Umpire farce - Getting worse by the minute! | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Umpire farce - Getting worse by the minute!

RoyceHart said:
Richmond fined $5k for abusive comments from a trainer to an umpire after the Freo game.

Lucky they don't fine the club for some of the supporter comments... ;D

A quote from Adrian Anderson about this was "All match-day staff are required to adhere to a clear set of guidelines in relation to their conduct towards umpires"

The bit that should be added onto the end of that sentence is "irrespective of how badly the umpires perform their role on the day".

An umpire can cost a team a game and there is no repercussions.
 
Vlad has accused the Carlton players of 'Umpire bashing' for these 2 tweets.

'Ruined a good game those blokes'

'R u not meant to try to b first in at the footy anymore? If u do u will b pinned for holding the ball. Shocking!!!

http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/afl/tweets-land-blues-in-hot-water/story-e6frepgf-1226396530309

Since when did a bit of criticism become umpire bashing? It's not like they called them maggots or anything, just criticised their officiating. But no-ones allowed to tell the emperor he's got no clothes.
 
Azza said:
Vlad has accused the Carlton players of 'Umpire bashing' for these 2 tweets.

'Ruined a good game those blokes'

'R u not meant to try to b first in at the footy anymore? If u do u will b pinned for holding the ball. Shocking!!!

http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/afl/tweets-land-blues-in-hot-water/story-e6frepgf-1226396530309

Since when did a bit of criticism become umpire bashing? It's not like they called them maggots or anything, just criticised their officiating. But no-ones allowed to tell the emperor he's got no clothes.

AFL and Vlad are a joke, what sports Administration in the entire world carries on like this when a few players make a comment about a game.

What do we live in 1980's communist Russia or something.
 
tiges said:
AFL and Vlad are a joke, what sports Administration in the entire world carries on like this when a few players make a comment about a game.

What do we live in 1980's communist Russia or something.

It looks like. What happened to free speech and feedback? Even a simple comment on the internet disturbs these over-protective morons.
 
Looks like it wasn't just the fans giving it to the umpires after the game last week.

Injured Blues Marc Murphy and Jeremy Laidler say sorry for Twitter outburst
AAP From: Herald Sun June 15, 2012 6:38PM

CARLTON players Marc Murphy and Jeremy Laidler have apologised to the AFL after the injured pair's outbursts fuelled fans' anger over umpiring decisions.
And Richmond has been fined $5000 after one of its trainers abused a field umpire in the aftermath of last weekend's narrow loss to Fremantle.
AFL chief Andrew Demetriou says they are likely to face fines for their statements on Twitter after Carlton's loss to West Coast on Thursday night.

"I understand (AFL general manager of football operations) Adrian Anderson is preparing a 'please explain' letter to both of those gentlemen," Demetriou told reporters on Friday.

"Everyone knows commenting on umpires, whether it's through Facebook, Twitter, email, press conference, over a radio interview is unacceptable.

"There's zero tolerance about that."

The Blues released a statement late on Friday afternoon saying both players agreed their comments were unfortunate.

"I was certainly frustrated and confused by how the rule was being applied, as were the commentators," Laidler
said.

"However it was not meant to be derogatory of the umpire."

Laidler and Murphy stressed they had great respect for umpires.

"I understand my tweet could have been interpreted as criticism towards umpires and, in hindsight, should have considered the wording more," Murphy said.

Demetriou said the AFL found it extremely difficult to recruit umpires.

"We will not accept any criticism of umpires and everyone knows that," he said.

"Our players know that and they've been told about social media and its pitfalls.

"Adrian will deal with it. There's really no excuse to be talking about umpires.

"Normally in these situations, there would be a financial sanction."

Fans have raged on Twitter that the AFL is stifling freedom of speech by banning players' comments on umpires.
But Demetriou said he didn't buy the argument.

"Freedom of speech has to come with some responsibility," Demetriou said.

"If we were all allowed to say everything we wanted to say, we'd be in a bit of strife, particularly me."

As for Richmond, AFL football operations manager Adrian Anderson said the league chose to impose the financial sanction on the Tigers, as head coach Damien Hardwick had also approached the umpires during a recent game.

The latest incident was brought to the AFL's attention after it was included in a report by the umpires.

"All match-day staff are required to adhere to a clear set of guidelines in relation to their conduct towards umpires,'' Anderson said.


"It is important that the AFL continues to take a zero tolerance approach in dealing with umpire abuse, as a negative match-day environment is still the primary factor impacting on the recruitment and retention of umpires in community football across Australia.''

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/teams/injured-blues-marc-murphy-and-jeremy-laidler-say-sorry-for-twitter-outburst/story-e6frf9k6-1226396530309
 
Sieg..... HEIL !

"Freedom of speech has to come with some responsibility," Demetriou said

Sorry Adolf, there is none in the AFL as you say; "Everyone knows commenting on umpires, whether it's through Facebook, Twitter, email, press conference, over a radio interview is unacceptable."There's zero tolerance about that."

Maybe correct the cause of the problem NOT the effect of the problem and you just might solve this stupid situation we are in.
 
Al Bundy said:
Sieg..... HEIL !

"Freedom of speech has to come with some responsibility," Demetriou said

Sorry Adolf, there is none in the AFL as you say; "Everyone knows commenting on umpires, whether it's through Facebook, Twitter, email, press conference, over a radio interview is unacceptable."There's zero tolerance about that."

Maybe correct the cause of the problem NOT the effect of the problem and you just might solve this stupid situation we are in.

Get ready for the Big Brother on fans in years to come. Every seat at the ground will be tapped. Anything you say will be a fine.
 
Geisch Vladimir and Anderson can thank their lucky stars that those maggots are officiating here in oz, cause we are a forgiving lot, Image there same umps officiating a game in Europe or South America :veryupset :fire :hmm :boxing.
 
Vlads seen the big pot of gold growing at Punt Road and wanted a slice of it. :hihi

Are we the only team(on Earth) that never gets a home ground advantage with the umps?


Shocking umpiring last week and the last quarter the week before that.
Havent even mentioned McBurney or Bannisters terrible shonky umpiring efforts either.

Have now.

;D

Geppeto and Pinocchio, Adolf and Goebbels.
 
Al Bundy said:
Sieg..... HEIL !

"Freedom of speech has to come with some responsibility," Demetriou said

Sorry Adolf, there is none in the AFL as you say; "Everyone knows commenting on umpires, whether it's through Facebook, Twitter, email, press conference, over a radio interview is unacceptable."There's zero tolerance about that."

Maybe correct the cause of the problem NOT the effect of the problem and you just might solve this stupid situation we are in.


Would the players of the afl have any legal standing against this ?
Surely like other posters have said, people in this country have a right to freedom of speech , those rights are
Being repressed by AFL gagging what anyone can say. I realise it's a sport but still it's ridiculous .
 
im sympathetic towards umpires...i used to umpire footy and cricket..
its a bloody tough..unthnakful task
but s*&t..even i think the upriring in the esssendon...the saints and the freo game against us was particularly strange to the point of paranoid conspiracy theory..

making up rules as they went along in some cases.."justin free...ivan you jumped and came down before you tapped the ball"...
wtf
 
arlobill said:
im sympathetic towards umpires...i used to umpire footy and cricket..
its a bloody tough..unthnakful task
but s*&t..even i think the upriring in the esssendon...the saints and the freo game against us was particularly strange to the point of paranoid conspiracy theory..

making up rules as they went along in some cases.."justin free...ivan you jumped and came down before you tapped the ball"...
wtf

Yeah that's one I couldn't believe and am still waiting on an explanation to be handed down from Gieschen.
Simply gobsmacked.
 
There has been some staggering frees either paid or not. The subjective one of deliberate is hilarious, Power was obvious Rance wasn't.
 
LOL @ those who think we have no right in blaming umpires...get some glasses folks and look what at what they do to us more often than not...pitch invasion required ASAP!

Rats!!!