Bachar Houli - بشار حولي, | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Bachar Houli - بشار حولي,

I recall the same article and I'm also sure he didn't want an exception.

The thing to remember people is that it's bloody winter - the days are very short. It's not like he has to go 16 hours without something to eat.
 
Tiger Rob said:
I recall the same article and I'm also sure he didn't want an exception.

The thing to remember people is that it's bloody winter - the days are very short. It's not like he has to go 16 hours without something to eat.

No fluids would be the concern.
 
Tiger Rob said:
I recall the same article and I'm also sure he didn't want an exception.

The thing to remember people is that it's bloody winter - the days are very short. It's not like he has to go 16 hours without something to eat.

Dont forget during daylight hours during Ramadan you are not allowed to drink as well as eat.
 
GoodOne said:
I distinctly remembering a story that Basher did not want to seek permission not to obey Ramadan.

Surely he couldn't contemplate playing footy while not taking in fluids?
 
GoodOne said:
Houli did not play 1 game in Essendon seniors during Ramadan. In 2010 it ran from 10 August to 9 September and Houli played rounds 17 to 19 with 19 being on the 6th August. That was his last game (interesting to know if this is why Essendon didnt play him after Rd 19 and maybe contributed to his final decision to leave). 2009 it was from 21st August and he played last game on 8th August. Two previous years Bashar played, Ramadan was outside the footy season. I distinctly remembering a story that Basher did not want to seek permission not to obey Ramadan.

Did he play at Bendigo during those dates?
 
to settle a few things on this.

1) Basher has not had an issue with fasting during season because either Ramadan was after the H&A or he was failing to get a game.  He has however in the past obtained an exemption, so its wrong to say this is not something he will consider.  This article pre draft camp covers this decision:

http://www.smh.com.au/news/afl/not-so-fast-when-footy-and-faith-collide/2006/10/04/1159641393272.html

2) Also while he hasn't had the conflict, the Dons were preparing for it in advance.  As discussed in the below article, the intention was to slightly modify his program to minimize the distruption, and to follow the learnings obtained from Muslim professional athletes overseas.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/victoria/young-bomber-on-fast-track/story-e6frf7kx-1111114433706

Given he is devout, and has been looking into how to manage this for 4 years now, I think its safe to assume he has the info he needs, and our training staff are developing a program that gives both parties what they want.

He has shown a willingness to adjust his training times as required, and has stopped the fast (for the minimum time required) in the past, so IMO this is a massive non-issue.

EDIT - forgot to mention, discussion on the Blues forum, BF Essendon board, and the RL BF board (they were discussing because El Masri was in the same boat), all mentioned Houli had sought and gained permission to break the fast if Essendon made the finals.
 
I wonder how the Bumber fans are feeling now.

They were sticking the boots in early in the season. I think they'd rather Houli kicking from half-back over Stanton right about now. ;D
 
Tiger74 said:
to settle a few things on this.

1) Basher has not had an issue with fasting during season because either Ramadan was after the H&A or he was failing to get a game. He has however in the past obtained an exemption, so its wrong to say this is not something he will consider. This article pre draft camp covers this decision:

http://www.smh.com.au/news/afl/not-so-fast-when-footy-and-faith-collide/2006/10/04/1159641393272.html

2) Also while he hasn't had the conflict, the Dons were preparing for it in advance. As discussed in the below article, the intention was to slightly modify his program to minimize the distruption, and to follow the learnings obtained from Muslim professional athletes overseas.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/victoria/young-bomber-on-fast-track/story-e6frf7kx-1111114433706

Given he is devout, and has been looking into how to manage this for 4 years now, I think its safe to assume he has the info he needs, and our training staff are developing a program that gives both parties what they want.

He has shown a willingness to adjust his training times as required, and has stopped the fast (for the minimum time required) in the past, so IMO this is a massive non-issue.

EDIT - forgot to mention, discussion on the Blues forum, BF Essendon board, and the RL BF board (they were discussing because El Masri was in the same boat), all mentioned Houli had sought and gained permission to break the fast if Essendon made the finals.

So Houli has or will be gaining a fasting exemption this Ramadan is what you are saying? If so then this certainly nips this discussion in the bud ;D
 
He received an exemption for draft camp, and got one in case the dons made the finals. Refutes your claim that he has refused to break the fast at all.

As for this year, given he dealt with the issue previously, why do you think he won't now?
 
I am much more optimistic about free agency seeing us go out and get value from guys like Houli, Grigg and Miller without having to give up much. The club is clearly doing its homework on how can come in and play a role for us.
 
Tiger74 said:
He received an exemption for draft camp, and got one in case the dons made the finals. Refutes your claim that he has refused to break the fast at all.

As for this year, given he dealt with the issue previously, why do you think he won't now?

I didn't claim anything and never said he wouldn't. I was just asking the question based on remembering having read somewhere in an article not long after he was drafetd that he did not want to ask for an exemption. Therefore I assumed this was the case. If he is fine with it, then as I said in my previous post, end of discussion.
 
wayne said:
I wonder how the Bumber fans are feeling now.

They were sticking the boots in early in the season. I think they'd rather Houli kicking from half-back over Stanton right about now. ;D

They booed him when we played them. Just goes to show how moronic they are. Their team wouldnt give him a game when they were gifting games to no hopers ahead of him.

We are playing the bloke and lo-and-nehold he is performing greatly.
 
Tigers of Old said:
Amazing PSD pick up.

Gold Coast selections aside, he's arguably the recruit of the year.

Yep, not bad when the guy steps in as PSD and is as reliable off half back as your Captain - they both spot up a man superbly.
 
LidsBling&Cotch said:
not sure you're just playing devils advocate goody

I was genuinely interested how he would handle the rigours of AFL footy while fasting. Not an issue as he is not fasting.
 
Houli is embarrassing the pants off Ess right now. Stanton, jeepers, what a turnover merchant.