jb03 said:
Are the games in HD?
Do all games have the alternative commentaries?
If so, are the alternative radio commentaries synced?
Have only had a quick look but the news is all bad. Bear in mind that I haven't watched any DVD in a fair while, let alone footy.
- Only the GF disc contains radio commentaries.
- The radio commentaries seem out of sync (behind by 1-2 seconds) - same as the reports on the standalone DVD. I had assumed this could be corrected by the BRP settings - 'A/V sync' on mine - but having never had the need to use it before, discovered that the adjustment range is only up to 200 ms. Not sufficient to cancel out the delay which is somewhat distracting.
- The picture quality is not great. As for "HD"... not sure DVDs are issued in HD anymore? Certainly, the picture quality is below that on a Foxtel h&a match telecast. And as stated elsewhere, the long angle shots are particularly dire. The fixed cameras while play is in progress are better, but the overhead one on the wires, and the roaming cameras out on the ground before play produce a lower quality picture. My disc player has Darbee processing; applying this at a low level resulted in a modest improvement, but cranking it up produced artefacts.
- The first two finals are labelled 'QUALIFYING FINAL 2' and 'PRELIMINARY FINAL 2', but the GF disc is labelled simply 'RICHMOND'
I'm left with the feeling that something was not right during the production process. I'll need to watch a few other DVDs to be sure.
It was a great relief to put on the GF Blu-Ray where the picture was superb. The difference from the DVD was night and day. Although I haven't been in the habit of watching DVD's lately, I have never noticed this big a difference. The BR picture is good enough that, as the players are going to their positions for Q3, you can see what looks like grease on Martin & Houli's jumpers (to slip past tackles?).
Curiously, the BR has the same audio delay on the radio calls, which led me to wonder whether they naturally call "behind the play" on the radio? Not convinced though.
The wash-up of all this is that I'm joining the chorus for a BR Victory Pack and Season Pack!