Changes against Bulldogs | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Changes against Bulldogs

We look like losing 3 top liners in Grimes, Lambert and Dust and I don’t think our present game will stand up against the Bulldogs without those 3.

Aarts is tough but doesn’t win enough of his own ball and Houli has dropped pff noticeably after his return from injury, which also robbed him of a pre-season.

We need to change our emphasis if we are to have any chance and our one point of possible advantage is our
(little known) strength in talls, who gave good speed. Chol on a wing could tear them apart!

I’d make 5 changes

In: Cameron-Jones, Chol, Collier-Dawkins, Humphrysmith
and Rioli M,
Out: Grimes Lambert Martin injured, Aarts, and Houli omitted.

B Astbury Broad Balta
HB Short McIntosh HUMPREYSMITH
C Cotchin Bolton CHOL
HF COLLIER-DAWKINS Edwards Castagna
F Lynch Riewoldt Rioli D
R Nankervis Graham Baker
I/C Cameron-Jones, Mansell Pickett Rioli M.
Sub Houli.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
We look like losing 3 top liners in Grimes, Lambert and Dust and I don’t think our present game will stand up against the Bulldogs without those 3.

Aarts is tough but doesn’t win enough of his own ball and Houli has dropped pff noticeably after his return from injury, which also robbed him of a pre-season.

We need to change our emphasis if we are to have any chance and our one point of possible advantage is our
(little known) strength in talls, who gave good speed. Chol on a wing could tear them apart!

I’d make 5 changes

In: Cameron-Jones, Chol, Collier-Dawkins, Humphrysmith
and Rioli M,
Out: Grimes Lambert Martin injured, Aarts, and Houli omitted.

B Astbury Broad Balta
HB Short McIntosh HUMPREYSMITH
C Cotchin Bolton CHOL
HF COLLIER-DAWKINS Edwards Castagna
F Lynch Riewoldt Rioli D
R Nankervis Graham Baker
I/C Cameron-Jones, Mansell Pickett Rioli M.
Sub Houli.
Cameron-Jones? Humphrey-Smith?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
No way Chol. Absolutely no way. Has done zero in the VFL and is a weak footballer full stop.

No way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Cumberland looked OK, with a few of the things he did, other than belting the Melbourne guy, given it was his first 'grown-up' game, and he was coming back from a knee. He may turn out alright, though very early days.
 
We look like losing 3 top liners in Grimes, Lambert and Dust and I don’t think our present game will stand up against the Bulldogs without those 3.

Aarts is tough but doesn’t win enough of his own ball and Houli has dropped pff noticeably after his return from injury, which also robbed him of a pre-season.

We need to change our emphasis if we are to have any chance and our one point of possible advantage is our
(little known) strength in talls, who gave good speed. Chol on a wing could tear them apart!

I’d make 5 changes

In: Cameron-Jones, Chol, Collier-Dawkins, Humphrysmith
and Rioli M,
Out: Grimes Lambert Martin injured, Aarts, and Houli omitted.

B Astbury Broad Balta
HB Short McIntosh HUMPREYSMITH
C Cotchin Bolton CHOL
HF COLLIER-DAWKINS Edwards Castagna
F Lynch Riewoldt Rioli D
R Nankervis Graham Baker
I/C Cameron-Jones, Mansell Pickett Rioli M.
Sub Houli.

Who's Collier-Dawkins? Its Collier-Davies :D
 
It all depends on who’s available yet and can/can’t come up. Too early to call the full suite of changes.
 
I gather many on here didn’t watch the VFL either on livestream or live .
 
I gather many on here didn’t watch the VFL either on livestream or live .
Chol ? 11 disposals in an otherwise really ordinary 4 games. Big deal. How does that warrant a game ahead of others ?

He’s a bad karma on our team with his lack of intensity and competition. Will be de listed at years end.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I reckon most of us agree who need to be dropped if only to make a statement that they need to wake up. Ross has to be given a start as does CCJ. I read somewhere the MR picked up an injury at VFL so not sure who should replace DR or JA but perhaps someone has an idea. If the news about Grimes is true and he may miss next week then it could well be Millertime. We have to blood the kids sooner or later so with our injury problems we may as well go for broke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Will Shedda get a week?
The MRO mob said Edwards gets to a stationary position before turning his body to brace when he makes contact with player Oliver. It was determined by the MRO that the action was not unreasonable in the circumstances. No further action was taken. We seem to have won one for a change
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 users
The MRO mob said Edwards gets to a stationary position before turning his body to brace when he makes contact with player Oliver. It was determined by the MRO that the action was not unreasonable in the circumstances. No further action was taken. We seem to have won one for a change
They do realise he plays for Richmond?
MRO going soft
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users