I still like Logan, I’m buying stock, lots of it. He’s an elite CHF runner, long Tom Lynch runs BUT one paced. BUT runs all day.
SCG is not his track. Suited to bigger grounds. Could see the Eagles coming hard for him.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Matthew Clarke
- Thread starter Harry
- Start date
SCG is not his track. Suited to bigger grounds. Could see the Eagles coming hard for him.
Every one knows we stink at the draft.
Seriously getting Tarranto and Hopper and giving away the picks was a no brainer
Seriously getting Tarranto and Hopper and giving away the picks was a no brainer
The 2021 draft will make him or break him methinks..crucial to our future fortunes.
Gibbus is a tick
A fitter stronger hardened Sonzie and Clarke will also likely be ticks.
Banks and Brown are the ???
I suspect we will see Banks very soon. Bauer is another one. Maybe even this week.
Then go and have a look
Open your eyes
Lennon
Griffens
Ellis X2
Collier-Dawkins
Coleman Jones
Dow
Where shitt at drafting
You can't teach 'hardness'
Either the player has balls or he doesn't.
People bagged Bulter for avoiding contact, at least he kicked goals.
Brown will go down as the properly the worse selection he has made.
Banks was injured when we drafted him, he is still injured 2 yrs later.
Gibcus was tracking well and Sony will be fingers crossed ok.
But the damage has been done.
Collier-Dawkins should be replacing Cotchin.
Ellis should be replacing Flappers
Coleman Jones should be our Ottens ruck/foward.
The selection of Higgins in 2018 shouldve been the final draft he was incharge of.
Kids on here select better kids.
*2023 shopping list
*chuck out Teague McQualter new assistants
* A fitness bloke that pushes them to run
* A new recruiting team.
Hartley and Clarke haven't nailed a 1st rounder since Rioli and BigV and that's close to 10yrs now.
And we have had some killer picks to.
I think his position needs to be reviewed. Only Baker, Bolton and Pickett are proven top line players taken since 2017. His Coleman Jones, RCD and Dow picks are really hurting at the moment. Just my opinion but I think we need to do better than this bloke if we want to avoid a long period in the wilderness.
Last edited:
Bollocks.
Our ladder position meant we had little to choose from.
Show me all the picks within the next 18 of each player selected that have shown we missed a star. Obviously any father son or academy players are out. I
Ellis x2 Brown??
Even if we had 2 coming through.
He needs to go for missing Oscar Allen
So if he gets sacked for missing one player, does get a statue for Baker?
Here's another look at the 2017 ND. The first after Clarke's promotion to honcho of youth.
Round | Pick | Player | Drafted to | Recruited from |
1 | 1 | Cameron Rayner | Brisbane Lions | Western Jets |
1 | 2 | Andrew Brayshaw | Fremantle | Sandringham Dragons |
1 | 3 | Paddy Dow | Carlton | Bendigo Pioneers |
1 | 4 | Luke Davies-Uniacke | North Melbourne | Dandenong Stingrays |
1 | 5 | Adam Cerra | Fremantle | Eastern Ranges |
1 | 6 | Jaidyn Stephenson | Collingwood | Eastern Ranges |
1 | 7 | Hunter Clark | St Kilda | Dandenong Stingrays |
1 | 8 | Nick Coffield | St Kilda | Northern Knights |
1 | 9 | Aaron Naughton | Western Bulldogs | Peel Thunder |
1 | 10 | Lochie O'Brien | Carlton | Bendigo Pioneers |
1 | 11 | Aiden Bonar | Greater Western Sydney | Dandenong Stingrays |
1 | 12 | Darcy Fogarty | Adelaide | Glenelg |
1 | 13 | Jarrod Brander | West Coast | Bendigo Pioneers |
1 | 14 | Matthew Ling | Sydney | Geelong Falcons |
1 | 15 | Zac Bailey | Brisbane Lions | Norwood |
1 | 16 | Ed Richards | Western Bulldogs | Oakleigh Chargers |
1 | 17 | Jack Higgins | Richmond | Oakleigh Chargers |
1 | 18 | Brandon Starcevich | Brisbane Lions | East Perth |
1 | 19 | Wil Powell | Gold Coast | Claremont |
2 | 20 | Callum Coleman-Jones | Richmond | Sturt |
2 | 21 | Oscar Allen | West Coast | West Perth |
2 | 22 | Lachie Fogarty | Geelong | Western Jets |
2 | 23 | Will Walker | North Melbourne | Sandringham Dragons |
2 | 24 | Tim Kelly | Geelong | South Fremantle |
2 | 25 | Noah Balta | Richmond | Calder Cannons |
2 | 26 | Liam Ryan | West Coast | Subiaco |
2 | 27 | Brent Daniels | Greater Western Sydney | Bendigo Pioneers |
2 | 28 | Sam Taylor | Greater Western Sydney | Swan Districts |
2 | 29 | Charlie Spargo | Melbourne | Murray Bushrangers |
2 | 30 | Tom De Koning | Carlton | Dandenong Stingrays |
2 | 31 | Bayley Fritsch | Melbourne | Casey |
2 | 32 | Brayden Ainsworth | West Coast | Subiaco |
2 | 33 | Tom McCartin | Sydney | Geelong Falcons |
2 | 34 | Patrick Naish | Richmond | Northern Knights |
2 | 35 | Oscar Clavarino | St Kilda | Dandenong Stingrays |
2 | 36 | Charlie Constable | Geelong | Sandringham Dragons |
2 | 37 | Harrison Petty | Melbourne | Norwood |
3 | 38 | Jack Petruccelle | West Coast | Northern Knights |
3 | 39 | Nathan Murphy | Collingwood | Sandringham Dragons |
3 | 40 | Andrew McPherson | Adelaide | Woodville-West Torrens |
3 | 41 | Toby Wooller | Brisbane Lions | Oakleigh Chargers |
3 | 42 | Charlie Ballard | Gold Coast | Sturt |
3 | 43 | Connor Ballenden | Brisbane Lions | Brisbane Lions |
3 | 44 | Hugh Dixon | Fremantle | Tigers |
3 | 45 | James Worpel | Hawthorn | Geelong Falcons |
3 | 46 | Ben Paton | St Kilda | Murray Bushrangers |
3 | 47 | Sam Hayes | Port Adelaide | Eastern Ranges |
3 | 48 | Oskar Baker | Melbourne | Aspley |
3 | 49 | Jordan Houlahan | Essendon | Sturt |
3 | 50 | Tyler Brown | Collingwood | Eastern Ranges |
3 | 51 | Kane Farrell | Port Adelaide | Bendigo Pioneers |
3 | 52 | Brayden Crossley | Gold Coast | Palm Beach Currumbin |
3 | 53 | Ryley Stoddart | Sydney | Eastern Ranges |
3 | 54 | Jack Payne | Brisbane Lions | Noosa |
3 | 55 | Connor Nutting | Gold Coast | Broadbeach |
4 | 56 | Zac Langdon | Greater Western Sydney | Claremont |
4 | 57 | Gryan Miers | Geelong | Geelong Falcons |
4 | 58 | Jake Patmore | Port Adelaide | Claremont |
4 | 59 | Mitch Crowden | Fremantle | Sturt |
4 | 60 | Joel Garner | Port Adelaide | Eastern Ranges |
4 | 61 | Dom Barry | Port Adelaide | Glenelg |
4 | 62 | Kyron Hayden | North Melbourne | Subiaco |
4 | 63 | Ben Miller | Richmond | Subiaco |
4 | 64 | Nick Shipley | Greater Western Sydney | St George |
4 | 65 | Tom North | Fremantle | Eastern Ranges |
4 | 66 | Brandon Zerk-Thatcher | Essendon | Sturt |
4 | 67 | Dylan Moore | Hawthorn | Eastern Ranges |
4 | 68 | Hamish Brayshaw | West Coast | Sandringham Dragons |
4 | 69 | Lloyd Meek | Fremantle | Greater Western Victoria Rebels |
4 | 70 | Angus Schumacher | Carlton | Bendigo Pioneers |
5 | 71 | Jackson Ross | Hawthorn | Eastern Ranges |
5 | 72 | Tristan Xerri | North Melbourne | Western Jets |
5 | 73 | Sam Switkowski | Fremantle | Box Hill |
5 | 74 | Callum Porter | Western Bulldogs | Gippsland Power |
5 | 75 | Scott Jones | Fremantle | East Perth |
5 | 76 | Matt Guelfi | Essendon | Claremont |
5 | 77 | Billy Hartung | North Melbourne | Hawthorn |
6 | 78 | Jarrod Garlett | Carlton | South Fremantle |
