Jack Dyer 2015 Top 10 PRE-Dictions

[Smoking Aces]

With the Brownlow over who do you think will win the Jack Dyer medal and the remaining top 10?

Here is my prediction-

Winner - D. Martin

2. A. Rance
3. T. Cotchin
4. J. Riewoldt
5. B. Deledio
6. A. Miles
7. B. Houli
8. S. Edwards
9. B. Ellis
10. T. Chaplin

 

[22nd Man]

I would think Grigg in top 10, Ellis not

 

[Tigerfan]

When is the JDM?

 

[taztiger4]

When is the JDM?

Next Tuesday 6th Oct

 

[Rancey18]

1 D Martin
2 A Rance
3 T Cotchin
4 A Miles
5 J Riewoldt
6 B Deledio
7 B Houli
8 B Ellis
9 S Edwards
10 S Grigg

 

[caspar]

1 rance
2 Martin
3 cotchin
4 lids
5 jack
6 Houli
7 miles
8 Ellis
9 Grigg

10 kamdyn



Can't remember how long sheds was doing his thing for. I guess not enough of the season to make top 10?

We'll see.

 

[St Kevin]

1. Rance
2. Martin
3. Jack
4. Cotchin
5. Deledio
6. Grigg
7. Miles
8. Houli
9. Ellis
10. Edwards

 

[waiting]

My top 10 would be!

Rance
Dusty
Cotchin
Jack
Miles
Grigg
Deleido
Ellis
Houli
Edwards

Rance should win his first!

Anyone going?
Wanted to go but apparently sold out?

 

[spook]

1. Rance
2. Martin
3. Riewoldt
4. Cotchin
5. Miles
6. Grigg
7. Houli
8. Ellis
9. Vlastuin
10. Hunt

 

[mrposhman]

1. Rance
2. Martin
3. Jack
4. Cotchin
5. Deledio
6. Miles
7. Grigg
8. Houli
9. Ellis
10. Edwards

 

[poppa x]

1. Martin
2. Rance
3. Cotchin
4. Riewoldt
5. Miles
6. Grigg
7. Houli
8. Ellis
9. Edwards
10. Chaplin

 

[Scoop]

Can't fathom people leaving Edwards outside the top 10. Even with injuries.

The finals donut has fooled a lot of people.

 

[St Kevin]

Can't fathom people leaving Edwards outside the top 10. Even with injuries.

The finals donut has fooled a lot of people.

Missed a few games during the season, which counts against you with the voting system.

 

[Baloo]

Missed a few games during the season, which counts against you with the voting system.

Agree, the votin system rewards those who play more games

 

[spook]

Can't fathom people leaving Edwards outside the top 10. Even with injuries.

The finals donut has fooled a lot of people.

I left him and Lids out on games missed. Votes per game, they're both top 4.

 

[Rancey18]

Missed a few games during the season, which counts against you with the voting system.

Yep, I fell for it last year with Rance, Lids and Miles thinking they would finish a lot higher than they ended up doing.

 

[dcstar]

Agree, the voting system rewards those who play more games

IIRC our system is based on how well a player performs his assigned "role" during a game, so a player may get bugger-all stats but do exactly what the coaches wanted and score well even though most outside observers don't think he played well.

For that reason I'd be surprised if Vlastuin is not in the top 5.

 

[Smoking Aces]

IIRC our system is based on how well a player performs his assigned "role" during a game, so a player may get bugger-all stats but do exactly what the coaches wanted and score well even though most outside observers don't think he played well.

For that reason I'd be surprised if Vlastuin is not in the top 5.

I agree. I completely forgot about Vlastuin when doing my top 10. He will feature definitely.

 

[caspar]

Funny that. I forgot about V too.

Somewhere around 8th?

As for sheds he plays all year how he did at the start , he'd be 3 - 5.

 

[tigerlove]

Interesting so many picking Rance to win. PRE usually gets pretty close in the vote thread and Rance is only 3th. We voted Martin by the length of the straight followed by, Cotchin Rance, Edwards, Reiwoldt.