2006 Player of the year | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2006 Player of the year

Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

3. Hyde
2. Pettifer
1. Simmonds

To finally beat Geelong at Kittylitter Park and have 3 of our less heralded players as best is fantastic.
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

3. Pettifer
2. Hyde
1. Cogs
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

3- Pettifer

2- Simmonds

1- Coughlan

I'd have preferred to give 6 votes of 1 this week. :spin

Hyde, Tambling, Polo, Newman, Kellaway even P.Bowden did well. Maybe 16 getting 1/2 vote. ;D
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.


3. Hyde
2. Krakouer
1. Tambling

... apologies Simmonds ! ;D
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

PlayerRd 9Total
Richardson 512
Simmonds110461
Raines 429
Polo 2235
Hyde125224
Bowden J 203
Pettifer82154
Tuck 132
Deledio 124
Foley 108
Coughlan23101
Bowden P 100
Tivendale 98
Kellaway 92
Tambling 4076
Newman 355
Krakouer455
Hartigan 48
Johnson 48
Thursfield 33
Brown 24
Hall114
Jackson 9
Stafford 8
Roach 3
Pattison 2
Hughes 1
Meyer 1
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

Thanks Tiggy. :)

I'm surprised Joel is so far behind. He'd have to be pretty good odds to take Jack home again at this stage.
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

rosy23 said:
Thanks Tiggy. :)

I'm surprised Joel is so far behind. He'd have to be pretty good odds to take Jack home again at this stage.
Click to expand...
Hi Rosy how did Bowdo go in the PRE award last year out of interest?

Seems to me the likes of J. Bowden and Newman don't seem to do that well in the PRE award. I'm not so sure why. Seems as established defenders they don't get much credit for their work. Here anyway.
Perhaps that's because expectations for them are so high and they deliver in unspectacular fashion every week. it takes something exceptional for them to stand out.

Also I think we as supporters seems vote the underdog or the youngster ahead of our more established players (Richo aside).

I think those that make the decisions regarding the JDM might see things a bit differently to how the supporters do.

Personally I'd like to see 5 votes given each week. Because I think some on the fringe of vote getting sometimes get left out.
 
Re: Player of the year 2006 [Merged]

Raines is an absolute revelation this season. Sheer hard work and a determination to learn under coach Wallace.

Keep at it son...... you are a sheer joy to watch :clapping
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

Tigers of Old said:
Hi Rosy how did Bowdo go in the PRE award last year out of interest?

Seems to me the likes of J. Bowden and Newman don't seem to do that well in the PRE award. I'm not so sure why. Seems as established defenders they don't get much credit for their work. Here anyway.

.....Personally I'd like to see 5 votes given each week. Because I think some on the fringe of vote getting sometimes get left out.
Click to expand...

We weren't that far out ToO.

2005 PRE Player of the Year results

Tuck - 1337
Richardson - 991
Coughlan - 842
Bowden - 547
Brown - 546
Deledio - 412
Gaspar - 407
Newman - 380
Johnson - 319
Hyde - 285

2005 Jack Dyer Medal results

1st: Joel Bowden 221
2nd: Matthew Richardson 220
3rd: Shane Tuck 197
4th: Darren Gaspar 184
5th: Mark Coughlan 172
6th: Chris Newman 171
7th: Kane Johnson 147
8th: Wayne Campbell 141
9th: Troy Simmonds 140
10th: Nathan Brown 129

We had a discussion on the forum about different voting systems.  We've been pretty spot on most years and have selected the winner some years.  Might be a bit different this year with us rewarding kids for their efforts, as shown with Polo coming 4th this year and Lids making our top 10 last year but not the coaches top 10.

The 5 vote system would make a lot of extra work for Tiggy or me or whoever counts the votes and it's a pretty time consuming job already.
 
Re: Player of The Year Round 9 vs Cats.

rosy23 said:
Tigers of Old said:
We had a discussion on the forum about different voting systems. We've been pretty spot on most years and have selected the winner some years. Might be a bit different this year with us rewarding kids for their efforts, as shown with Polo coming 4th this year and Lids making our top 10 last year but not the coaches top 10.

The 5 vote system would make a lot of extra work for Tiggy or me or whoever counts the votes and it's a pretty time consuming job already.
Click to expand...
Thanks for posting that Rosy.
Obviously I appreciate the work Tiggy and yourself do BTS. Am happy to leave it as it is.
Click to expand...
 
Round 10 player of the year votes vs Freo.

3-Coughlan
2-P Bowden
1-Tuck.

A big :clap to all of the kids. Polo very impressive and a promising debut by Matty.
 
Re: Round 10 player of the year votes vs Freo.

3. Cogs
2. Tuck
1. Hyde


Special mention to young Peake for Freo who played very well for them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< The useless, too much time on my hands, alternative B&F votes | 2005 Player of the year >
Official PRE merch now on Redbubble!
Top Bottom