Pick the Brownlow trifecta | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Pick the Brownlow trifecta

Just hope Hawthorn don't go top four in the coming years, Tom Mitchell would have four of these
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 1 user
Midfield is the only position where your opponent can get 40 touches and thrash u ,and u get 27 touches and still poll 2 votes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Richmond FC back to retro status.

No one in the top 20 of a Brownlow and No Finals.

FFS
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Yeah its a bit contrived now.

Maxy Gawn has completely dominated the comp this year, yet gets nowhere near it.
Gawns dominance in clearancea gave Oliver say 9 votes and Petracca 6.... but if he got them still wouldn't have won it though. Reckon the 70s was the ruckman era. And three Tiger Brownlows to ruckmen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Some of the umpires' voting in our games quite baffling e.g. we got a draw against Dorks in last match, right? But not even one of our players got a vote. Other similar odd results other games.

But no real surprise, eh? It's the AFL umps.

Delighted that Shai won MotY - well deserved. My view in the poll on PRE was that I rated it higher than JR's as just so exciting, a genuine speccie. (It helped seeing it live right in front of me too!)

But Shai should have won GotY too for that dodging and weaving one. Better than Serong's fluke. Not even nominated. But that's determined by a silly competition I think, pop vote, not the umps.
 
Last edited:
How does Walsh gain so many votes from a losing team?
Good player but was plucking votes off 5 goal losses.
If the umpires can't find one player from the winning team to give 3 votes too they should stop voting.
I've never understood how a team wins by 10 goals but an opposition player still gets a vote.
We drew with Hawthorn and the *smile* sticks couldn't pluck 1 vote for one of our player's that got us back into the game.
No-one remembers brownlow winner's anymore
 
Walsh will win multiple Brownlows if Carlton get any good.

The two I loved from that draft class was Wines & Grundy.

Think I compared Wines to Joel Selwood. Super player is Wines, King of Echuca.
 
Good player but was plucking votes off 5 goal losses.
If the umpires can't find one player from the winning team to give 3 votes too they should stop voting.
I've never understood how a team wins by 10 goals but an opposition player still gets a vote.
We drew with Hawthorn and the *smile* sticks couldn't pluck 1 vote for one of our player's that got us back into the game.
No-one remembers brownlow winner's anymore
Yeah. Seems weird.
St Kilda 27 more votes than Richmond :unsure:
It's not just the free kick count these flogs kill us with.