RIVALS FOR THE “4”
Essendon, on the fringe of dropping out of the top four, and Richmond vigorously demanding a place there, will meet in the main opening League football match at the MCG tomorrow.
Both sides must win because they cannot afford to lose. Richmond knows this from last year when they suffered four defeats and played a draw and missed the finals. Essendon with only four defeats scraped in.
Essendon must win because the draw already has conspired against them — they play Richmond, St Kilda and Collingwood in their first three games which means they play them in return matches, too.
If the Dons win four of these six games they will be doing fine but, on Richmond’s experience last year, it gives them only a margin of two other games to drop this season. It means that from tomorrow until August 26, when they play Melbourne on the MCG in the last home and away game, Essendon will be living dangerously.
Essendon’s greater experience, their pace and their proven strength down the centre of the ground should give them the game. But it will not be easy.
Richmond will play it aggressively. They will tackle hard and come through vigorously. But the big MCG is one of Essendon’s favourite grounds and in Birt, Fraser and Clarke, Essendon have the players to open up Richmond’s defence and expose their lack of experience.
Full-forward Fordham will be a worry to Richmond. He is in fine ball-getting form although when I left the Essendon ground at half-time last week he had sprayed his kicks for two goals from 10 chances. But that does not mean Fordham will not be on the job tomorrow. And Richmond have a pessimistic theory that all wrong-footed full-forwards come good against them.
Fordham’s opponent will be
Erwin who knows the full-forward job. He came to Richmond from Collingwood where he played full-back. Richmond turned him into a full-forward but his kicking was so unreliable that he is back in defence. Erwin is tough and strong and can be hard to get on with. So can Fordham, and with talented players like Birt, Noonan and Fraser in front of him he will not lack chances.
Shinners, flown down from Sydney by Richmond, will not lack match practice but he may lack condition to see out a full game. If he does, Birt, Shaw and Clarke will take full advantage of it. Shinners could not ask for a tougher trio in his first League game. Birt is clever and fast: Shaw can mark as well as anyone in the Essendon side and has tons of pace; Clarke was playing League football when Shinners was still attending State school.
Mike Perry is one of the coming centre half-backs and Noonan, who has to face up to second year jitters, will find kicks scarce. On the half-back flanks, Richmond are more hopeful than talented.
Burgin and
Strang meet new boys in Ellis, a lovely mover from the Reserves, and Thompson, a high flier from Alexandra.
The centre-line battles will be interesting. Fraser will beat
Barrot in the air, even if Barrot is in form. Already Barrot has had a patchy season. He has been ill and then he struck unexpected and talented opposition from
Sheedy of Prahran in the practice games.
Clay, who began at centre half-forward for Richmond last year, is on one wing;
John Perry, a six-footer, is on the other. They will tower over Gosper and Egan who will have to rely on pace and cleverness for kicks. Height will not worry little Egan — I saw him win lots of kicks against 6ft. 1in. Meagher at Hawthorn last yea. And Meagher was in form because when he was switched on to Fraser in the centre he did well.
Richmond’s attack is so full of talent that if every player fires they will win. One half-forward flanker is
Northey who can go unnoticed for three quarters, then win a match off his own boot in the last. But he must kick straighter this year. [
pictured below]
Captain
Fred Swift will kick goals from centre half-forward. He lacks Guinane’s strength but is a fine mark for his inches.
Dean, on the other flank, is one of my favourite footballers. He has everything — skill, determination, fire, pace and he can mark.
Young
Hart, playing his first game will test Brown. Brown is not a high flier; he is a spoiler. Hart is a spectacular mark and if he can reproduce his practice match form he will give League football a lift. Unlike many high fliers, Hart has not built his game solely on marking. He moves well, too.
I hope he makes it; he deserved to. He came from Tasmania, played for Richmond Thirds and has fought his way up.
Richmond should win in the ruck where they have
Crowe, one of the most consistent big men;
Richardson, adept at handball and teamwork, and
Ronaldson and
Green, two most promising well-over-six-footers.
McKenzie carries Essendon’s rucks. He has a tremendous spring for knock-outs and with Shaw as a ruck-rover and Birt roving will help to offset much of Richmond’s ruck advantage.