I happened to catch Rhys’ debut on TV a few years ago. I’d never heard of him at the time, but I was astounded to witness the first ever player I’d seen whose game appeared to be built around ducking. Not like Selwood, or any other players who are known as serial duckers. They usually do it when they run out of options. But Mathieson used it as his first option. Every. Single. Time.
He’d run hard at a contest, drop his knees, fall into a tackle and throw his head and arms back theatrically. Contrived self-clotheslining. At speed. Extraordinary.
I wondered at the time if this was how he’d made his way through various squads to find himself at AFL level, and if recruiters had thought it some sort of AFL trait, or thought it could be trained out of him. To be honest, I couldn’t see anything else in his game except ducking, and I haven’t since.
So I’m not really fussed about his grating personality, but I don’t see a use for someone who slows the play when they get a free kick, or is ineffective because they’re busy acting when they don’t.
Double-reinforced hard no from me.