2019 All Australian | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2019 All Australian

Tom Stewart is the new Corey Enright. Just became the permanent HBF nominee. Not that I didn't like Enright, he was a gun and a different class to Stewart, who IMO has never impressed in the big games. Especially against us.

Ablett? Seriously he has played some really poor games at times, it has to be about your whole years performance?

great post. Enright was a champ, and AA a couple of times no doubt, but every single bloody year? Joke, made a mockery of AA. Stewart has stepped into the breech it seems.
 
here's one for ya L2, I wonder how the coaches votes correlate or don't correlate with the AA squad?

Not sure but on the AFL Player ratings Tom Stewart is assessed as a key defender (Jack & Tom say yes please) and is ranked the 295th player.

There are 59 small/medium defenders rated higher than him in the ratings. Not sure he should be that low but he's behind around 8-10 HBF's IMO. I understand they all play slightly different roles but Vlastuin is better playing the floating role, a better user and a better ball handler whilst Grimes is better as a pure defender. If Tom Stewart gets the nod over Grimes for the 3rd medium defender (I think Hurn/Siciliy will get 2 of the 3 medium defender spots) it will be disappointing.
 
I'm with most here. couldn't give a toss about the AA. happy 4 of the boys got a nod. think Nick V and Sheds are far superior to several of those picked.
 
I'm with most here. couldn't give a toss about the AA. happy 4 of the boys got a nod. think Nick V and Sheds are far superior to several of those picked.

I’m with you 110%, it means jackshit to me, but I think it’s good to see your players rewarded for a good season.
Have a look at Edwards, he has gone up another level since being an AA.
I think Big V should’ve been in the team, but being a 2 time premiership player might mean a bit more.
 
Treloar? Seriously? So just running really fast and blasting the ball forward anywhere gets you an AA nomination?


Yep. Biggest turn over merchant in the game.
Selected just on stats?
Who on the committee? Robert Walls?
 
Yep. Biggest turn over merchant in the game.
Selected just on stats?
Who on the committee? Robert Walls?

throws must be a key criteria this year (I actually don;t mind Treloar, he's not on his Pat Malone as a power mid with less than perfect disposal, and I don't blame him for getting away with what he can to get an edge, but he is the throwing king of the AFL. Its an umpiring issue. Pay a couple and he'll stop).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Yep. Biggest turn over merchant in the game.
Selected just on stats?
Who on the committee? Robert Walls?

He is a midfielder,
Is he better then Martin?
Bompetelly
Cripps
Fyfe
Neale
Congilio
Dangerfield
Kelly
Ross

If the answer is No, he won’t make the side.
 
here's one for ya L2, I wonder how the coaches votes correlate or don't correlate with the AA squad?

Need to break these in half as there's a character limit...

2019 (after 20 games):

PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Bontempelli, MarcusWB931st143413122212623y274d
Kelly, TimGe862nd12232311224525y29d
Fyfe, NathanFr833rd1313411122017327y341d
Cripps, PatrickCa784th1141121112010124y159d
Shuey, LukeWC765th102311212219929y83d
Neale, LachieBr736th11421132215726y93d
Dangerfield, PatrickGe727th124211132124529y141d
Grundy, BrodieCo688th1113221112213025y130d
Boak, TravisPA679th1031121112126431y24d
Cunnington, BenNM6510th92111312220928y55d
Macrae, JacksonWB6411st1013121112214025y22d
Dunkley, JoshWB62eq 12nd1043111226522y228d
Yeo, ElliotWC62eq 12nd113113212115325y327d
Gawn, MaxMe60eq 14th92212112112027y237d
Prestia, DionRi60eq 14th10212111112215226y317d
Zorko, DayneBr5816th1022121112216630y197d
Martin, DustinRi5717th91231112022128y60d
Pendlebury, ScottCo5318th102112312229931y228d
Cameron, CharlieBr5219th8213112210625y51d
Cameron, JeremyWS4722nd8311122015026y145d
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Sicily, JamesHa4623rd82111111228224y230d
Ablett junior, GaryGe44eq 27th911111312134235y102d
Walters, MichaelFr44eq 27th613112215128y230d
Darling, JackWC42eq 31st7121212219427y72d
Treloar, AdamCo41eq 33rd8321112216126y167d
Gaff, AndrewWC38eq 36th91221122019527y69d
McCluggage, HughBr36eq 41st711221216121y175d
Hawkins, TomGe31eq 57th7111222225431y34d
Houli, BacharRi31eq 57th6111211920431y105d
Andrews, HarrisBr30eq 62nd711212199522y257d
Brown, BenNM30eq 62nd612212212126y277d
Stewart, ThomasGe2870th91224226526y162d
Grimes, DylanRi27eq 71st711322114828y40d
Blicavs, MarkGe21eq 88th612212215528y149d
Hurn, ShannonWC21eq 88th31111926731y354d
Sheppard, BradWC20eq 94th4222217628y93d
Haynes, NickWS17eq 106th511121912427y98d
McGovern, JeremyWC17eq 106th511122112427y131d
Rampe, DaneSy11eq 144th61322115929y83d
Talia, DanielAd1eq 299th112218627y327d
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
2018

PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Gawn, Max*Me971st13521211111229626y239d
Cripps, Patrick*Ca912nd12414111228123y160d
Mitchell, Tom*Ha883rd14431111222210925y86d
Grundy, Brodie*Co824th142123121212210424y132d
Beams, DayneBr72eq 5th123123122116828y195d
Macrae, JacksonWB72eq 5th12311122111911824y22d
Oliver, Clayton*Me72eq 5th1121221121225721y35d
Martin, Dustin*Ri70eq 8th151231211322119927y60d
Whitfield, Lachie*WS70eq 8th111222121112211224y39d
Higgins, Shaun*NM6711st112112111112020330y175d
Gaff, Andrew*WC65eq 12nd141122111141917526y71d
Laird, Rory*Ad65eq 12nd1211241212012124y239d
Sidebottom, Steele*Co6414th1122211211112220727y235d
Pendlebury, ScottCo62eq 15th131121211222127330y230d
Yeo, ElliotWC62eq 15th941111112212924y329d
Dangerfield, Patrick*Ge60eq 17th15243512122328y142d
Lambert, KaneRi5619th91112211207226y272d
Cotchin, TrentRi4926th7212112021828y140d
Breust, Luke*Ha48eq 27th912121112218327y287d
De Goey, JordanCo48eq 27th81111113176722y163d
 
PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Neale, LachieFr48eq 27th82112112213525y93d
Riewoldt, Jack*Ri48eq 27th1021212212224729y298d
Ward, CallanWS4532nd1021113212221428y138d
Franklin, Lance*Sy44eq 33rd9311131828931y207d
Smith, DevonEs44eq 33rd102112132213125y96d
Gray, Robbie*PA42eq 36th712222119930y147d
Lloyd, JakeSy42eq 36th1011112222211424y339d
Brown, BenNM40eq 40th7211111229925y279d
Hurn, Shannon*WC40eq 40th71112122224530y356d
Hawkins, TomGe39eq 43rd7211212023130y35d
Edwards, Shane*Ri38eq 45th71112112222929y304d
Gunston, Jack*Ha38eq 45th911221212117026y313d
Stewart, Thomas*Ge35eq 59th7111121214225y163d
Rance, Alex*Ri30eq 67th621212219728y320d
Caddy, JoshRi2970th51132013725y331d
McGovern, Jeremy*WC27eq 72nd6111312110026y133d
Andrews, HarrisBr23eq 82nd711113187621y258d
Jonas, TomPA22eq 88th51311812127y227d
Blicavs, MarkGe14eq 130th5412213227y150d
Grimes, DylanRi11eq 164th4111112112527y40d
 
2017

PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Martin, Dustin*Ri1221st15834212217526y62d
Dangerfield, Patrick*Ge1182nd16632121112119927y143d
Sloane, RoryAd783rd112232212216327y163d
Merrett, Zachary*Es774th11331211218021y328d
Mitchell, Tom*Ha765th132232211228724y86d
Kelly, Joshua*WS756th1251213218122y195d
Crouch, Matt*Ad68eq 8th14111133311226922y128d
Ross, SebastianSt68eq 8th102211211228124y112d
Zorko, Dayne*Br68eq 8th11331222112228y198d
Franklin, Lance*Sy6711st10311111122226930y208d
Bontempelli, MarcusWB6612nd915111228521y274d
Yeo, Elliot*WC6313rd121311111212110523y330d
Ryder, Patrick*PA62eq 14th1512134222120929y165d
Selwood, Joel*Ge61eq 16th1021211211824629y92d
Kennedy, Josh P.Sy5820th1132121121920229y67d
Kennedy, Josh J.*WC51eq 24th82112111720530y2d
Shiel, Dylan*WS51eq 24th1112231112210924y170d
Brown, BenNM48eq 30th811213227724y279d
Kreuzer, MatthewCa48eq 30th14111112252116128y105d
Gray, Robbie*PA47eq 32nd731212217729y149d
 
PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Treloar, AdamCo47eq 32nd1011112132112224y170d
Rance, Alex*Ri4636th822121122217227y322d
Daniher, Joe*Es4439th6411229223y176d
Walker, TaylorAd42eq 40th7221112015027y124d
Docherty, Sam*Ca39eq 44th612111229223y313d
Laird, Rory*Ad39eq 44th811112111229823y241d
Hibberd, Michael*Me38eq 50th7211121810227y235d
Hurley, Michael*Es38eq 50th91112222013927y87d
Jacobs, SamAd37eq 54th61111112217129y139d
McGovern, Jeremy*WC33eq 61st731112227725y134d
Greene, TobyWS25eq 79th5111111611423y335d
Lever, JakeAd25eq 79th611112175321y175d
Lynch, Tom T.Ad22eq 90th5112122010326y346d
Roberton, DylanSt22eq 90th611312212426y67d
Howe, JeremyCo20eq 98th612122114127y58d
Betts, Eddie*Ad19eq 102nd4111112127430y274d
Scully, TomWS16eq 120th41212114826y103d
Jonas, TomPA14eq 134th511122110326y229d
Garlett, JeffMe6eq 213rd112116728y23d
Jetta, NevilleMe4eq 242nd3122211627y195d
 
2016

PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Dangerfield, Patrick*Ge1211st1951114131132217626y144d
Sloane, Rory*Ad932nd14231112312113926y162d
Martin, Dustin*Ri903rd1343121112215325y62d
Bontempelli, Marcus*WB884th12531121225920y278d
Parker, Luke*Sy86eq 5th15222111332212323y307d
Selwood, Joel*Ge86eq 5th12323242222628y93d
Hannebery, Daniel*Sy837th151223211412216625y185d
Shuey, LukeWC828th1241122112213326y85d
Kennedy, Josh J.*WC69eq 10th102131122218729y1d
Kennedy, Josh P.*Sy69eq 10th13313124112117928y68d
Mitchell, SamHa68eq 12nd1112221212030533y321d
Pendlebury, ScottCo68eq 12nd12113111132223628y234d
Betts, Eddie*Ad67eq 14th93131112225129y274d
Lynch, Tom J.*GC67eq 14th13121321122210223y301d
Steven, JackSt67eq 14th1122212112213426y153d
Franklin, Lance*Sy64eq 17th1331142222224329y210d
Treloar, AdamCo64eq 17th12212112122210123y172d
Gawn, Max*Me63eq 19th9221211226124y241d
Gaff, AndrewWC5524th1021122112113124y71d
Coniglio, StephenWS5326th11111211113218322y256d
 
PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Enright, Corey*Ge51eq 27th10111211212133034y348d
Neale, LachieFr51eq 27th11111111122229223y96d
Laird, RoryAd47eq 31st91112121177422y241d
Rioli, Cyril*Ha38eq 42nd81121121917627y45d
Rance, Alex*Ri37eq 44th512112015026y323d
Scully, TomWS37eq 44th81212212212525y104d
Greene, Toby*WS35eq 48th711132219622y337d
Ward, CallanWS35eq 48th71211112216526y139d
Lynch, Tom T.Ad34eq 52nd711231218125y346d
Simpson, KadeCa31eq 57th91112222226432y114d
Shaw, Heath*WS29eq 61st821322223530y274d
Tarrant, RobbieNM29eq 61st5122228327y124d
Jenkins, JoshAd28eq 65th422229127y200d
Docherty, SamCa2772nd912123227022y315d
Boyd, Matthew*WB26eq 73rd711232027834y1d
Gunston, JackHa25eq 76th6112112212524y317d
McGovern, Jeremy*WC25eq 76th82132215424y133d
Rampe, Dane*Sy23eq 88th61123229426y86d
Talia, Daniel*Ad23eq 88th711242212024y329d
Pittard, JasperPA17eq 109th5311229825y148d
 
2015

PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Hannebery, Daniel*Sy1011st1432213212214224y193d
Fyfe, Nathan*Fr1002nd13613121811023y352d
Kennedy, Josh P.Sy873rd1242111122215627y77d
Priddis, Matt*WC754th141211222122219530y168d
Gaff, Andrew*WC745th14114311122210723y81d
Goldstein, Todd*NM73eq 6th113221212114627y65d
Mundy, David*Fr73eq 6th10431112123130y47d
Mitchell, Sam*Ha698th11312111112028132y328d
Pendlebury, ScottCo679th11332122221427y242d
Dangerfield, Patrick*Ad6510th1211112121112115225y153d
Gray, Robbie*PA61eq 12nd1321132222113627y159d
Martin, DustinRi61eq 12nd1021112212213024y70d
Wingard, Chad*PA5815th1211523228922y38d
Naitanui, NicWC5317th8122122012825y124d
Rance, Alex*Ri5118th911121122212925y330d
Deledio, Brett*Ri48eq 20th71211111723128y139d
Kennedy, Josh J.*WC48eq 20th74122216228y11d
Hill, StephenFr47eq 22nd9211111112114925y127d
Neale, LachieFr44eq 27th91111131226822y104d
Swan, DaneCo44eq 27th921111122125731y193d
 
PlayerClubVotesRankPolled10987654321GmsCareerAge
Stringer, Jake*WB43eq 32nd8111131214921y133d
Hurley, Michael*Es42eq 35th912111211911925y97d
Gunston, JackHa41eq 40th9111111122210123y324d
Cameron, JeremyWS38eq 49th63111227322y158d
Higgins, ShaunNM36eq 54th7121122115027y184d
Rioli, Cyril*Ha36eq 54th5111112015326y53d
Walker, TaylorAd35eq 59th6211112110525y133d
Murphy, Robert*WB34eq 61st81211212029133y88d
Wood, Easton*WB3267th811222218626y1d
Betts, Eddie*Ad31eq 68th6111212122728y283d
Boyd, MatthewWB31eq 68th712221825733y9d
Gibson, Josh*Ha30eq 73rd81111222118631y176d
Lewis, JordanHa26eq 84th62221923629y134d
Dahlhaus, LukeWB24eq 88th711113229323y15d
McGovern, JeremyWC24eq 88th41111173023y143d
Riewoldt, Jack*Ri23eq 94th42112217926y308d
Laird, RoryAd21eq 102nd811222215521y250d
Shaw, Heath*WS20eq 106th6211112221329y283d
Burgoyne, ShaunHa14eq 138th511122229132y319d
Ibbotson, GarrickFr7eq 208th5232214927y174d