I'm over it Graig. They are the most overrated thing in football.
You spend 37 yrs on the bottom of the ladder, more 1st rounders then GWS and we still don't make finals.
We give away pick 6 and a few others and 12 months later we win a flag.
100% it's AFL Roulette wheel.
I'm so over it. I find the kids that are drafted later are hunger to succeed and the Rookie kids are like hungry lions.
Lennon, Ellis x2, Dow, Collier Dawkins, Higgins & Vickery that's almost 10 yrs of 1st rounders.
Unless they are a pick 2 or 5 Cotchin or Martin *smile* it trade it..
Also if you're drafting last or close to last, you're a crap team!! No two ways around it.
Unless you fix the environment of how a club is run, the cycle rinses and repeats. Us, Carltoon and Melbourne have shown it doesn't matter how many top 10 draft picks you have, if you're poorly administered, lack training facilities and coaches going in and out every year or two, you're blowing these kids careers up.
And now St Kilda and the Bummers are the perfect example of saying 'hold my beer' to all the above!! They're terrible and who knows when their cycle ends.
I would be pretty confident if the guys we drafted top 5 or top 10 from years ago, if they went to Richmond today, or instead went to an earlier Hawks and Cats, they'd nearly all have better careers at the end of their time.
Geelong are the perfect example, 16 years now, with no top 5 draft picks, lost Ablett their best player for 5-6 years, yet stayed competitive nearly every year bar one or two. Put the old Richmond board or the current St Kilda/Essendumb/Carltoon board in their place and they'd be doing nothing much.
GWS issues with their drafts are different. They started with around 19 on the list being 1st round picks. This is where I agree with no hunger to succeed, they had no one who had to fight in their junior/late teen years for spots on the list.
No Lamberts, Broads, Grimes, Baker or a Pickett who had to do it the hard way and get knock backs in 2-3-4 drafts. So you can give the Giants every 1st round draft pick like they have again this year, they aren't going anywhere until they find a good bunch of 'hard workers'.
Giants have 16 first rounders on their list, they're adding three more to that this year, good luck with that! (That'll take them to 19 first rounders again, same as in 2012)
Richmond have 11 first rounders, the Cats have 5 and three of the Cats 5 first rounders are the three trades they bought in last week!!
No hunger, no fight, no Lambo, Baker or Pickett might!!