2004 Player of the Year | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2004 Player of the Year

Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

Based on the one-and-half quarters I saw before I spat the dummy:

-3 entire RFC excepting the new kids (from what I read in today's dailies)
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3 - Fleming.. Was given another chance & he proved he wanted to play not like other washed up senior players.

2. Brown... I hate to think if we didn't draft him how worse we would be.

3. KRak... just magic

(Just missed vote were Hart).. Roach tried hard but should have been put on the field to start.
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

Newman said:
3). Krakouer by a country mile

2). Flemming - first and last time his name will appear here.

1). Hyde. Did a couple decent things which is more than most others.

No appologies warranted for anyone else.
Click to expand...

I am far from a footy guru/expert but how can you possibly rate Hyde's 6 possessions above Brown's 29 and a goal.
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3-Krakouer (the only one worth paying to watch)
2-Fleming (deadset had a dip)
1-Brown (earning his money)
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3. Fleming ( Heart- enough said )

2. Brown ( made the most of his possessions-class act )

1. Hartigan ( Coghlan with better skills )

Apologies to Andrew Krakouer ( two very good goals ) and Aaron Fiora ( ran hard ). Ottens had a very good first half but drifted out of it a bit.
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

Fleming 3
Krak 2
Hartigan 1

Brown played ok but got some easy ball as well as 7 clangers!!!
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3 votes - "Jam Tin" Fleming - even his disposals were good :eek: :eek:

2 votes - Browny - would we have even scored if he wasn't there?

1 vote - Fiona - did everything that was asked of him in about 5 different positions (of which the wing was where he did best and should have stayed).

Apologies to Krak, who had one good half, Harts and the umpires who made sure it wasn't a total debacle in the second half.
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

From a poor game...
3- Flemmo... hard at it all night
2- Browny... good around the ground
1- Krak-man and Harts... have to share one, Krak for 2nd half, Harts for when he was given a go.

Otherwise... what was on the umps mind in the second half...?
4-14 frees against RFC for the 1st half, and then all kinds of soft junk fress to us in the second half.

Dont tell me they dont look at stats!
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3 Fleming. Ran all night. Only bloke who seemed to want to be there.
2 Krakouer
1 Hartigan
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

Roar34 said:
Based on the one-and-half quarters I saw before I spat the dummy:

-3 entire RFC excepting the new kids (from what I read in today's dailies)
Click to expand...

The end for me was when Chaffey delivered to the chest of a Crow 30ms out from the kick in. I got up out of my seat and told my mates that I would be at the bar if they wanted to find me.

I feel supremely sorry for Brownie who is starting to have the look of someone that is asking himself, "What have i done by coming to the tiges", but he is a pro and gets the 3 from me.

Harto was next best for me and gets the 2, he is fast becoming probably the only reason that i still get to the games, love the way he runs straight and hard.

And the much maligned Tim Fleming gets the 1, well i have never quite understood why he gets a game but i would never dispute the guys commitment to the cause, he is something like an Andy Goodwin, no skill but would run through a brick wall for the tiges, good on you Flemo.
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3 votes - Brown
2 votes - Krak
1 vote - Fleming

Apols - Harto.

Never to play again - Bowden
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

It is hard to give votes after a game like that but I will give it ago.




3. Krak

2. Brown

1. Fleming and like 3aw said 1 more vote to all Richmond fans that stayed to the end like i did :)
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

3.Brown
2.Hartigan
1.Flemming :eek:
 
Re: Player Of The Year Votes Round 5 Vs. Crows

1. Hartingan
2. Flemming
3. Krak
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< Player of the Year voting system | Coaches votes this week >
Official PRE merch now on Redbubble!
Top Bottom