they can of the entire mix that they have. They get it right they chase flags, get it wrong n they collect spoons n chase new jobs.
Good post. I got Grigg wrong but he got a great go at it and was given plenty of time.
I reckon I’m still right about Nigel won’t make it ha ha.. Same with Hugo
I think Ross is being treated unfairly, basically reemed and people still see the shortcomings that were there, and refuse to see his improvement and development against the odds eg. In/out and played in awkward positions
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Dow had a good preseason to and has performed in vfl his been unlucky to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users