It was also a lazy comparison.I think the constant comparison to Buddy from media and supporters would have had an impact on him mentally as well. The pressure to perform and live up to being drafted ahead of him was there throughout his career
There are so many factors that go into the drafting of a particular player, including, obviously, the club's needs at the time.
While I know the Tigers were heavily into Roughie, the fact is we had a very good forward line in 2004 but an average midfield.
Solid but limited players like Hyde, Fleming, Hartigan and Fiora were getting plenty of midfield minutes that year.
You could see why a player of Tambling's type appealed.
Not at the time nor in the years since have I thought we stuffed up the early part of that draft. I also still believe the Polo selection was defensible.
No doubt Meyer was a total bust and Pattinson a fair bust, but that draft is sometimes overstated as a debacle. It was a pretty thin draft.
Postscript: Brett Deledio to GWS gave us a first and third round pick in the 2017 draft. We bundled up those two picks (#15 and #54 -- Zac Bailey and Jack Payne) for Brisbane's #20 and #25 picks (CCJ and Noah Balta). The 2004 draft lives on!