The Blair "Which?" Project | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

The Blair "Which?" Project

I think you'd need some very good inside intel
from what I've seen the guy could be a real knob , or he was just playing up for a camera ?
I'd prefer to not take the risk
I just reckon he is one of those guys who is an athlete first and foremost and just not that bright. We certainly need some hardness around the ball though
 
Dow is a kajillion times better than Mathieson. His disposal is fine for an inside mid. We need blokes who can get the ball before the bad guys too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Both Dow and Matheson are likely delistings at the end of the year so they will be free to a good home if we want them. Dow possibly, Matheson would just clog up a list spot. Is Matheson the guy who was interested in going to the Kangas until they baulked at his contract?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
This is going to be an unpopular one but I would have a look at the barometer, Rhys Mathieson.
Playing magoos at Brisbane, hard working inside mid

I happened to catch Rhys’ debut on TV a few years ago. I’d never heard of him at the time, but I was astounded to witness the first ever player I’d seen whose game appeared to be built around ducking. Not like Selwood, or any other players who are known as serial duckers. They usually do it when they run out of options. But Mathieson used it as his first option. Every. Single. Time.
He’d run hard at a contest, drop his knees, fall into a tackle and throw his head and arms back theatrically. Contrived self-clotheslining. At speed. Extraordinary.
I wondered at the time if this was how he’d made his way through various squads to find himself at AFL level, and if recruiters had thought it some sort of AFL trait, or thought it could be trained out of him. To be honest, I couldn’t see anything else in his game except ducking, and I haven’t since.
So I’m not really fussed about his grating personality, but I don’t see a use for someone who slows the play when they get a free kick, or is ineffective because they’re busy acting when they don’t.
Double-reinforced hard no from me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7 users
Mathieson is too slow to play midfield for us. All our guys (except Dusty) need to be strong two way runners for Dimma to play them. He is too slow to do that, thus be amazed if we target him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I happened to catch Rhys’ debut on TV a few years ago. I’d never heard of him at the time, but I was astounded to witness the first ever player I’d seen whose game appeared to be built around ducking. Not like Selwood, or any other players who are known as serial duckers. They usually do it when they run out of options. But Mathieson used it as his first option. Every. Single. Time.
He’d run hard at a contest, drop his knees, fall into a tackle and throw his head and arms back theatrically. Contrived self-clotheslining. At speed. Extraordinary.
I wondered at the time if this was how he’d made his way through various squads to find himself at AFL level, and if recruiters had thought it some sort of AFL trait, or thought it could be trained out of him. To be honest, I couldn’t see anything else in his game except ducking, and I haven’t since.
So I’m not really fussed about his grating personality, but I don’t see a use for someone who slows the play when they get a free kick, or is ineffective because they’re busy acting when they don’t.
Double-reinforced hard no from me.
It’s funny how some players seem to just solely play to receive free kicks. Cody Weightman has become my least favourite player for this reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
It’s funny how some players seem to just solely play to receive free kicks. Cody Weightman has become my least favourite player for this reason.
My 16 y. O son was loudly highlighting this fact all game Saturday night. Gets under your skin. Shame he's a relative of one of ours
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Mcstay isn’t as terrible as made out here, he’s a decent 3rd banana but he,ll be 27 going into 2023. A 6 year contract will have him playing til 32. Just don’t think you want a 3rd banana on 600k at 31,32.
D94A2A56-0922-439D-BF18-DA2DC65C5F19.jpeg
 
Reading VFL reports - Elijah Hollands is who we should be chasing. Starting to get it together.
Absolutely this. That could be our Rachelle.

Tom Powell / Will Phillips, reckon one of them moves at years end. Watch and evaluate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Both Dow and Matheson are likely delistings at the end of the year so they will be free to a good home if we want them. Dow possibly, Matheson would just clog up a list spot. Is Matheson the guy who was interested in going to the Kangas until they baulked at his contract?
Is Nah Nah Goon the Kangas
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Imho big contracts ,money wise should be saved for gun mids and gun kPP , don’t mind longer contracts for “ role players “ if it keeps there yearly coin down.

On Mcstay wouldnt mind him , however not at 600k a year , not sure I’d pay 500
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Said it before, I'll say it again: if someone's going to get squeezed out of Sydney it won't be Luke Parker. It could be George Hewett.

19 disposals, 13 tackles, 6 clearances today. 26 in December. Free agent. 187cm, 84kg. Can tag or just play accountable two-way footy. Apart from last year has played 21 or more games every year since his debut.

You might be able to get him for 4 x 450.
averaging 30 disposals, 8 clearances to R5. 26y/o.

5th in the comp for contested possessions
1st for centre clearances
2nd for total clearances
2nd for effective disposals
8th for score involvements
in the comp.

26y/o. Free agent. 4x450.

Is our cap chockers?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
You would assume we have some cap space, even with Lynch's salary getting to the out of proportion stage - given the backended contract.

One star like Taranto is my dream.

It's early days - and dare I say it, no one wants to even think about this - but quite a bit of Blair's brilliance will manifest based on what Dusty decides to do from 2023 onwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user