I think you would want him in the midfield, he has evasion & clean skills, not sure he is a two way runner so there's work to be done.Is Draper a mid or more half forward?
I think you would want him in the midfield, he has evasion & clean skills, not sure he is a two way runner so there's work to be done.Is Draper a mid or more half forward?
That question is why I’m not that high on Draper and why he’s rightly slipped in the Draft. He might be a winger in time but he’d need to lift his work rate esp running. I also don’t see the highest of competitiveness - bit of a cheap gatherer at times. Prefer Spook’s boy Murley over him and others.Is Draper a mid or more half forward?
And we used their pick they traded for us to take him.Geelong traded up for Bulldogs pick 23 to get Brown too I reckon.
Just seeing this result. Pretty shocked with our haul so far. Erasmus now gone, Alleer too.Perhaps, you never know if kids are sending signals out to stay at home, it's entirely possible. Performance wise? Maybe they see him as too uncontested but I can see a well rounded midfielder with an imposing physique & outstanding skills. If I'm Freo I'm smiling all the way to the bank, three homegrown kids including a Cerra replacement.
I think there's still some outstanding depth, Taylor, Goater, Howes, Butler & Draper.Just seeing this result. Pretty shocked with our haul so far. Erasmus now gone, Alleer too.
Keen on Johnson but don’t see how we get him.
Fejo a must. Butler?
They’ll throw rhe kitchen sink at trying to get Johnson so I’d say 50/50 chance he gets to us.I'm with the crowd he goes to Hawks.
Time will tell
Have you seen him play? He was always going 1st round.On Brown and taking a back flanker in the top 20....
Its a safe bet. Too safe.
Feel like we should have aimed for elite A class.
We've seen how important it is to have a well rounded team - but we've got that and can top it up each year.
But Superstars are also needed.
It was time for a high stakes pick.
Barry Gibcus gives us an elite defender.
We could've aimed for a starting centre square onballer.
Hope with our last pick its on the wildest small we can find - Ronny Fejo maybe?
I.m with you on this Pman, though I'd go Sonz first.Still reckon with the players on the board I'd be looking at trading up and around. I want either Sonsie or MacDonald (as think Johnson is off the radar), both suit is very well and a lot of the other players have question marks. I'd be happy with sliding a bit further back to get what we want.
If we can't get Norths pick 22, the Hawks pick 26 is what I'd be after to get 1 of them, preferably MacDonald, reckon he's the best pure mid left in the draft (maybe Johnson too).
Sonsie / Butler / Draper / Tayler - Probably 1 of them, all can start at half forward
Bazzo - Maybe, do we need another tall with next year being a talls draft
Knevitt / Roberts - Don't want
Goater - Poor kick, this could hold him back significantly
Is MacDonald’s kicking good enough ?
Both deserve scrutiny.Seems ok, whats wrong with it? Are you asking the same of Goater?
Do you think Johnson/Sonsie/MacDonald/Taylor can't be better than any of those 3?No point picking a mid if he isn’t better than Dow, RCD or Martyn.
I.m with you on this Pman, though I'd go Sonz first.
Sonsie by trade
Hope Macca is available. If not Taylor or Draper (think Butler will be gone)
Then Fejo or Artie Jones!
Do you think Johnson/Sonsie/MacDonald/Taylor can't be better than any of those 3?
Makes a lot of sense Bob.I'm not disappointed.
He is 186cm. Some on here are saying he's 184.
Cal Twomey had him going at the next pick to Sydney, so clearly he was in the range of picks in most drafts.
We havent got a power running, speedy, good sized half back that runs all day. Bachar retired.
It tells me we like Stack (if he makes it), up forward. We like Liam Baker to help with midfield rotations. And we arent sure about Daniel at half back. Personally, I'd put Daniel up for trade to help us get Taranto next year.
For those saying you dont pick defenders and half backs with 1st round picks, Brisbane picked Wilmot before us and GWS picked Alleer with pick 15.
Melbourne needed 2 1st round picks for Lever didnt they?