One of the all time funniest threads.
Maybe the real treasure was the friends we made along the way
One of the all time funniest threads.
Isnt Glen Luff the goose from champion data.The other issue here is it looks like we’re dealing with a moron in this Glenn Luff. All this chest beating talk from a club that survives on equalisation. What a garbage organisation.
Because if Tarrant moves to us as a free agent it *smile* with our compo pick for Cholly. We'll be in negotiation with # lonorf to manufacture a trade deal to try and ensure we get something reasonable for Cujo, while " paying " minimum chips for Tarrant and also keeping pick 38 from Cholly leaving.I don't understand Chol goes to GC.
Kelly goes to Essendon.
Why hasn't Tarrant moved?
One is 24 and the other 32.Because if Tarrant moves to us as a free agent it *smile* with our compo pick for Cholly. We'll be in negotiation with # lonorf to manufacture a trade deal to try and ensure we get something reasonable for Cujo, while " paying " minimum chips for Tarrant and also keeping pick 38 from Cholly leaving.
If Tarrant comes to us for free, then the Cholly pick might become 50 something instead n I'm pretty sure we'll then b thoroughly pissed at our list managers and the AFL honchos.
Won't cancel each other out but knowing the AFL they'll find an excuse to push it back after realising belatedly that they were far to generous giving us pick 38 when we already have a shitload of picks this year even though we've earned all our picks.One is 24 and the other 32.
How could the AFL use that to cancel each other out?
So your saying pick 39 + Cj
For pick 20 + Tarrant?
But The North bloke said no chance with pick 20.
Yeah, Luff still thinks he’s playing SuperCoachIsnt Glen Luff the goose from champion data.
Kingy and Healys love child
Yeah... I reckon you're right... they'll wheel out the Nank trade then that *smile* stick Cornes will bang on about us whinging for the next three weeks. ...Luff reckons pick 38 is about right for CJ. He stated that this is what rucks and forwards historically go for.
Not sure what history he is basing it on. There aren't too many that Ruck/Forwards that leave clubs where they are wanted and valued that are wanted..... Nank is probably best comparison I could find.
Nank was drafted at 35.... played 12 games in 3 years.... and reluctantly traded for pick 46.... He knocked back a 2 year contract with Swans to sign a 3 year deal at Tigers.
I don't understand Chol goes to GC.
Kelly goes to Essendon.
Why hasn't Tarrant moved?
Fingers crossed North don't back door us.We will trade for him, rather than FA
You half-empty glass. I think it was a great theoretical discussion. Einstein would have been proud of us.What a waste of internet disk space that CJ v Chol debate turned out to be.
Interesting isn't it. I think we became a great team not because of our best draft picks (other than the obvious they've had limited success) but the unbelievable success we've had with picking up role/fringe players with low and alternate draft picks.Fingers crossed North don't back door us.
If Cj goes into the pre-season
Draft
That will be 3 top 20 picks down the drain
Higgins Ellis and now Cj
Not sure that is necessarily correct. Otherwise they could just do the same thing with CCJ. North would need to willingly delist Tarrant to allow him to be picked up that way - just like we would have to delist CCJ for them to do similar with him (which wont happen - either we trade him or he goes to the PSD).We can also pick Tarrant as a delisted free agent. This will happen after list lodgement.
When n0rt is cutting their list down, they have to cut however hasn’t signed a contract for the next year. Whether that’s after 1st, 2nd or 3rd list lodgment. If he becomes a delisted free agent, then our Chol pick will not be affected.
There is still a bit to play out with Tarrant. He doesn’t have to be part of any trade.
And we keep the Chol compo pick unchanged. Not ideal but reasonable IMOI suspect this will be done relatively easily and early this week.
CJ and a future 4th for Pick 39 and Tarrant.
CJ is worth more than 39, Tarrant is worth more than a future 4th, so balance them out within the trade and move on to other trades.
The Chol pick can not be affected one way or the other. Chol is gone and pick 38 is ours.And we keep the Chol compo pick unchanged. Not ideal but reasonable IMO