He's solid, proper tough, not sniper tough, good overhead as well, and a solid kick, within his limits.
It can't hurt to develop him a little more, more strings to his bow the better.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Training
- Thread starter caesar
- Start date
It can't hurt to develop him a little more, more strings to his bow the better.
Tony Braxton-Hicks
There are no stupid ideas, just stupid people
Broad could certainly match KMac's physicality but would be a bonus as extra aerial cover when dropping back into defence. No need for him to finesse his kicks: just belt it long and straight like Brando and we've lost nothing.
Definitely has the skill set to play on the fat side of the ground as a defensive winger
I agree. Broad was fantastic last year doing the versatile, reliable defensive stopper (Grimes) role allowing Grimes to do the Rance role. Still need that in 2020 as far as I can tell!
He’s always looked like a wingman playing defensive to me. Broady would make any position his own.
Griggy played ruck in the GF.
So where did I apologise to you? Why on earth would I need to? Go back over my posts. I've always maintained that Noah's instincts as a footballer seem to be much more to attack and be aggressive than play defensively. Still true - which is what was implied by these words in my prior post - "... and Noah gets to develop gradually at his own rate well enough to step into the side wherever needed."
I also maintained that he might become a KPD and Rance's replacement long-term, when Alex the Great was finished. Maybe you haven't heard but that looks to have happened much earlier than expected. Hence, my post follows with - " ... he is now the long-term young player with the most potential (IMHO) to fill the shoes of the great man eventually."
See how I even said 'eventually.' You were calling for him to take over CHB all last year, before Alex even considered retiring. There's a long way to go before he should be expected to take the best opposition KFs yet, on an ongoing, regular basis. But he will be tried in rotations and the club will be watching his progress carefully. I spoke about him in the context of if we cop any more injuries to our KPDs - Dave or Grimesy; not expecting NB to waltz into taking one of these roles overnight. There's also Garth, but I think Noah has greater talent, and size, to make an A-grader possibly - over few years.
Nothing inconsistent in what I've posted, so stop being a peanut.
Last edited:
1000% it wont happen.
Collingwood would rather delist 10 players rather lose Degoey & Moore.
Have you noticed, DeGoey returned from the summer break looking like Arthur Dunger. And the club didn’t fine or punish him???
My favourite posters on PRE for a laugh
3 votes, EzYt, AKA eZyT
2 votes Zipper
1 vote Leon (chill mate, it's only an internet forum)
