Josh Caddy

[Scoop]

Deserved 2 to 3.

We'll take the week and run.

Rubbish, challenge it.

 

[MB78]

Rubbish, challenge it.

I would also be providing the cash for a challenge. The intent was the ball. Open hand, just a playing accident.

 

[seven]

I would also be providing the cash for a challenge. The intent was the ball. Open hand, just a playing accident.

We'll loose the challenge.
All about protecting the head
Accidentally or purpose, doesn't matter.
He made contact with the head.
Take the 1 week.

 

[zippadeee]

We'll loose the challenge.
All about protecting the head
Accidentally or purpose, doesn't matter.
He made contact with the head.
Take the 1 week.

The suspension dosent increase if you fail.
Challenger's ready
Gladiator's ready
GO

 

[Mr Brightside]

I would also be providing the cash for a challenge. The intent was the ball. Open hand, just a playing accident.

Agree MB . Interesting to see if we do challenge , I think the fact Mackay got concussion means we have no chance to get off.

 

[Brodders17]

im not sure about others, but if i am trying to stop someone passing over my head i tend to lift my arms over my head rather than swing a roundhouse.
no chance he will get off.

 

[MD Jazz]

im not sure about others, but if i am trying to stop someone passing over my head i tend to lift my arms over my head rather than swing a roundhouse.
no chance he will get off.

Yeh, funny sort of a block. Rarely see it in basketball (a bloke knocked out) yet they are attempting the block the ball all the time.

Caddy knew what he was doing .

 

[rocsta75]

Heaps saying to challenge but no one has provided anything solid on the basis. Can challenge medium impact cause player did not come back leaving only was it acccidental or careless. As pointed out a block is not a swing of the arm so I think careless will stay. Save the 10k cause I think their is little chance he could get it downgraded

 

[artball]

there is no challenge in it, Caddy was careless and he collected the guy in the head by swinging his arm in the weirdest 'block' i've seen.

 

[fastin bulbous]

Looked like he was trying to knock the ball from the players hands rather than block

 

[easy_tiger]

Looked like he was trying to knock the ball from the players hands rather than block

Ive got no doubt he wasnt trying to hit the bloke in the head, but I reckon a week for clumsiness is about right

 

[year of the tiger]

We will miss Caddy as he is one of our form players atm.

Take the week as I can’t see it being reversed .

This opens up a spot for Higgens to debut.

 

[Tigers of Old]

Disappointing the club accepted the 1 match ban.

 

[Total Tiger]

It's the right decision. He might not have meant it but he got a bloke concussed. It's careless but still worthy of a week.

 

[year of the tiger]

It's the right decision. He might not have meant it but he got a bloke concussed. It's careless but still worthy of a week.

.


Agree can’t argue the decision - the bloke was concussed and couldn’t finish the game

 

[UKTiger]

We certainly are a far better side when Josh is included. He brings so much to the side with his awareness, hardness, strength and running

 

[waiting]

And can take a contested mark too!

 

[TigerForce]

Woke up in the 2nd half.

 

[taraba]

We’re a better side when he plays. No doubt about it.

 

[Ridley]

Woke up in the 2nd half.

Yep terrible first half but sensational in second half. I was concerned he was still injured in first half.