Changes v GC | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Changes v GC

Great news re Tom and Dave.

In: Lynch, Astbury, Miller, RCD, Stack
Out: Balta, Broad, Ryan, Aarts, Short


Don't think Vlastuin will get up. Big corky

I'll go

Out: Balta, Broad, Vlastuin

In: Lynch, Dave, Stack
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I am not going to criticise our own players especially two who have given such excellent service. But their performances simply don’t justify continuing selection.
Looking at our opposition over the weekend.
Simply put RCD and Dow are now better prospects.
I am not suggesting they do justify continuing selection but circumstances play a part. Whilst we're still a chance for finals I think teams are much more likely to choose the experienced player. Particularly in our case with 3 experienced players going out through injury, we're not going to drop even more experience. Houli will not get dropped this week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Lynch for Ryan is a given. Mansell for Vlastuin.. Looks like Astbury is back for Balta. Broad replacement is an interesting one. If we're debuting Miller sounds like the man. I can"t are too many more changes unless other injuries.
 
Surely Stack gets a gig.

And same with Miller. Especially if Chol is out.
 
Last edited:
Surely Stack gets a gig
Broad, Vlas, Balta and Ryan will make way. Lynch,Astbury and Miller will come in. That leaves one more so maybe Stack.

Despite posters calling for Short and Castagna to be dropped, don't think it will happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Richmond coach Damien Hardwick is expected to turn to his fifth debutant for the season on Thursday night. But who is it? Early Mail for round 16.

Richmond thinks it has found another diamond in the rough, with key defender Ben Miller in the frame to bolster the backline against Gold Coast on Thursday night.

Fresh injuries to Noah Balta (ankle) and Nathan Broad (ankle) have the West Australian in line to become the club’s sixth debutant this season. Carlton, Gold Coast and Melbourne have blooded just one player each in 2021.

David Astbury is still no certainty to return from a grumbly Achilles and so the Tigers might have to piece together a makeshift backline to combat Suns targets Ben King and Josh Corbett.

But Miller’s sparkling VFL form has had him under discussion at match committee for some time and if he gets the nod it will not be a Steven Bradbury-type debut.

It can be revealed that the Kalgoorlie prospect was firmly in the mix to crack coach Damien Hardwick‘s best 22 long before last weekend’s double blow to Balta and Broad.

Tigers VFL coach Xavier Clarke told News Corp that Miller had come of age this season.
“Benny Miller is one not a lot of people hear about,” Clarke said earlier this month.

Ben Miller can play on the talls and the smalls.

Ben Miller can play on the talls and the smalls.

“His game has improved dramatically from the end of last year to this year as that key back.
“It’s getting to the point now where we’re talking about him at match committee. Can he play at the level?
“Whereas two years ago he had a little bit more work to do.”

Miller was then named in Richmond’s extended squad against West Coast and enjoyed a career-best VFL game against Sandringham on Saturday.
The 198cm defender collected 119 ranking points, which was easily his best from 42 VFL matches.
Miller racked up six intercept marks, eight intercept possessions, 10 spoils and five tackles in a dominant display.

“The growth in his game is the ability to be able to play on talls, but also smaller medium-sized forwards,” Clarke said.
“He has the ability one-on-one against the bigger boys.”

Under talent boss Blair Hartley and recruiters Matthew Clarke, Francis Jackson and Richard Taylor the Tigers pieced together their premiership backline almost exclusively through the draft’s dumpster.

Liam Baker and Jayden Short were rookie revelations while Broad was taken at pick No.67 and Dylan Grimes in the pre-season draft.
Miller was secured with pick No.63 in 2017 and has since been demoted to the rookie list. Those at Tigerland are quietly confident they might have found another one in Miller.

Midfielder Jack Ross and goalkicker Daniel Rioli are being reprogrammed into halfbacks in the VFL.
Ross had 29 disposals (130 ranking points) against the Zebras to put his hand up for a recall against the Suns.


Nigel, Not Dusty, R2D2, Raaalph, Delilah, now possibly Millerlite. Last time I counted up on my fingers n toes, that'd make six debutants for the year. Imbeciles n noisy self gratifiers in the meedjia at it again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
A key position change until Nank returns is CCJ to play first ruck. He looked at least competitive against Ryder/Marshall & seems comfortable in the role. Plus he can take contested marks. He’ll get even better over time. Can’t tolerate insipid & inconsistent effort from Chol any longer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
I am not suggesting they do justify continuing selection but circumstances play a part. Whilst we're still a chance for finals I think teams are much more likely to choose the experienced player. Particularly in our case with 3 experienced players going out through injury, we're not going to drop even more experience. Houli will not get dropped this week.
If you don’t want to run in a straight line towards the ball or otherwise put yourself in harms way to get the ball, or physically can no longer do either, you won’t.
Being experienced doesn’t help.
Dimma has evidently accepted that two of his long time favourites no longer justify selection and has sent them back.
Common sense demands that he looks at two more.
Not saying he will. Just saying he should.
 
Prestia out as well.

almost ready to put the cue in the rack for 2021 and play RCD, Hugo, Dow and get ready for next year
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
out: balta,broad, vlaustin inj. chol ryan omitted.
in: lynch, astbury, caddy, rioli, naish or rcd.
move marlion and kmac to half back
Caddy plays forward ccj to ruck with dave.

Ryan will be good but not yet.
and in the interest of me not putting my foot through the Kreisler, Mabs traded to the Bombers asap.
 
Injury will account for 3, Broad, Balta and Prestia and add Ryan to that. I think that’ll be your 4 outs.

Astbury, Lynch Miller and RCD as the ins maybe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user