He played every game and seems to have a fair build, but I need to have another look at him. I'm guessing he averaged about 60 in the preseason going by his dreamteam scores (not bad for a bottom priced player and considering shorter quarters), just don't see the point in pulling the trigger now if I don't have to.
If he scores above say 80 next round I'll seriously consider him, but if Hurley scored at around the same level I'd probably go with him even though his price is higher. I think Hurley could be far more important to Essendon's structure than Cheney might be to Melbourne. The problem with this though is whether he might be expected to just do a job at times which could seriously impact on his scoring.
Then of course there's the possibility of choosing Ricky Petterd if he has another good week. Didn't score quite as well as the other two boys in the opening round and is a bit more expensive, but he's got the advantage of having been in the system a bit longer than the other two and he tends to use the ball quite well too. If he stays fit (another concern :-\) he could be a better medium term proposition than the other two, enabling a possible straight swap for a premium player after say round 8-10. What's really needed here is for a bloke like Hodge to continue his slowish start to the season which would see his value plummet.
My immediate concern this week is the hope that Broughton gets a game for Freo this weekend, which is fortunately quite likely given the performance his team mates put up in the last round. This would mean that I should have a full complement of defenders to choose from with the obvious exception of Raines. I'd rather take an average score from Petrenko and not have to use a trade this week than use a trade simply because I have an injured player in my lineup. The benefit of getting a good second look at the likely candidates to replace Raines could far outway that matter of 10-20 points difference that playing Petrenko might present.