Umpire: SHEALES
takings $20,655.45
TIGERS A THREAT
By ALF BROWN (The Herald)
RICHMOND gave notice at the MCG today that they will be an even stronger Final Four contender this year than last year. They beat Essendon easily, and would have won by a far greater margin but for bad kicking for goal.
Richmond beat Essendon in all phases of the game. They were better forward, won in the ruck, were just as fast, and tackled much harder.
Essendon broke down badly forward, where Fordham, the top League goal-kicker last year, was below form. When Fraser was playing well, Essendon had a chance, but when he faded after half-time, Essendon lacked drive.
Richmond have found a star full-forward in 18-year-old Royce Hart [pictured below]. He took 10 marks, but his kicking let him down. However, it was a tremendously promising first performance.
When the sides lined up, Davis was centre half-back for Essendon. Soon after the game started, Dean went to the centre for Richmond and Barrot to centre half-forward.
The game was fast and scrambling. Too many players were on the ball, and pot shots by Richmond just missed. A great mark by Crowe gave Dimattina a chance to run spectacularly up the field and snap Richmond’s fourth behind.
New Essendon player Thompson held the ball and let Richmond in, and Hart kicked the first goal after 14 minutes.
Fordham (twice) and Clarke missed for Essendon. The strong crosswind was upsetting both sides. Clever handball by Northey allowed Barrot to goal and Richmond led by 15 points. Then Clay kicked a long one.
Essendon switched new player Ellis into the centre, and Fraser to a half-forward flank. Both coaches were moving players as though on a draughts-board.
Quarter-time scores:
RICHMOND 3.7-25
ESSENDON 0.3- 3
FIRST QUARTER GOALKICKERS:— Hart, Barrot, Clay.
Fraser was a fine player for Essendon, but many of his mates were out of touch. Twice Fraser marked to put Essendon into attack, but Richmond’s defence was too solid.
Williams and Clarke missed, before Shaw snapped Essendon’s first goal, after 39 minutes of play. Ronaldson was marking strongly for Richmond, but his kicking for goal was poor. However, his snap after a beautiful kick by Swift, atoned for earlier misses.
Ellis marked and kicked a fine goal. He was making a good debut. Ellis kicked his second after a poor holding the ball decision, and Essendon were only 11 points down. Noonan snapped one for Essendon — Mike Perry had kept him quiet — and for the first time Essendon looked like making a game of it.
Fordham’s shot on the siren missed. He had kicked 0 goals, 3 behinds from four shots.
Half-Time Scores:
RICHMOND 4.11-35
ESSENDON 4. 5-29
SECOND QUARTER GOALKICKERS:—
Richmond: Ronaldson.
Essendon: Ellis (2), Shaw, Noonan.
Crowe’s handball in the centre started Richmond off. Clay carried the ball on, and Hart snapped his second. It was Richmond’s best flash of football since the first quarter. Crowe, cruising around the centre, was winning kicks for Richmond.
Clay to Richardson, to lanky Ronaldson, who kicked straight for once, and Richmond had a handy lead once again. A great dash by wingman Egan gave Essendon a much needed goal. Fumbling by Davis let Swift in and Crowe marked in front of McKenzie for a goal. [pictured]
Richardson’s pace and expert handball was cutting the Essendon defence to pieces, and the Dons were fortunate that Hart was off target. Crowe, on his knees, handballed to Northey for another Richmond goal. Essendon were 27 points down and playing badly.
It was all Richmond, and Barrot goaled on the run from 55 yd out . Essendon were flat, and had no player to lift them. Great defence by Pryor started an Essendon attack, and Clarke goaled. Essendon had Payne on Hart, who had been too good for Brown.
Three-quarter time scores:
RICHMOND 9.16-70
ESSENDON 6. 6-42
THIRD QUARTER GOALKICKERS:—
Richmond: Hart, Ronaldson, Crowe, Northey, Barrot.
Essendon: Egan, Clarke.
Young Hart continued to win the ball well and kicked badly. His kick gave him the unflattering figures of 2 goals 7 behinds, but it demonstrated his great potential. Clay showed him how to do it, and goaled from 65 yds out. He had kicked well all day.
Fordham missed an easy one for Essendon, but Noonan got one, seconds later. Richmond’s reply was a brilliant one — a long goal by Barrot. Essendon with one of their rare bursts of system, carried the ball the length of the ground by handball for a goal to Birt. But they wanted a lot more to challenge Richmond.
Hart pulled down his 10th mark and kicked his third goal. He is a great prospect, and with him Richmond will be a real Finals threat. Barrot was brilliant for Richmond and kept sending the ball forward. Essendon had stopped to a walk and were putting up weak opposition.
McKenzie ran and ran and ran, neglecting to bounce the ball, and goaled. Pryor was a great player for Essendon. But for him, Essendon would have lost by a far greater margin.
Final scores:
RICHMOND 15.20-110
ESSENDON 11. 9- 75
FINAL QUARTER GOALKICKERS:—
Richmond: Clay, Barrot (3), Hart, Bartlett.
Essendon: Noonan, Birt (2), McKenzie, Thompson.
GOALKICKERS FOR THE MATCH:
Richmond: Barrot (5), Hart (3), Ronaldson (2), Clay (2), Crowe, Northey, Bartlett.
Essendon: Birt (2), Noonan (2), Ellis (2), Clarke, Shaw, McKenzie, Egan, Thompson.
BEST PLAYERS:
Richmond: Barrot, Richardson, Hart, Bartlett, Erwin, Clay, Crowe.
Essendon: Pryor, McKenzie, Clarke, Egan, Davis, Fraser, Shaw.
REPLACED: Barlett (cramp) by Moore, Richardson (cramp) by Patterson, last quarter.
* * * * *
BAD KICKING — GREAT WIN
By BARRIE BRETLAND
If, as the purists claim, bad kicking is bad football, Richmond turned in a poor performance at the MCG on Saturday.
But just try telling that to the thousands of ecstatic Tiger fans who saw their side trounce last year’s No. 3 team Essendon, 15.20-110 to 11.9-75. As they would be justified in pointing out, even deplorable kicking — around the ground AND in front of goal — did nothing to even up the game as a contest.
The harsh truth for Dons’ fans was that their players looked lethargic alongside their enthusiastic rivals, were yards slower, were outmarked and brushed aside in the physical encounters. Two factors kept the teams on even terms in the first half — Richmond’s wild-horse style kicking and Ken Fraser.
Until half-time, the Dons’ skipper, operating out of the centre, virtually played the Tigers on his own and was easily the best player afield. Afterwards the Essendon “brains trust” unaccountably swung him into attack.
The result was doubly disastrous — the team lost its only regular source of drive, and Fraser’s dominant 23 became just another number on the back of a beaten Bomber.
Richmond, in direct contrast with the out-of-form Dons, got good service from most players. Outstanding were winger *smile* Clay and veteran ruckman Neville Crowe, who have seldom if ever played better, and Bill Barrot. [below: Crowe contests a throw-in with Don McKenzie; Dean and Richardson wait for the crumbs, with Gosper (No 6) hovering.]
Ironically, Barrot, together with promising new forward Royce Hart, tall follower John Ronaldson and Roger Dean, was among the chief offenders in the wild kicking orgy.
Moved to centre half-forward after five minutes in the middle, Barrot became a match-winner.
Best: RICHMOND: Barrot (best on ground), Crowe, Clay, Richardson, Hart, Dimattina, Ronaldson, Dean, Shinners.
ESSENDON: Pryor, Payne, McKenzie, Fraser, Birt, Gosper, Ellis.