What’s the point of making our midfield thinner.still valuable to us, particularly with the 2 imports. Makes him more dangerous
I reckon the club wants the Tarranto & Hopper inclusions resolved this year.Don't want to lose Graham; Richmond man and he needs another 3 games so we get father-son dibs. Would rather keep him if we can and add Taranto and Hopper to the midfield mix. That gives us serious mid rotation.
I would happily trade Short; IMHO he is surplus to requirements. But he just signed a 5 year deal so can't see that happening.I reckon the club wants the Tarranto & Hopper inclusions resolved this year.
They most likely don't want to lose picks next and if they have used Soldo as trade bait and they haven't had alot of interest.
Maybe Graham is the one they have brought in to use him as a down payment.
I wouldve kept Graham and used Short or Baker
Agree.I would happily trade Short; IMHO he is surplus to requirements. But he just signed a 5 year deal so can't see that happening.
I wouldn't trade Graham or Baker; but yes it may end up happening that Graham gets traded so we can bring the Giants players in. Personally I hope we can get them without trading Graham.
I’ve been a Short fan but have to say I’ve tired of his dump kick disposal which the opposition just pick off or simply punch the ball because they’ve certainly had time to, it’s spent half an hour in the air!I would happily trade Short; IMHO he is surplus to requirements. But he just signed a 5 year deal so can't see that happening.
I wouldn't trade Graham or Baker; but yes it may end up happening that Graham gets traded so we can bring the Giants players in. Personally I hope we can get them without trading Graham.
He doesn't play midfieldAren’t we trying to strengthen and build our midfield? Trading him seems counterproductive.
I'm off Short; reckon he has been pretty ordinary since 2020 GF and we can easily cover his role. Yes his dump kicking 50 metres straight to the opposition is very frustrating.I’ve been a Short fan but have to say I’ve tired of his dump kick disposal which the opposition just pick off or simply punch the ball because they’ve certainly had time to, it’s spent half an hour in the air!
Him signing a contract doesn’t seem to matter much any more but it’d have to be a very good deal.
Sam Edmund also said - Far more likely to stay at Punt Rd.According to SEN - 5 Clubs have enquired about Graham who is receptive to offers. The Hopper/Taranto effect.
Is there any legit chatter about Marshall leaving port?Graham is worth 1 1st rounder
Straight swap for Rozeee
Or Marshall.
Feels that way to me tooAren’t we trying to strengthen and build our midfield? Trading him seems counterproductive.
No but there is a name the club is offering up that the little members might not be too happy about.Is there any legit chatter about Marshall leaving port?
Sam Edmund mentioned that with Mince who was giggling quietly.Maybe the media just want Richmond fans to think the Taranto/Hopper deal is causing friction within the club and now we have to trade away all our young players?
Makes for a good story
And keeps them in AFL's good books