It's weird, my knock on Bachar has always been the exact opposite.
I really don't think he's soft. He's also been extremely important in our very lean patch this year in throwing himself into contests and keeping the ball in front of him, and pushing it out of our backline.
Unfortunately, he's a poor user of the ball when he gets space. Almost always goes long to a contest, or an outnumber, and usually leads to repeat reentries for the opposition.
IF our best 22 is fit, we may look for an upgrade. I'd have Short in his role. At the moment, he's a must have in. You need to maintain a level of experience, match fitness, old man hardness and leadership in your onfield 22, and he's almost all of it at the moment.