-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Dayle Garrlet or Dom tyson?
- Thread starter tigertom0108
- Start date
Barnzy said:
Leysy never said Rohan was a positive (though it will in time injury permitting), was more pointing out that clubs that love grunt more than most will still take class & flair when the get the chance.
Baloo said:
Surely X-Factor are simply guys who can produce things that most can't.
Why do they automatically need to not be inconsistent over there career as well? i.e. Guys like Jetta, Dangerfield, Steve Johnson etc are X factor players that are now consistent footballers...
Sorry leysy doesnt understand your pidgeon hole.
We have X factor midfielders than can kick goals lots of teams don't have that! We have Riewoldt Vickery King Edwards Nahas all goal kickers supplement that with Cotchin Martin Deledio Tuck Foley Grigg!
All the class players have X factor.
The only two factors to be considered are whether there's a concrete option of Garlett at 9 compared to offering 9 for Tyson.
First no guarantee for Garlett to be there so first and logical choice would be to chase Tyson with 9.
Second and most important isn't X factor it's character. Is one player an honest, diisciplined, hard working person who shares into a team environment? Is the other person a self indulgent, flighty, egotistical troublemaker?
Don't know the players, only whats been written up in the media and internet forums. From what I've read the talent of both seems on a par.
Then it's just a matter of do you go for the Cotchin type character or the Ebola type character.
The only two factors to be considered are whether there's a concrete option of Garlett at 9 compared to offering 9 for Tyson.
First no guarantee for Garlett to be there so first and logical choice would be to chase Tyson with 9.
Second and most important isn't X factor it's character. Is one player an honest, diisciplined, hard working person who shares into a team environment? Is the other person a self indulgent, flighty, egotistical troublemaker?
Don't know the players, only whats been written up in the media and internet forums. From what I've read the talent of both seems on a par.
Then it's just a matter of do you go for the Cotchin type character or the Ebola type character.
Garlett v Tyson is a hard question to answer.
Different types, apples v oranges. Very much like Cotchin v Rioli in 2007.
We certainly could do with one of each.
Logically:
We do have a Cotchin type -> Cotchin.
We don't have a Rioli type though.
Hmmm, good question!
Different types, apples v oranges. Very much like Cotchin v Rioli in 2007.
We certainly could do with one of each.
Logically:
We do have a Cotchin type -> Cotchin.
We don't have a Rioli type though.
Hmmm, good question!
blx said:
Why is X-factor a risk? Just because a couple haven't worked out in the past doesn't mean they'll never work out. I'd say the opposite is true, especially given the new pro approach of the tiges. Lessons learnt.
As for DT v DG, I reckon they'll both be absolute champs.
its very risky giving up more than pick 9, for young tyson, has we will be facing a mouth watering talent choice for a young gun, who will at a minimum be a good player, if not a star, just like tyson
The X-factor reared it's head against GC so I can understand the cold sweats everytime it's mentioned. But on a serious note, Garlett has had numerous issues relating to attitude which will see him marked pretty harshly - missing training, not playing a team game, being a bit of a night owl. Given our issues with Connors et al, I reckon we'll go the safe route with our first pick. If we get another mid teens pick and Garlett is on the board, I'd say we might be tempted, it's a big call but one which could pay off in spades.
mad_doggy911 said:
Quite possible, I'm sure if they are interested they'll be coaching him on how to give the perfect bum steer interview - perhaps another media Darling in the making.
would like to think the likes of Blair and co will soon, if not already, started to get the Tyson to Richmond project underway for the 2014 season.
If we get this year's draft right, I'd be happy for us to "risk" an "x-factor" player in next year's draft
But not this year's draft and not at the expense of Tyson
But not this year's draft and not at the expense of Tyson
<
Top 10 predicitions?
|
Ruckman
>
