Changes V Pies

[tigerman]

Wouldn't have too many changes, if Miles is sore give him a spell. Morris stays in to play on the Pies small forwards.

In : Shed
Out : Miles

 

[achillesjones]

miles must NEVER BE DROPPED. Essential if we are to win finals.

 

[funky]

Out thomas hopefully for good
In shed.

 

[Tigaman]

Miles out No. Thomas out No. Hate to see MacIntosh left off the list as he has not done anything wrong this year. Sheds will have to wait after time in the Magoos.

 

[JR8]

Wouldn't have too many changes, if Miles is sore give him a spell. Morris stays in to play on the Pies small forwards.

In : Shed
Out : Miles Thomas

Corrected for accuracy!!

 

[tigerman]

miles must NEVER BE DROPPED. Essential if we are to win finals.

I wouldn't call it dropped, i would call it rested.
I agree he is crucial to finals success. Shed would be a handy replacement and Thomas playing another game is like for like.

 

[St Kevin]

Miles out No. Thomas out No. Hate to see MacIntosh left off the list as he has not done anything wrong this year. Sheds will have to wait after time in the Magoos.

No way in hell Edwards will play reserves.

In: Edwards
Out: Thomas

KMac stays as sub.

 

[TigerForce]

Doubt Shank will be back by next week. Probably for the Norf game.

 

[axlefoley]

No change, we're on fire.

 

[tiger_25]

The way Edwards injury has dragged out no certainly to return next week.

 

[Tigerfan]

Thomas gave us steel in the middle.
Morris was aggressive at half back where he belongs.
He was a fan favourite when he started his career in that spot.

But we need to find room for edwards and maybe conca later.
Knights might squeeze back in later if the gods are just.

I'd say: no change.

 

[Tigertool]

Out: Thomas
In: Shane

 

[mrposhman]

I reckon no changes too unless Titch is totally right.

 

[achillesjones]

I would give Edwards another two weeks, then play against North.

 

[tigertim]

Surprised at the drop Thomas calls, thought he earnt another game.

 

[Tigerfan]

Surprised at the drop Thomas calls, thought he earnt another game.

He did have a good game
But there's no surprise in the 'drop thomas and morris' calls
;D

 

[jb03]

Surprised at the drop Thomas calls, thought he earnt another game.

Who would you drop if Edwards was fit to come back?

 

[BrisTiger24]

LOL at Miles being dropped before Thomas. Thomas had a good game? Sheesh, our standards are pretty low. He was serviceable but only had 4 kicks, looked slow. We had 1 tackle for the first qtr, Thomas trying to make an impact, he should have been leading the way on that stat in the first qtr.

In: Edwards (or McDonough)

Out: Thomas

 

[RemoteTiger]

Surprised at the drop Thomas calls, thought he earnt another game.

Agree.

Reckon our small forwards were made to look ok yesterday too. They had a lot of room to strut their stuff and they will not have that against the Pies. The Lloyds, Lennons etc. will get shut out by the Pies backman. Vickery in big games generally plays only average. We are no sure thing against Collingwood and they would be rightly pleased to stuff up our top four/eight chances by beating their old foe.

Our forward line needs a lot more work and maybe a change of personnel. Could this be game to bring in McBean - use Jack and Vickery as decoys and McBean kicks a bag - Swans do that with Reid (using Franklin and Tippett as decoys)

Our midfield has to put pressure on the other way - why the likes of Miles, Delidio, Martin and to a lesser extent Cotchin don't tackle is beyond my football nous? Thomas and Maric tried hard to lay effective tackles inside packs, but they are in close players who can't catch the opposition outside runners.

We have to fire up against Collingwood or they will make us pay.

 

[tigersnake]

Out: Thomas, Morris

In: Edwards if fit, and the Collingwood specialist, McBEAN!

Is Miles injured? If he is, Thomas stays