Callum Coleman-Judas - extricate yourself to Nth Ballarat, you git

[zippadeee]

Jeez man CCJ to PSD and we get nothing...........thats bad for footy

Only a *smile* of a bloke would do that.
If he went into the PsD.
He would be boooooed every minute he would play against us.
He would make The Adam Goodes booing feel controlled.
These nobody footballers who think they're worth more.
*smile* him off to GC for Anderson

 

[Sintiger]

You could pick a team of ex Collingwood players from that period.
Noel Lovell,
wally Lovell,
the Consendine brothers and Rod Oborne as part of the Alan Edwards deal
John Mrakov
John Hummel
Terry Keays
Aaron James
Neil Peart
Bob Heard

About the only decent footballer we got from that lot, and only briefly was Neil Pearl until a.coaching change I think from memory to Paul Sproule saw him and Jimmy Jess, both CHB's out of favour

Great list

Hummel started at Richmond and went to Collingwood

 

[Dont Argue]

These nobody footballers who think they're worth more.
*smile* him off to GC for Anderson

How about you show the bloke some loyalty if you expect it in return?
He’s a Richmond man. Until he’s not

 

[taraba]

Jeez man CCJ to PSD and we get nothing...........thats bad for footy

I don’t even get why we still have this draft. It serves no purpose. With free agency, the rookie draft and the ability to pick up delisted free agents etc… what is the actual value of this? You only ever get a small handful of players picked up in it anyway. It’s rubbish.

 

[zippadeee]

How about you show the bloke some loyalty if you expect it in return?
He’s a Richmond man. Until he’s not

Im booing him now.
He was offered a contract in july, the club increased it and he still hasn't signed it.
Booooooooo

 

[daniel30]

Im booing him now.
He was offered a contract in july, the club increased it and he still hasn't signed it.
Booooooooo

If that's the case we'll last years incident will have no impact.

 

[jokershoppe]

I like CCJ,and he's got to be thinking with Soldo back,how do I fit into Richmond with a 50 goal 3rd forward in Caddy made obsolete.
T71 from memory said he wanted fair compo for Richmond,which would fit his personality remembering he was Sth Australian Captain.

 

[King Kong]

How about you show the bloke some loyalty if you expect it in return?
He’s a Richmond man. Until he’s not

We've had 3 years of being loyal, particularly after Kebab gate. About time he showed some in return.

 

[zippadeee]

We've had 3 years of being loyal, particularly after Kebab gate. About time he showed some in return.

Hullaluya
Trade and get something we need.
Miller looked ok.
Soldo is back
And we should've had Allen instead of Huggins.
This all gets back to the 2017 draft.

 

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

On loyalty, he's been left to rot in the reserves when another club may have shown faith and given him a shot ahead of the loper. No guarantees he gets played next year either. Another club may be showing more enthusiasm and he's considering it.

 

[Dont Argue]

Im booing him now.
He was offered a contract in july, the club increased it and he still hasn't signed it.
Booooooooo

You’d better hope he doesn’t sign then and make you look like a fool

 

[Dont Argue]

We've had 3 years of being loyal, particularly after Kebab gate. About time he showed some in return.

Bet you said the same about Dusty when he took his sweet time to sign his contract.

 

[jb03]

On loyalty, he's been left to rot in the reserves when another club may have shown faith and given him a shot ahead of the loper. No guarantees he gets played next year either. Another club may be showing more enthusiasm and he's considering it.

Not rotting, learning.

 

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

Learning to rot. Dimma used to say that players stuck in the VFL learn to be VFL players.

 

[MalenyTiger]

I don't buy the lacked opportunity argument. Why did Chol get the green light ahead of him this year? Many would argue (and obviously the selectors agreed) that Chol showed better form at VFL level. I reckon there's a spot for him at the Tigers but he needs to grab his opportunity when it arrives. Sure, gold coast may play him more often in the short term next year but will that be a better outcome success-wise? I doubt it. He needs to consider his long term future ATM not just next season.

 

[Aegean Tiger]

Always have been dubious about the benefits of a ruck/forward or forward/ruck position in AFL football. IMO the very best talls have clearly defined identities on the field. They are either very good rucks, KPF or KPD. So what is the true essence of CCJ....? Is he a KPD...certainly not! A KPF....don't think so. Too slow and cumbersome to be elite in that position. So then a ruck....possibly.....but we already have Nank, Soldo and young Ryan as a developing type.

Very good currency at the moment......and we need an A grade clearance machine in the guts to complement our mids!

 

[The Lurker]

Chol = Ruck/Fwd & CJ = Fwd/Ruck is what i saw in reasoning

 

[Aegean Tiger]

Chol = Ruck/Fwd & CJ = Fwd/Ruck is what i saw in reasoning

Lurks will either be A grade / elite in any one position....?

 

[jb03]

Learning to rot. Dimma used to say that players stuck in the VFL learn to be VFL players.

He only says that when he unexpectely promotes someone. Didn't seem to apply to RCD.

 

[St Kevin]

On loyalty, he's been left to rot in the reserves when another club may have shown faith and given him a shot ahead of the loper. No guarantees he gets played next year either. Another club may be showing more enthusiasm and he's considering it.

True in relation to this year. He should have been playing as soon as he was available.

Last year, CJ shot himself in the foot in that regard. I doubt the coaches’ first preference was Balta and Astbury backing up Nankervis once Soldo went down. If he doesn’t get the munchies he’s probably already a premiership player.