I say insufficient intent
yeah he will only be fined and should play IMO
I say insufficient intent
Absolutely I did. Huge miss.Buggered if I remember. Probably you.
Didn't you love Mathieson that draft?
The two narratives that Greene is hard done by and clumsy mummy are pretty bizarre.Having watched the enhanced footage on Fox lastnight, both close up and from down the ground. ... I'm starting to think he's some (miniscule) sort of chance to get off. (I had to tune out of Brad Johnson's 3 to 4 week rant)
To begin with, Matt Stevic doesn't seem all that fazed by the interaction. .. mind you, had it been Razor he would've executed a perfect reverse double somersault as he reached for the book, giving him a detailed explanation whilst spinning. .. (degree of difficulty 9.7)
Regardless, he's a *smile* head for putting himself in that position. As much as I love him as a player, if he was ours it would do my head in knowing he's always a brain fart away from suspension!
Initially the vision looked like he walked straight through him but the slo-mo is more favourable. Stevic would know how much contact there was.Having watched the enhanced footage on Fox lastnight, both close up and from down the ground. ... I'm starting to think he's some (miniscule) sort of chance to get off. (I had to tune out of Brad Johnson's 3 to 4 week rant)
To begin with, Matt Stevic doesn't seem all that fazed by the interaction. .. mind you, had it been Razor he would've executed a perfect reverse double somersault as he reached for the book, giving him a detailed explanation whilst spinning. .. (degree of difficulty 9.7)
Regardless, he's a *smile* head for putting himself in that position. As much as I love him as a player, if he was ours it would do my head in knowing he's always a brain fart away from suspension!
Having watched the enhanced footage on Fox lastnight, both close up and from down the ground. ... I'm starting to think he's some (miniscule) sort of chance to get off. (I had to tune out of Brad Johnson's 3 to 4 week rant)
.........................
Stevic did not flinch, withdraw or respond at all, Id suggest very little if any contactInitially the vision looked like he walked straight through him but the slo-mo is more favourable. Stevic would know how much contact there was.
I thought he'd get a week at first but thinking just a fine now. Good for the Giant$. Not so good for Geelong.
Game of chances in the 3rd Hogan kicks 2 goals and not posters it was probably game over they were on top and that would have put them 6 maybe 7 goals up. Certainly slowed down in the lastOne of the luckiest wins you’ll ever see I reckon. That last quarter by the Giants was pathetic. They didn’t try to win; just hung on for grim death and got lucky that the Swans couldn’t kick straight. Whitfield is supposed to be a beautiful kick but turned it over straight to Swans players twice in last 5 minutes.
If the suggestions he didn't a actually touch Stevic are true i will retract my statement he should get 4 weeks. And offer my sincerest apologies to Greene.I'm not sure 'proper mental' is the right term, but i know someone who knew him as a school kid. From what i have heard i reckon there is a fair chance he has something diagnosable.
On first viewing i thought there had to be some reasonable explanation. But hearing his lack of excuse he is gone. Should be about 4 weeks.
I expect GWS will appeal, hopefully they can drag it out and he can play this week.
Stevic provides the evidence and then they decide. You can see there wasn't much in it. He does have the elbow one to explain though.It's not up to Stevic and nor should it be.
Having seen the other footage it seems like there's not much in it though.
Stevic provides the evidence and then they decide. You can see there wasn't much in it. He does have the elbow one to explain though.
Hard to see anyone stopping Melbourne now unfortunately. Looked in very good nick last night.
Agree Ant.Stevic would only provide evidence if there was a penalty and GWS appealed. The MRP reviews the video and applies a penalty, or not.
Given that second angle no case to answer, unless they consider Toby walking through where Stevic would have been some form of misconduct. It will be a fine or nothing, and Stevic is unlikely to be involved.