For mine we take the 2 picks to the Draft, in a shallow draft we currently could get 3 picks inside 30 incl Naish.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Trading two draft choices for a single player. Nup.
- Thread starter Dyer'ere
- Start date
Tony Braxton-Hicks said:
Here's some research based on the St Kilda decision to knock pick 4 & 7 and instead take McCartin. It's not quite the same but makes for interesting reading.
bullus_hit said:
yep, we could even trade into 2nd round i'd reckon that'd be handy too. end up with 4 picks inside 30-35ish for exampleTT33 said:
Trade scuttlebutt on Twitter
Sources close to Richmond have told me? The dees have proposed a trade of 10 + 27 for 15 +17 to assist in lever deal #AFLTrades #exclusive
Sources close to Richmond have told me? The dees have proposed a trade of 10 + 27 for 15 +17 to assist in lever deal #AFLTrades #exclusive
Ghost of Punt Road
Tiger Champion
DirtyDogTiger said:
Don't mind it but it definitely is better for them. If we could go 15, 17 + 50 for 10, 27 and their 2nd next year then I'd be stoked. Move 1 first above a Naish bid. Use Melbournes 2nd on Naish and gain an extra pick in the 2nd round next year. All good.
DirtyDogTiger said:
15 & 17 = 2137 points (ours)
10 & 27= 2098 points (theirs)
"Tell em they're dreamin " Bloody cheapskates. You want our picks? Cough up, no discount, they need to pay a premium, we're not here to make it easy for them. Just remember when they tried to flog off a damaged Trengove to us.
Somebody's quoting zippers as a source close to Richmond, or is he tweeting his own rumours.DirtyDogTiger said:
Reckon either of these we should go back to Melbourne with
In Picks 10, 27 and their 2018 2nd (lets say Pick 31) = 2704 points
Out Picks 15, 17 and 50 = 2410 points
Adds a 2nd next year and gets points for Naish. Pick 27 and 53 has all bases pretty much covered
Or
In Picks 10, 45 and their 2018 2nd (lets say Pick 31) = 2348 points
Out Picks 15 and 17 = 2137 points
Still gives us the 2nd next year and also gives us an extra 3rd for Naish. Picks 45, 50 and 53 will also have us covered, we'll just have to go into the draft with an extra spot on the list than the 1st option which is why I prefer that one.
In Picks 10, 27 and their 2018 2nd (lets say Pick 31) = 2704 points
Out Picks 15, 17 and 50 = 2410 points
Adds a 2nd next year and gets points for Naish. Pick 27 and 53 has all bases pretty much covered
Or
In Picks 10, 45 and their 2018 2nd (lets say Pick 31) = 2348 points
Out Picks 15 and 17 = 2137 points
Still gives us the 2nd next year and also gives us an extra 3rd for Naish. Picks 45, 50 and 53 will also have us covered, we'll just have to go into the draft with an extra spot on the list than the 1st option which is why I prefer that one.
bullus_hit said:
I wouldn't do that either, I see melbourne as a top 6-8 team next year and that would put their pick at around 28/29 before free agency compo's kick in
The only way i would do a pick down grade is if we are still into Schache and we could get him for the later pick we trade in this year
e.g #15 + #17 for #10 + #27 and #27 gets Josh Schache
mrposhman said:
i think people need to pay less attention to points. how many points pick 10 is worth would hopefully be irrelevant to us, just as points are irrelevant to the Dees.
obviously points gained for Naish are relevant but points allocated to picks that will be used in the draft have no value.
