Shane Mumford

[poppa x]

Just announed that the big mummy is out for the rest of the season.

Top 4 opens up a tad.

 

[The_General]

How crappy must Giles be feeling. Can't get a game at Essendrugs, but could be playing finals at GWS.

 

[WesternTiger]

Another supercoach trade down the toilet!

 

[Tigerfan]

How crappy must Giles be feeling. Can't get a game at Essendrugs, but could be playing finals at GWS.

I have no doubt geelong will replace GWS in the top 8 by finals time.

 

[St Kevin]

Davis also out for 6-8. Puts finals in jeopardy.

 

[BrisTiger24]

Davis also out for 6-8. Puts finals in jeopardy.

They are following a similar trajectory to the Suns last year. Top 4 chances mid year then injuries to key players and then likely miss finals altogether.

 

[Tigerfan]

Daisy out for the season!
Great tackle Lids!
Watch the blues start sending it's players in for surgery and throwing the farm at Dangerfield.
It's 2007 again.

 

[Tigers of Old]

Wasn't it McIntosh that tackled Daisy?

 

[CarnTheTiges]

They are following a similar trajectory to the Suns last year. Top 4 chances mid year then injuries to key players and then likely miss finals altogether.

It is very similar. I think the GWS will fall away from this point on. The difference between them and the Suns is that they were a one man team and once that player went down so did their season.

 

[tigertim]

How crappy must Giles be feeling. Can't get a game at Essendrugs, but could be playing finals at GWS.

Yep, its been a career killing move for Giles.

Who are the other rucks for GWS. Phillips?

 

[Tigertool]

Yep, its been a career killing move for Giles.

Who are the other rucks for GWS. Phillips?

It'll be Phillips or Lobb.

 

[Razorgang2]

Wasn't it McIntosh that tackled Daisy?

Lids in the first contest of the first quarter.

 

[waiting]

Think it might have been Macattack that tackled Daisy?

GWS chances slim now. The big mummy has been great for them this year. Top 4 opens up for someone to take now.

GWS have two young rucks and they are raw. Giles would be thinking why I left. Hird doesn't think his form is good enough so they take Carlisle out from their forward structure and is their ruckman and Bellchambers is out of form? Didn't Mckernan go to the Dons ?

 

[Tigertool]

Lids in the first contest of the first quarter.

Lids was the bump on Simon White in the first 7 seconds, Daisy tackle was McIntosh.

 

[Baloo]

Yeah, GoPro's first involvement in AFL footy was to put Daisy out for a season. Nearly better than kicking a goal wiith your first touch

 

[tigertim]

Think it might have been Macattack that tackled Daisy?

GWS chances slim now. The big mummy has been great for them this year. Top 4 opens up for someone to take now.

GWS have two young rucks and they are raw. Giles would be thinking why I left. Hird doesn't think his form is good enough so they take Carlisle out from their forward structure and is their ruckman and Bellchambers is out of form? Didn't Mckernan go to the Dons ?

There has been quiet murmurings re Giles and Essendon. Apparently "they" dont think he's mobile enough and too much of an old style ruckman so they aren't keen on playing him.

Which begs the obvious question......

 

[Razorgang2]

Lids was the bump on Simon White in the first 7 seconds, Daisy tackle was McIntosh.

So it was, sorry about that.

 

[wayne]

Thanks for keeping our top 4 spot warm GWS >

 

[Willo]

Think it might have been Macattack that tackled Daisy?

GWS chances slim now. The big mummy has been great for them this year. Top 4 opens up for someone to take now.

GWS have two young rucks and they are raw. Giles would be thinking why I left. Hird doesn't think his form is good enough so they take Carlisle out from their forward structure and is their ruckman and Bellchambers is out of form? Didn't Mckernan go to the Dons ?

Mckernan's on the rookie list.

 

[Tames]

Massive loss, Mummy's a beast, but their mids are so good they will still make the 8 you'd think.