Nankervis !!

[dimmauchump]

For mine the Soldo and Chol combo worked very well against Grundy. Shoukdnt keep his spot but most likely will. If he does has to be told to stick his knees into Grundy at every ruck contest. Don't even worry about the ball.

 

[Letsroar]

At the game. It seemed we were clearly better with Soldo in the middle. I would play Choi. Nani didn’t appear fit

 

[jb03]

Look a little laboured but I think we have to keep him in (although he often looks like that and gets better as the game goes on)

 

[MD Jazz]

He struggled for mine. Soldo is clearly our number 1 ruckman for mine. But will we get more from Balta or Choi?

 

[Baloo]

He struggled for mine. Soldo is clearly our number 1 ruckman for mine. But will we get more from Balta or Choi?

I don't think so. Nank's a warrior. Warriors win Grand Finals

 

[UKTiger]

He struggled and to me, he was not entirely match fit but between him and the alternative rucks I reckon he is the best we have to support Ivan.

 

[spook]

Does he play in the GF?

No.

 

[DavidSSS]

I'd play him, I agree he was down tonight but he didn't look quite right. Hopefully a week off will see him improve. He is Grand Final material.

It was a tough game that Prelim, maybe got a niggle at some point.

DS

 

[Bullarto Tiger]

Nank didn't seem right. The match committee is going to have a few headaches this week with selection. And the Big Fella will be one of those under the microscope.

 

[tigerlove]

He struggled for mine. Soldo is clearly our number 1 ruckman for mine. But will we get more from Balta or Choi?

Nope. I to a GF with no lead up AFL finals games they'll get slaughtered. Our ruck combo wore the opposition down and were on top in latter part of the game. Nanks will play GF. Don't think we have a choice really.

 

[tommystigers]

I don't think so. Nank's a warrior. Warriors win Grand Finals

He knows what sacrifice is required to win a GF. He will offer that sacrifice for the team on Saturday.

 

[Spirit of Jack]

No way Hardwick brings in Choi or Balta for Nank - unless he is injured.

 

[taraba]

Probably depends on the opposition really but I think he plays. If it’s GWS then we could maybe get away with just big Ivan. Against the filth we may want some extra run maybe with Stack, Ross, Menadue or even Pickett (as amazing as that seems).

So let’s see who we’re playing first and then we can adjust. But we’re talking about a bloody tough player here. The kind you want I’m GF’s.

 

[Tigertool]

Shouldn’t play IMO. Chol or another mid in Ross.

 

[No 4]

If it was up to me, I would say no, but I reckon those that matter will have the opposite opinion.

My answer is yes. We need to ensure our dominance in the centre and around the ground, having both will assist us.

 

[year of the tiger]

Will need to watch the replay when I get home but at the game I didn’t notice him that much and they seemed to win the centre clearances when he was in there but it was hard to tell.

We need to rucks against Grundy but not sure against GWS.

Can’t see him being dropped to be honest.

 

[craig]

Need two rucks to work over Crundy if we play the skunks

 

[Tames]

He's way too slow to play forward, or any other position other than ruck, but Soldo has proved that he takes that position.

Cant see Dimma dropping him, so hopefully his game improves.

 

[Tigertool]

I don’t think we need two rucks to go up against Mumford. Playing GWS doesn’t help Nankervis’ bid to play the GF. I’d definitely prefer the extra mid here.

 

[Tigers of Old]

I'd play a more mobile tall.