It wasn't my intention to post again on this thread, but so many folks have shown the courtesy to respond to my initial post that I feel I need to clarify a few things.
Firstly, at no point did I criticise the negativity of posters as such ... only the "sameness" of the negativity. My point about suspicion of multiple pseudonyms for a single poster was really just an illustration of how similar many of the posts have become.
Secondly, I believe every Richmond player warrants continual critical appraisal, from Campbo to the rookies to the coaching group to the admin ... nobody's immune, but surely saturation point can be reached in shooting off at the lip for some individuals. I just felt some posters have exceeded this saturation point for way too long for it to be interesting anymore.
Thirdly, I certainly didn't mention anything about personal abuse. There is very little, if any, serious personal abuse on this board. And when it does pop up, well, folks can simply ignore it, or respond appropriately, or whatever they like. There seems to be a bit of an unwritten law amongst us here on that sort of thing anyway. I'm pretty much of the opinion that you can call me whatever you like ... Hell, I'm a Tiger supporter - I'm used to copping petty abuse!!
Finally, I can't remember who posted it (It was on the first page), but they questioned whether I was happy with the Tiger's progress etc .. To that I'll answer of course not. Every weekend I expend way way too much emotional energy on the result of the Tigers games, and until I experience another Tiger premiership, I will never be truly satisfied with the performance of one of my great loves in life ... the Richmond Footy Club.